Abstract: In recent years, there is an increasing demand for unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) to complete multiple applications. However, as unmanned equipments, UAVs lead to some security risks to general civil aviations. In order to strengthen the flight management of UAVs and guarantee the safety, UAVs can be equipped with automatic dependent surveillance-broadcast (ADS-B) devices. In addition, as an automatic system, ADS-B can periodically broadcast flight information to the nearby aircrafts or the ground stations, and the technology is already used in civil aviation systems. However, due to the limited frequency of ADS-B technique, UAVs equipped with ADS-B devices result in the loss of packets to both UAVs and civil aviation. Further, the operation of civil aviation are seriously interfered. Hence, this paper firstly examines the packets loss of civil planes at different distance, then analyzes the impact of UAVs equipped with ADS-B on the packets updating of civil planes. The result indicates that the 1090MHz band blocking is affected by the density of UAVs. Besides, the frequency capacity is affected by the requirement of updating interval of civil planes. The position updating probability within 3s is 92.3% if there are 200 planes within 50km and 20 UAVs within 5km. The position updating probability within 3s is 86.9% if there are 200 planes within 50km and 40 UAVs within 5km.
Introduction
As the sky gets crowded with Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs), the 1090 MHz frequency band—the backbone of civil aviation's ADS-B monitoring system—is reaching its capacity limits. Automatic Dependent Surveillance-Broadcast (ADS-B) is the "digital heartbeat" of modern aviation, where aircraft periodically broadcast their position, velocity, and ID. This allows other planes and ground stations to track them without relying solely on traditional radar.
However, the 1090 MHz band uses a "random access" protocol (ALOHA), meaning if too many devices transmit simultaneously, their signals collide and become unreadable. As thousands of UAVs are integrated into the low-altitude economy for delivery and rescue, many are being equipped with ADS-B for safety. This paper simulates how increasing drone density causes packet collisions and signal interference, potentially "blinding" air traffic controllers to manned aircraft by dropping position update probabilities below critical safety thresholds.
Methods
The researchers developed a discrete-event simulation using a 3D airspace model to analyze these effects.
Key components of the methodology include:
- Airspace Modeling: A cylindrical volume with a 100km diameter for civil aircraft and a smaller 10km diameter "inner circle" for UAVs, centered around a Ground Station (GS).
- Protocol Simulation: The model utilizes the ALOHA random access protocol. To mitigate repeated collisions, a "shaking interval" was implemented—a slight randomization of the broadcast period.
- Physical Layer Realism: The study accounts for Free Space Path Loss and the bit error rate (BER) associated with 8-PSK modulation, allowing for Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR) calculations based on distance.
- Packet Diversity: Six different types of ADS-B messages (Position, Velocity, ID, etc.) were simulated, each with distinct transmission frequencies.
The simulation generated synthetic traffic data based on ICAO standards and S-mode extended squitter specifications, testing scenarios with 50 to 200 civil aircraft and 0 to 40 UAVs.
Key Results and Insights
The simulation revealed several critical insights regarding the degradation of monitoring performance as drone density increases.
The Distance Penalty and UAV Interference
Packet loss is driven by both physical signal attenuation and channel collisions. As shown in Figure 4, the received ratio for both planes and UAVs drops sharply as distance from the ground station increases. At 50km, signal attenuation and interference can lead to a packet loss rate as high as 60%, even before accounting for significant UAV traffic.
UAVs act as significant "noise" generators. Despite transmitting at lower power (1W vs. 25W for planes), their high density in localized areas increases the collision probability for the entire channel.
Safety Thresholds and Packet Loss
Air traffic control requires a position update within a specific timeframe—typically 3 seconds for terminal areas. The simulation results indicate:
- Baseline: With 200 planes and zero UAVs, the 3-second update probability is 97.8%.
- Drone Impact: Adding 20 UAVs to the 200-plane scenario drops this probability to 92.3%. Increasing to 40 UAVs further reduces it to 86.9%.
- Consecutive Loss: The introduction of 40 UAVs caused instances where 16 or more packets were lost consecutively, potentially making an aircraft invisible for over 8 seconds.
Conclusion
The results suggest that the 1090 MHz band is nearing saturation, highlighting the need for alternative frequencies or more advanced MAC protocols for the burgeoning drone industry. Future work should address channel complexities like multipath fading and weather interference, as well as investigate adaptive power control for UAVs to minimize interference while maintaining civil aviation safety.
Summary updated