Identification of miRNA-mRNA regulatory modules by exploring collective group relationships

S. M. Masud Karim, Lin Liu, Thuc Duy Le, Jiuyong Li

TL;DR

This paper introduces DICORE, a novel computational framework for identifying miRNA-mRNA regulatory modules (MMRMs) by focusing on "collective group relationships" rather than individual interactions. This approach aims to provide a more robust and biologically significant understanding of gene regulation by considering how groups of miRNAs collectively regulate groups of mRNAs.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

MicroRNAs (miRNAs) are crucial regulators of gene expression, primarily by targeting messenger RNAs (mRNAs). Understanding how miRNAs and mRNAs interact is key to deciphering cellular functions and disease mechanisms. While many computational methods exist to identify miRNA-mRNA regulatory modules (MMRMs), most focus on individual miRNA-mRNA pairs or lack a comprehensive approach to collective regulation. This leaves a gap in understanding how groups of miRNAs might coordinate to regulate groups of mRNAs, a phenomenon suggested by biological evidence. Existing methods often require prior knowledge (like the number of modules) or struggle with the complexity of dense interaction networks. This paper aims to fill this gap by developing a method that explicitly models and leverages these collective relationships.

Methods

The core of DICORE lies in its two-stage approach:

  1. Forming Separate Groups:
    • Interaction Weight Matrix (W): First, the paper constructs a weighted bipartite graph representing miRNA-mRNA interactions. The weights are derived from the absolute values of Pearson correlation coefficients between miRNA and mRNA expression profiles. This captures both the strength and direction of potential interactions.
  2. Collaboration Score: To quantify collective relationships, a "collaboration score" is introduced. For a pair of miRNAs, this score measures their similarity in targeting common mRNAs. Similarly, for a pair of mRNAs, it measures their similarity in being targeted by common miRNAs. This is calculated using a formula that considers shared targets.
  3. Clustering: Using these collaboration scores as similarity measures, an overlapping clustering algorithm (adapted from ClusterONE) is employed to form cohesive groups of miRNAs and groups of mRNAs independently. This allows for miRNAs or mRNAs to belong to multiple groups.
  4. Identifying Collective Group Relationships (COREs):
    • Canonical Correlation Analysis (CCA): Canonical Correlation Analysis is applied to pairs of miRNA groups and mRNA groups. CCA measures the strength of the linear relationship between two sets of variables, effectively quantifying the collective regulatory relationship between a miRNA group and an mRNA group.
  5. MMRM Identification: Group pairs with significant canonical correlations (above a threshold of 0.50) are identified as MMRMs, also referred to as Collective Group Relationships (COREs). The strength of these COREs is determined by their canonical correlation values.

Datasets

The DICORE framework was validated using three real-world gene expression datasets:

  • NCI60 Dataset: Focused on Epithelial to Mesenchymal Transition (EMT), comprising 60 cancer cell lines.
  • Breast Cancer (BR) Dataset: Included expression profiles from 50 breast cancer cell lines.
  • Multi-Class Cancer (MCC) Dataset: Covered samples from various cancer types (bladder, breast, colon, kidney, lung, pancreas, prostate, and uterus).

The paper also utilized "ground-truth" databases of experimentally confirmed miRNA-mRNA interactions, combining data from DIANA-TarBase, miRTarBase, miRecords, and miRWalk, to validate the identified modules.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Collective Regulation is Key: The central idea is that understanding how groups of miRNAs collectively influence groups of mRNAs provides a more accurate and biologically relevant picture of gene regulation than focusing solely on individual interactions.
  • Collaboration Score as a Novel Metric: The introduction of a "collaboration score" to quantify the similarity of miRNAs (or mRNAs) based on their shared interactions is a novel contribution.
  • CCA for Quantifying Collective Strength: Using Canonical Correlation Analysis to measure the strength of relationships between entire groups of miRNAs and mRNAs is a powerful way to capture complex, multi-component interactions.
  • Overlapping Modules are Biologically Realistic: The use of an overlapping clustering algorithm allows for miRNAs and mRNAs to participate in multiple regulatory modules, reflecting the complex and interconnected nature of biological systems.

