Abstract
Coping with the outbreak of Coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19), many countries have implemented public-health measures and movement restrictions to prevent the spread of the virus. However, the strict mobility control also brought about production stagnation and market disruption, resulting in a severe worldwide economic crisis. Quantifying the economic stagnation and predicting post-pandemic recovery are imperative issues. Besides, it is significant to examine how the impact of COVID-19 on economic activities varied with industries. As a reflection of enterprises' production output, high-frequency electricity-consumption data is an intuitive and effective tool for evaluating the economic impact of COVID-19 on different industries. In this paper, we quantify and compare economic impacts on the electricity consumption of different industries in eastern China. In order to address this problem, we conduct causal analysis using a difference-in-difference (DID) estimation model to analyze the effects of multi-phase public-health measures. Our model employs the electricity-consumption data ranging from 2019 to 2020 of 96 counties in the Eastern China region, which covers three main economic sectors and their 53 sub-sectors. The results indicate that electricity demand of all industries (other than information transfer industry) rebounded after the initial shock, and is back to pre-pandemic trends after easing the control measures at the end of May 2020. Emergency response, the combination of all countermeasures to COVID-19 in a certain period, affected all industries, and the higher level of emergency response with stricter movement control resulted in a greater decrease in electricity consumption and production. The pandemic outbreak has a negative-lag effect on industries, and there is greater resilience in industries that are less dependent on human mobility for economic production and activities.
Introduction
Traditional economic indicators, such as GDP, stock indices, and corporate surveys, are often "lagging indicators" that fail to capture the immediate, granular effects of sudden shocks like the COVID-19 pandemic. Furthermore, these metrics often lack the resolution needed to distinguish between different industrial sub-sectors or specific geographic regions. This study addresses the challenge of quantifying the real-time causal impact of public health measures on economic activity by using high-frequency electricity consumption data as a proxy for production output.
Distinguishing between a pandemic-induced slump and seasonal economic fluctuations—such as the annual dip during the Lunar New Year in China—requires sophisticated modeling. By leveraging data from 96 counties in Zhejiang Province, this research provides a high-resolution "thermometer" of economic shock and recovery.
Methodology and Data
The researchers utilized a dataset of daily electricity consumption from January 1, 2019, to July 1, 2020, covering 53 industrial sub-sectors. To isolate the causal effect of the pandemic from seasonal trends, a Difference-in-Difference (DID) estimation model was employed. This model compares the "treatment group" (2020 data) against a "control group" (2019 data).
Key methodological features include:
- Lunar Calendar Alignment: 2020 dates were matched to their corresponding Lunar calendar dates in 2019 to neutralize the "Spring Festival" effect.
- Multi-Phase Analysis: The pandemic response was divided into four phases based on government emergency levels (Level 1 to Level 3, followed by a post-recovery phase).
- Fixed Effects: The model controlled for county-specific and week-specific variables to account for local differences and time-dependent factors like weather.
Key Results and Economic Impact
The study quantifies the economic stagnation across different levels of emergency response. The strictest measures (Level 1) resulted in the most significant drop in electricity consumption, reflecting a near-halving of regional production.
Major findings include:
- Severity of Impact: Level 1 emergency response led to a 47.53% decrease in electricity consumption. As restrictions eased to Level 2 and Level 3, the decreases moderated to 42.55% and 36.88%, respectively.
- Recovery Dynamics: Most industries returned to pre-pandemic trends within 7 to 15 weeks. By May 2020, sectors like Education and Building Construction even showed a "retaliatory rebound," with consumption exceeding 2019 levels as they worked to compensate for lost time.
- Sectoral Resilience: Resilience was found to be inversely proportional to human mobility. Industries like Information Transfer and Internet Services remained stable, while those reliant on physical presence, such as Catering and Accommodation, faced the steepest and longest recovery paths.
Discussion and Conclusion
The use of high-frequency electricity data provides a powerful tool for policymakers to monitor economic health in real-time. The findings highlight a "negative-lag effect," where the shock of the initial outbreak continues to suppress production even after restrictions are eased.
While the study is localized to Zhejiang Province, it offers a scalable framework for evaluating the trade-offs between public health interventions and economic stability. Future work could aim to disentangle specific policy effects and further refine models to account for weather-driven fluctuations in energy use. Ultimately, this research underscores that economic resilience in the modern era is deeply tied to an industry's ability to operate independently of physical human mobility.
Summary updated