Image segmentation on cell-center sampled quadtree and octree grids

Byung Moon Kim, Panagiotis TsiotrasProceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE 2009 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel method for efficiently segmenting 2D and 3D images using cell-centered quadtree and octree grids. By restricting grid connectivity and pre-computing interpolation weights, they overcome the challenge of interpolating data on these adaptive grids, leading to significant speedups in image segmentation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Image segmentation, particularly for objects with complex shapes and varying curvature, often requires high-resolution grids. Traditional methods using dense grids can be computationally expensive and memory-intensive. Adaptive grids like quadtrees and octrees offer a solution by refining the grid only where needed, but storing data at cell centers (which simplifies the tree structure) makes continuous interpolation difficult. This paper tackles the problem of efficiently performing continuous interpolation on cell-centered quadtree/octree grids, which is crucial for accurate and stable image segmentation using level set methods.

Methods

The core contribution of this paper lies in its approach to continuous interpolation on cell-centered adaptive grids. They propose two key innovations:

  • Constrained Grid Refinement/Coarsening: They introduce specific rules for how quadtree and octree grids can be refined or coarsened. These rules limit the possible local connectivity types between neighboring cells to a small, manageable number (15 for quadtrees, 255 for octrees). This constraint ensures that the grid resolution changes gradually, avoiding abrupt jumps.
  • Precomputed Interpolation Weights: For these limited connectivity types, they precompute the weights needed for continuous interpolation. This is achieved by defining "interpolation boxes" and recursively interpolating values at sub-grid points. These precomputed weights are stored in a lookup table, drastically reducing the computational cost of interpolation during the segmentation process.

They also adapt region-based level set segmentation methods to work with these grids, utilizing the continuous interpolation for accurate PDE solving and derivative computation.

Datasets

The paper evaluates their method on:

  • A 512x512 2D image (Figure 6).
  • A synthetic 3D test image (Figure 7).
  • A volumetric cell image from the CCDB site (http://ccdb.ucsd.edu) (Figure 8).

No new datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Cell-centered simplicity vs. interpolation complexity: The paper highlights the trade-off between a simpler tree data structure (cell-centered) and the challenge of interpolating values. Their work demonstrates that this challenge is surmountable with clever constraints and precomputation.
  • The power of restricted connectivity: By limiting the types of local grid configurations, they create a predictable environment for interpolation. This predictability is key to precomputing interpolation rules and achieving efficiency.
  • Precomputation as a performance booster: Storing precomputed interpolation weights in a lookup table is a critical optimization. It transforms a potentially complex and time-consuming interpolation step into a fast lookup operation.
  • Adaptive grids and image pyramids: The cell-centered approach naturally aligns with image pyramid concepts, allowing for efficient segmentation by starting at coarser resolutions and progressively refining.

Key Results

The paper demonstrates significant speedups in image segmentation:

  • 2D Segmentation: A 512x512 image segmentation took about 4 seconds using their method with a constant time step.
  • 3D Segmentation: A synthetic 3D image segmentation that took 34 seconds with naive time integration was reduced to 0.5 seconds by using a coarse-to-fine approach with their adaptive grid and interpolation method.
  • Volumetric Cell Image Segmentation: A segmentation that took 30 minutes naively was reduced to approximately 40 seconds by employing the coarse-to-fine strategy.

Qualitatively, the continuous interpolation ensures smooth level set interfaces and contour lines, avoiding artifacts.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations:

  • The paper acknowledges that the grid connectivity constraints might not always allow for the ideal desired tree depth, requiring a compromise between the desired resolution and the connectivity rules.
  • While the number of connectivity types is manageable, it's still a factor in memory usage for storing precomputed weights.

Future Work:

  • The authors plan to explore further optimizations by accommodating common speed-up techniques like narrow-band methods or freezing converged regions.
  • They aim to further investigate the accommodation of these techniques within their adaptive grid framework.

Summary updated

Abstract

Geometric shapes embedded in 2D or 3D images often have boundaries with both high and low curvature regions. These boundaries of varying curvature can be efficiently captured by adaptive grids such as quadtrees and octrees. Using these trees, we propose to store sample values at the centers of the tree cells in order to simplify the tree data structure, and to take advantage of the image pyramid. The difficulty with using a cell-centered tree approach is the interpolation of the values sampled at the cell centers. To solve this problem, we first restrict the tree refinement and coarsening rules so that only a small number of local connectivity types are produced. For these connectivity types, we can precompute the weights for a continuous interpolation. Using this interpolation, we show that region-based image segmentation of 2D and 3D images can be performed efficiently.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kim2009image,
  author = {Byung Moon Kim and Panagiotis Tsiotras},
  title = {{Image segmentation on cell-center sampled quadtree and octree grids}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE},
  year = {2009},
  doi = {10.1117/12.810965},
}

Loading related content...

Figure