Key Results

  • Validation with Ground Truth: The identified MMRMs showed a significant overlap with experimentally confirmed miRNA-mRNA interactions, suggesting the method's accuracy.
  • Biological Significance: The top mRNAs regulated by miRNAs within the identified MMRMs were found to be highly relevant to the biological conditions of the datasets (e.g., EMT-related genes in the NCI60 dataset).
  • Functional Enrichment: The identified MMRMs were shown to be functionally enriched and biologically significant, particularly in the context of cancer pathways. For instance, the "Pathways in cancer" KEGG pathway was consistently identified as significant across all three datasets.
  • Performance Comparison: When compared to other methods like Mirsynergy on a specific ovarian cancer dataset, DICORE identified a reasonable number of modules with a good average number of miRNAs and mRNAs per module.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Pearson Correlation Limitations: The paper acknowledges that Pearson correlation, while useful, might not fully capture all nuances of interaction weights. Future work could explore other statistical methods like maximal information coefficient, regression techniques (Lasso), or causal inference methods (IDA).
  • Ensemble Methods: The authors suggest that ensemble methods could be tested for capturing collective interactions.
  • Exploring Different Biological Conditions: The framework could be applied to datasets from different biological conditions to discover context-specific MMRMs.
  • Unweighted Graph Drawbacks: The paper notes that previous work using unweighted graphs can lead to computational inaccuracies, which DICORE aims to overcome by using weighted graphs and collaboration scores.

Summary updated

Abstract

Background microRNAs (miRNAs) play an essential role in the post-transcriptional gene regulation in plants and animals. They regulate a wide range of biological processes by targeting messenger RNAs (mRNAs). Evidence suggests that miRNAs and mRNAs interact collectively in gene regulatory networks. The collective relationships between groups of miRNAs and groups of mRNAs may be more readily interpreted than those between individual miRNAs and mRNAs, and thus are useful for gaining insight into gene regulation and cell functions. Several computational approaches have been developed to discover miRNA-mRNA regulatory modules (MMRMs) with a common aim to elucidate miRNA-mRNA regulatory relationships. However, most existing methods do not consider the collective relationships between a group of miRNAs and the group of targeted mRNAs in the process of discovering MMRMs. Our aim is to develop a framework to discover MMRMs and reveal miRNA-mRNA regulatory relationships from the heterogeneous expression data based on the collective relationships. Results We propose DIscovering COllective group RElationships (DICORE), an effective computational framework for revealing miRNA-mRNA regulatory relationships. We utilize the notation of collective group relationships to build the computational framework. The method computes the collaboration scores of the miRNAs and mRNAs on the basis of their interactions with mRNAs and miRNAs, respectively. Then it determines the groups of miRNAs and groups of mRNAs separately based on their respective collaboration scores. Next, it calculates the strength of the collective relationship between each pair of miRNA group and mRNA group using canonical correlation analysis, and the group pairs with significant canonical correlations are considered as the MMRMs. We applied this method to three gene expression datasets, and validated the computational discoveries. Conclusions Analysis of the results demonstrates that a large portion of the regulatory relationships discovered by DICORE is consistent with the experimentally confirmed databases. Furthermore, it is observed that the top mRNAs that are regulated by the miRNAs in the identified MMRMs are highly relevant to the biological conditions of the given datasets. It is also shown that the MMRMs identified by DICORE are more biologically significant and functionally enriched.
BibTeX
@article{karim2016identification,
  author = {S. M. Masud Karim and Lin Liu and Thuc Duy Le and Jiuyong Li},
  title = {{Identification of miRNA-mRNA regulatory modules by exploring collective group relationships}},
  journal = {BMC Genom.},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1186/s12864-015-2300-z},
}
Figure