TGGLinesPlus : A Robust Topological Graph‐Guided Computer Vision Algorithm for Line Detection From Images

Liping Yang, Joshua Driscol, Ming Gong, Katie Slack, Wenbin Zhang, Shujie Wang, Catherine Potts

TL;DR

This paper introduces TGGLinesPlus, a novel topological graph-guided algorithm for robust line detection in images. It addresses the limitations of existing methods by providing a parameter-free, intuitive approach that accurately extracts lines from diverse image types, outperforming several state-of-the-art techniques.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Line detection is a fundamental task in computer vision with applications ranging from document analysis and indoor mapping to critical scientific endeavors like extracting sea ice fracture lines from satellite imagery. Despite decades of research, existing line detection algorithms often struggle with robustness, intuitiveness, and performance across a wide variety of image domains. Many methods fail on challenging image types like scanned documents or satellite imagery, or require extensive parameter tuning. This paper aims to fill this gap by proposing TGGLinesPlus, a method designed to be robust, parameter-free, and capable of handling diverse image sources.

Methods

TGGLinesPlus employs a topological graph-based approach. The core idea is to represent the image as a graph derived from its skeleton. The process involves:

  1. Binarization and Skeletonization: The input image is first binarized, and then a skeleton is extracted using the Zhang-Suen thinning algorithm. This skeleton represents the "centerline" of the lines in the image.
  2. Skeleton Graph Generation: The image skeleton is converted into a graph where each pixel in the skeleton becomes a node, and edges connect adjacent pixels.
  3. Graph Simplification: To handle complexity and potential artifacts, the graph is simplified. This involves identifying "junction nodes" (nodes with more than two neighbors) and using cliques to detect "primary junction nodes." Edges that might unnecessarily complicate path segmentation are then removed.
  4. Path Segmentation: The simplified graph is then segmented into paths. This is achieved by identifying "terminal nodes" (nodes with only one neighbor) and the primary junction nodes, which serve as endpoints for path extraction.
  5. Output: The algorithm outputs a dictionary containing useful information, including connected components, junction nodes, terminal nodes, and segmented paths.

A key novelty is the avoidance of "turning nodes" and the Douglas-Peucker algorithm for simplification, which the authors argue leads to more intuitive and continuous paths.

Datasets

The paper evaluates TGGLinesPlus on a variety of image datasets from diverse domains, including:

  • MNIST and CMINIST: For character and digit recognition.
  • Earth Sciences: Satellite imagery (e.g., Landsat 8 OLI) for remote sensing.
  • Medical Imagery: Retina images.
  • Scanned Documents: For document digitization.
  • Contours Maps: For topographic data.
  • Structural Engineering: Concrete crack images.
  • Transportation/Mapping: Road images, contour maps.

The paper does not introduce new benchmark datasets but uses existing ones to compare its method against others.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Skeleton as a Bridge: The image skeleton acts as a crucial bridge between the pixel-based image representation and the topological graph representation, effectively capturing shape and connectivity.
  • Topological Graph for Robustness: Representing lines as a topological graph allows the algorithm to maintain connectivity and topology even in complex or noisy images, which is a significant advantage over methods relying solely on local gradients or edge detection.
  • Parameter-Free Operation: The absence of parameters is a major strength, making the algorithm easier to use and more reliable across different image types without the need for tedious tuning.
  • Intuitive Path Representation: By avoiding "turning nodes" and focusing on terminal and primary junction nodes, TGGLinesPlus generates more continuous and intuitive line segments, which better reflect human perception.
  • Rich Output for Downstream Tasks: The comprehensive output dictionary (including junction nodes, terminal nodes, etc.) makes the results highly reusable for various downstream machine learning and computer vision tasks.

Key Results

TGGLinesPlus demonstrated strong performance across various benchmarks:

  • Qualitative: Visually, TGGLinesPlus produced more continuous and accurate line representations compared to other methods, especially on small images (MNIST) and complex images (remote sensing, documents). It successfully handled curved lines and avoided breaking paths into multiple segments where other methods failed.
  • Quantitative: The paper presents quantitative evaluations based on the number of connected components, junction nodes, and terminal nodes. In many cases, TGGLinesPlus achieved results closer to the ground truth than other methods. For instance, on image #10 (document page), TGGLinesPlus was the only method that produced an output with connected components, junction nodes, and terminal nodes similar to the ground truth.
  • Robustness: The algorithm performed well across a wide range of image domains, from small digits to large satellite images, and under various scenarios (single vs. multiple subgraphs, with/without cycles).
  • Comparison: TGGLinesPlus outperformed five classic and state-of-the-art methods, including PPHT, LSD, EDLines, Linelet, and its predecessor TGGLines, particularly on challenging image types.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Reliance on Binarization/Skeletonization: The algorithm's performance is dependent on the robustness of the initial binarization and skeletonization steps. If these steps fail to preserve connectivity, TGGLinesPlus may not perform optimally.
  • 2D Limitation: Currently, the method is designed for 2D images. Extending it to 3D imagery is a future direction.
  • Noisy Skeletons: Noisy skeletons or images with extraneous objects can introduce artifacts that affect the skeleton graph and thus the line detection.
  • Performance Improvement: While fast, the path segmentation step is identified as the most time-intensive. Future work includes exploring non-sequential path search algorithms, optimizing subgraph processing, and enabling parallelization for analyzing very large datasets.
  • Turning Nodes: While TGGLinesPlus deliberately omits turning nodes for simplicity, the authors acknowledge that some applications might benefit from their detection, and their comprehensive output could facilitate further analysis for such needs.

Summary updated

Abstract

ABSTRACT Line detection is a classic and essential problem in image processing, computer vision, and machine intelligence. Line detection has many important applications, including image vectorization (e.g., document recognition and art design), indoor mapping, and important societal challenges (e.g., sea ice fracture line extraction from satellite imagery). Many line detection algorithms and methods have been developed, but robust and intuitive methods are still lacking. In this paper, we proposed and implemented a topological graph‐guided algorithm, named TGGLinesPlus , for line detection. Our experiments on images from a wide range of domains have demonstrated the flexibility of our TGGLinesPlus algorithm. We benchmarked our algorithm with five classic and state‐of‐the‐art line detection methods and evaluated the benchmark results qualitatively and quantitatively, the results demonstrate the robustness of TGGLinesPlus .
BibTeX
@article{yang2025i,
  author = {Liping Yang and Joshua Driscol and Ming Gong and Katie Slack and Wenbin Zhang and Shujie Wang and Catherine Potts},
  title = {{<i>TGGLinesPlus</i> : A Robust Topological Graph‐Guided Computer Vision Algorithm for Line Detection From Images}},
  journal = {Transactions},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1111/tgis.70015},
}
Figure