Ignition characteristics of methane-air mixture at low initial temperature

Chao Yang, Qing Han, Haibo Liu, Yuanyuan Wang, Ran ChengFrontiers in Energy Research 2023 · DOI

Introduction

As global demand for Liquefied Natural Gas (LNG) and oxygen-bearing coal-bed methane (CBM) increases, the safety of storage and liquefaction processes becomes paramount. At cryogenic temperatures—specifically around 150 K—methane-air mixtures can still reach explosive limits. However, experimental study at these temperatures is hindered by technical challenges like icing and complex cooling requirements. This study utilizes high-fidelity numerical simulations to bridge the gap in understanding the microscopic features of methane ignition under cryogenic conditions.

Numerical Methodology

The researchers utilized ANSYS FLUENT to conduct 2D numerical simulations of a cylindrical explosion vessel. The study employed the Eddy Dissipation Concept (EDC) to couple fluid dynamics with a detailed chemical reaction mechanism consisting of 20 elementary reactions and 13 species.

The 2D computational domain used for the simulation, highlighting the central ignition source and insulating walls.

To determine the critical conditions for ignition, the authors used a "high-temperature air mass" model, varying the radius ($r$) and temperature ($T$) of the initial spark. The model was validated against experimental Minimum Ignition Energy (MIE) data, showing a high degree of accuracy with a maximum absolute error of only 0.08 mJ.

Chemical Kinetic Insights

The simulation revealed distinct behaviors of free radicals and intermediate products during the ignition process:

  • Flame Front Concentration: Radicals such as $H$ and $O$ are primarily concentrated at the flame front, with negligible presence in the unburnt gas or the center of the burnt zone.
  • Hydroxyl (OH) Dynamics: Unlike other radicals, $OH$ serves a dual role as both a chain carrier facilitating the reaction and a persistent combustion product within the burnt zone.
  • Failure Mechanisms: The study identified two primary reasons for ignition failure based on which parameter is insufficient:
  • Temperature-Limited: If the ignition temperature is too low, the initial elementary reaction ($CH_4 \rightarrow CH_3 + H$) fails to initiate.
  • Radius-Limited: If the ignition radius is too small, the chain reaction cannot sustain itself. Specific elementary reactions (R8, R9, R12, and R13) terminate due to insufficient energy density to maintain the radical pool.

Critical Ignition Thresholds

For a methane-air mixture at an initial temperature of 150 K, the study established precise critical thresholds for successful ignition:

  • Minimum Ignition Radius: 4.6 mm
  • Minimum Ignition Temperature: 1180 K
Explosion pressure rise over time, identifying the 3.5 ms initiation stage defined by a 5% pressure increase.

The "initiation stage"—the duration from the spark to a 5% rise in pressure ($P = 1.05P_0$)—was found to be approximately 3.5 ms. Interestingly, while the initial gas temperature significantly impacts the required ignition radius, it has negligible effect on the critical ignition temperature needed to break the initial chemical bonds of methane.

Conclusion

This research provides essential data for designing safer LNG storage and fire-suppression systems. By identifying the specific chemical bottlenecks that lead to ignition failure, engineers can develop more effective fire-extinguishing agents that target and interrupt these critical elementary reactions. Future work may expand these 2D findings into 3D models to account for buoyancy and complex turbulence in real-world scenarios.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, FLUENT software coupled with the chemical reaction mechanism is used to study the ignition characteristics of methane-air mixtures at low temperature. Variations of the main free radical concentrations, the critical conditions for a successful ignition and the chemical reaction rate of each elementary reaction for a failure ignition are obtained, respectively. Results indicate that the consumption of methane immediately affects the concentration distribution of carbon monoxide, which presents the opposite relationship with that of methane. Mass fractions of the intermediate products and H, O free radicals are low in the burnt zone and unburnt zone, whereas reach the maximum on the flame front. OH is not only the intermediate free radical, but also the combustion product remained by the intermediate reactions. At a low temperature of 150 K, the critical radius and temperature of methane ignition are 4.6 mm and 1180 K, respectively. When ignition radius is smaller than the critical value, the failed ignition of methane is caused by the termination of the elementary reactions: R8: H + O 2 = OH + O, R9: OH + O = O 2 + H, R12: O + H 2 O = 2OH and R13: 2OH = O + H 2 O. However, when ignition temperature is lower than the critical value, because of the failed initiation of elementary reaction R1: CH 4 = CH 3 + H, the combustion of methane is not occurred.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yang2023ignition,
  author = {Chao Yang and Qing Han and Haibo Liu and Yuanyuan Wang and Ran Cheng},
  title = {{Ignition characteristics of methane-air mixture at low initial temperature}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Energy Research},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fenrg.2022.1003470},
}
Figure