Impact of COVID-19 on the Big Industrial Enterprises in Hebei, China: Grey Forecast Perspective

Shiyu Hu, Fei Wu, Lifeng WuInternational Journal of Grey Systems 2022 · DOI

Abstract

To analyze the impact of COVID-19 on the big industry enterprise in Hebei, a province of China, value added of the industrial enterprises ‘above designated size’ in Hebei Province is predicted by grey forecasting model GM (1,1). The difference between the predicted value and the actual value implied the influence. The study found that the impact of the epidemic is relatively serious in January-February 2020. The industrial value added has a difference of 27.6 billion Yuan. It is recommended that some tax reliefs should be given to the industries above designated size.

Introduction

Quantifying the impact of a "black swan" event like COVID-19 is notoriously difficult for traditional statistics. Standard econometric models often require large, stable datasets and assume specific data distributions (like a normal distribution). However, during a sudden crisis, data is often "small" (limited time points) and "grey" (uncertain or partially known).

This study, published in the International Journal of Grey Systems, applies a specialized mathematical framework to quantify the economic "scarring" caused by the initial COVID-19 outbreak on large-scale industrial enterprises in Hebei, China. By utilizing the GM(1,1) grey forecasting model, researchers established a counterfactual: what would the industrial output have looked like in 2020 if the pandemic had never happened?

Methodology

The researchers employed the GM(1,1) Grey Forecasting Model, a technique specifically designed for "small sample, poor information" problems. The process involved:

  1. Data Initialization: Using monthly industrial value-added data from 2016–2019 to establish a baseline.
  2. 1-AGO (Accumulated Generating Operation): Transforming chaotic raw data into a more regular, monotonically increasing sequence that reveals the underlying "grey exponent law."
  3. Model Construction: Calculating the development coefficient ($a$) and grey action quantity ($b$) to build a predictive differential equation.
  4. Counterfactual Comparison: Predicting the 2020 values based on historical trends and comparing them to the actual reported figures from the Bureau of Statistics.

Datasets

The study utilized a specific dataset from the Hebei Provincial Bureau of Statistics, focusing on the value added of industrial enterprises "above designated size" (Unit: 100 million Yuan) from 2016 to 2020.

Historical monthly industrial value-added data (2016-2020) for Hebei Province.

Key Results and Insights

The analysis revealed that industrial growth typically follows a predictable exponential trend, which the authors term the "Grey Exponent Law." COVID-19 acted as an external force that broke this law, creating a measurable deviation.

The most significant disruption occurred in the first two months of 2020. While the Lunar New Year always causes a seasonal dip, the model showed the 2020 dip was far deeper than historical trends predicted.

Comparison of actual vs. predicted industrial value-added for 2020, highlighting the Q1 shortfall.
  • The Shortfall: For the January-February 2020 period, the model predicted a value of 194.65 billion Yuan, but the actual value was only 167.05 billion Yuan. This represents a difference of 27.6 billion Yuan (an absolute percentage error of 16.52% relative to the "business-as-usual" prediction).
  • Recovery Signature: By March 2020, the error dropped to just 1.3%, signaling that large industrial enterprises were able to return to their historical growth trajectory relatively quickly after the initial lockdown.

Conclusion and Policy Recommendations

The study demonstrates the resilience of the industrial sector compared to tourism or retail. Once production resumed in March, the gap between predicted and actual values narrowed rapidly. Based on these findings, the authors suggest targeted tax relief specifically for these large-scale enterprises to help them recover the capital lost during the Q1 shortfall.

While the model effectively captures the "value added" impact, the authors acknowledge that future work should expand to include employment rates and supply chain delays to create a more holistic map of pandemic-induced disruption.

Summary updated

Abstract

To analyze the impact of COVID-19 on the big industry enterprise in Hebei, a province of China, value added of the industrial enterprises ‘above designated size’ in Hebei Province is predicted by grey forecasting model GM (1,1). The difference between the predicted value and the actual value implied the influence. The study found that the impact of the epidemic is relatively serious in January-February 2020. The industrial value added has a difference of 27.6 billion Yuan. It is recommended that some tax reliefs should be given to the industries above designated size.
BibTeX
@article{hu2022impact,
  author = {Shiyu Hu and Fei Wu and Lifeng Wu},
  title = {{Impact of COVID-19 on the Big Industrial Enterprises in Hebei, China: Grey Forecast Perspective}},
  journal = {International Journal of Grey Systems},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.52812/ijgs.60},
}
Figure