Impact of Skin Tone and Cupping on Erythema and Thermal Imaging Measurements

Kathleen S. Jordan, Glory Tomi John, Andrew Chung, Miriam Asare-Baiden, Vicki Hertzberg, Joyce C. Ho, Sharon Eve SonenblumResearch Square 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study demonstrates that while visual and colorimetric assessments of skin redness (erythema) are highly dependent on a patient's skin tone, thermal imaging provides a consistent, objective measure of underlying tissue stress. The findings suggest that thermography can bridge the gap in pressure injury detection for patients with darker skin tones, where traditional visual cues are often unreliable.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Pressure injuries (PrIs)—commonly known as bedsores—are a significant clinical challenge, particularly for patients with limited mobility. The standard of care relies on visual skin assessments to find "non-blanchable erythema" (redness that doesn't turn white when pressed).

However, this "redness" is notoriously difficult to detect in darker skin tones. Consequently, Black and African American patients are statistically more likely to develop severe PrIs and experience slower healing. There is a critical need for bedside technologies that can detect early tissue damage regardless of a patient's constitutive pigmentation. While thermal imaging (thermography) has shown promise, we haven't fully understood how temperature changes correlate with redness across the full spectrum of human skin tones.

Methods

The researchers used a pre-post experimental design involving 35 healthy adult volunteers with diverse skin tones. To simulate the physiological stress that leads to pressure injuries in a controlled environment, they used cupping therapy.

  • The Stressor: A 2-inch diameter cup was applied to the lower back (posterior sacral iliac spines) at -30 kPa for 5 minutes. This induces mechanical strain and vascular responses (hyperemia and ischemia).
  • Measurement Tools:
    • Thermal Imaging: A FLIR E8-XT camera captured sacral skin temperature.
  • Colorimetry: A SkinColorCatch® digital colorimeter measured the "Erythema Index" and "Melanin Index."
  • Spatial Analysis: The team identified three concentric Regions of Interest (ROIs): the ROI Center (maximum tensile stress), the ROI Edge (compressive stress from the rim), and the Peri-ROI (adjacent healthy tissue).
  • Timeline: Measurements were taken at baseline and every minute for 7 minutes post-cupping.

Datasets

The study utilized a primary experimental dataset of 35 participants.

  • Skin Tone Classification: Participants were categorized using the Monk Skin Tone (MST) Scale and the Modified Eumelanin Human Skin Colour Scale.
  • Cohort Breakdown: 30 participants were in the "darker" group (MST 6+) and 5 in the "lighter" group (MST 1-5). The majority of the cohort (74%) identified as Black or African American.
  • Metadata: The dataset included BMI, sex, age, and smoking status to control for confounding physiological factors.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Mismatch" Phenomenon: Temperature and redness are only weakly correlated. This suggests they are driven by different physiological mechanisms. Redness (erythema) is often caused by capillary rupture and blood accumulation, while temperature changes reflect active blood flow (ischemia vs. reactive hyperemia).
  • Skin Tone Independence: Temperature changes following tissue stress were consistent across all skin tones. Whether a participant was MST 2 or MST 8, the thermal camera detected the same physiological "signature" of the injury.
  • The Inverse Response in Dark Skin: Most surprisingly, in the darkest skin tone group, the erythema index actually decreased as temperature increased post-cupping. This suggests that in very dark skin, the colorimeter may be picking up ischemic changes (decreased blood flow) rather than the typical redness seen in lighter skin.
  • Mechanical Heterogeneity: The center of the cupped area (tensile stress) showed a significant temperature drop (-0.54°C) and took 3–4 minutes to recover, while the edge (compressive stress) recovered almost instantly. This highlights how different types of mechanical strain affect tissue recovery differently.

Key Results

  • Erythema is Biased: Changes in the erythema index varied significantly across skin tone categories (p < 0.001), making it an unreliable universal metric.
  • Temperature is Objective: No significant differences in temperature change were observed across BMI, sex, or skin tone.
  • Quantitative Recovery: Immediately post-cupping, the ROI Center temperature dropped by a median of 0.54°C. It took approximately 3–4 minutes to return to baseline, whereas visual redness persisted throughout the entire 7-minute window.
  • Clinical Implication: Thermal imaging can detect "hidden" ischemic events—areas where blood flow is restricted—before permanent tissue damage or visible redness occurs.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Sample Size: The "darkest" skin tone group was relatively small, and the "lighter" group was also limited, as the study intentionally over-sampled darker tones to address the research gap.
  • Healthy Volunteers: The study used healthy adults rather than clinical patients at high risk for PrIs, whose tissue might respond differently to pressure.
  • Short Window: The 7-minute recovery period provides a snapshot, but longer-term monitoring is needed to see how these thermal signatures evolve over hours or days.
  • Future Direction: The researchers suggest that future studies should compare these thermal signatures under actual clinical loading conditions (e.g., lying in a hospital bed) rather than just cupping.

Summary updated

Abstract

Erythema commonly presents as the reddening or discoloration of the skin due to hyperemia in tissue under pressure and is assessed in skin evaluations to detect early signs of pressure injuries (PrIs). While the use of thermography has been shown as a promising tool for the identification of PrIs, the correlation of temperature and erythema changes have not been consistent across all skin tone categories. Therefore, the objective of this study was to evaluate how thermography and colorimetry can track temperature and erythema changes following cupping across a diverse set of skin tones. Tissue changes over a bony prominence were induced by using a cupping device and maintaining -30 kPa for 5 minutes. After this, thermal images and colorimeter measurements were taken starting immediately post-cupping and repeated every minute for 7 minutes. No significant differences in temperature change were observed across BMI category, sex, or skin tone post-cupping. Measurements of change in erythema also did not vary across sex or BMI category, but did vary significantly across skin tone category (p<0.001). These findings demonstrate that thermal imaging detects underlying tissue changes that visual assessment cannot capture, supporting its use as a complement to, rather than replacement for, clinical assessment.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jordan2025impact,
  author = {Kathleen S. Jordan and Glory Tomi John and Andrew Chung and Miriam Asare-Baiden and Vicki Hertzberg and Joyce C. Ho and Sharon Eve Sonenblum},
  title = {{Impact of Skin Tone and Cupping on Erythema and Thermal Imaging Measurements}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-7272158/v1},
}

Loading related content...

Figure