In situ generation of RNA complexes for synthetic molecular strand displacement circuits in autonomous systems

Wooli Bae, Guy‐Bart Stan, Thomas E. OuldridgebioRxiv 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a novel method to autonomously generate the molecular "gates" needed for synthetic RNA circuits directly within a reaction system. By using self-cleaving ribozymes to cut a single RNA transcript, they can create these essential multi-stranded complexes in situ, paving the way for more complex and autonomous molecular computing systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Synthetic biology aims to engineer biological systems with predictable and programmable behaviors, often by borrowing principles from computation. Nucleic acid strand-displacement reactions, particularly those mediated by toeholds, are a powerful tool for building these synthetic molecular circuits. These circuits function like logic gates, where specific input molecules trigger the release of output molecules, enabling complex computations and feedback control.

A major hurdle in applying these circuits, especially in living cells or other autonomous systems, is the efficient and controlled production of the multi-stranded RNA complexes that act as these "gates." Traditional methods involve chemically synthesizing individual RNA strands and then annealing them together, a process that is not feasible for in situ generation. Simply transcribing individual strands within a cell is problematic because it can lead to uncontrolled reactions and difficulties in achieving the precise stoichiometry required for reliable circuit operation. This paper addresses the critical need for a method to autonomously produce these RNA gates within the system itself, enabling truly self-sufficient molecular circuits.

Methods

The core innovation presented is the use of self-cleaving ribozymes to engineer a single RNA transcript that can autonomously cut itself into the desired gate complex. Specifically, the researchers designed a DNA template that, when transcribed by RNA polymerase, produces a long RNA strand. This RNA strand contains two hammerhead ribozymes (HHRs) – one at each end of a "self-excising module" – that are engineered to cleave the RNA backbone at specific sites.

Here's a breakdown of the key steps:

  1. DNA Template Design: DNA templates are created to encode for the RNA sequences of the gate complexes, with the self-excising module integrated.
  2. In Vitro Transcription: RNA polymerase transcribes the DNA template, producing a single, long RNA strand.
  3. Co-transcriptional Folding and Self-Cleavage: As the RNA is transcribed, it folds into a specific secondary structure. The embedded ribozymes then catalyze self-cleavage, cutting the RNA at two points.
  4. Gate Formation and Dissociation: This self-cleavage process releases the self-excising module, leaving behind the desired multi-stranded RNA gate complex. The researchers also demonstrated that the self-excising module spontaneously dissociates from the gate.
  5. Strand Displacement Reaction: Once the gate is formed, it can participate in standard toehold-mediated strand-displacement reactions with input RNA molecules, which are also produced in situ from their respective DNA templates.

The researchers also incorporated a small hairpin at the 5' end of the transcript to promote rapid co-transcriptional folding of the ribozymes, preventing premature or incorrect folding that could lead to leak reactions.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on experimental demonstration using synthesized DNA templates and biochemical reagents.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Autonomous Gate Production: The most significant insight is the demonstration that complex multi-stranded RNA gates can be generated in situ from a single transcript using the cell's own machinery (or a reconstituted version). This bypasses the need for external synthesis and assembly.
  • Ribozyme-Mediated Self-Assembly: Leveraging the catalytic activity of ribozymes for precise molecular cutting and assembly is a powerful strategy for creating complex molecular structures autonomously.
  • Controlling Reaction Kinetics: The use of a 5' hairpin to direct co-transcriptional folding is crucial for preventing unwanted side reactions and ensuring the gate is ready for strand displacement only when triggered. This highlights the importance of kinetic control in molecular circuit design.
  • Modular Design for Cascades: The successful demonstration of a two-step cascade circuit shows the potential for building more complex computational systems by linking these autonomously generated gates.

Key Results

  • Efficient Ribozyme Cleavage: Both individual hammerhead ribozymes (HHR1 and HHR2) and the assembled self-excising module showed high cleavage yields (around 90% for individual HHRs, and an estimated combined yield for the module).
  • Successful Gate Formation: The self-excising module effectively cleaved itself out, leaving behind functional multi-stranded RNA gate complexes.
  • In Situ Single-Input/Single-Output Circuit Operation: A functional single-input, single-output circuit was demonstrated, where transcription, folding, cleavage, and strand displacement occurred simultaneously. Fluorescence recovery (indicating output signal) was observed only when active gates and the correct input were present.
  • Orthogonality: The RNA gates demonstrated discrimination between input RNAs with different toehold sequences, a critical feature for building complex, non-interfering circuits.
  • Two-Step Cascade: A two-step cascade circuit was successfully implemented, showing that the output of one autonomously generated gate can trigger another, leading to a final detectable signal.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Gate Complexity: The current work focuses on single-input, single-output gates. Generalizing this to multi-input, multi-output gates will require incorporating more self-excising modules and potentially placing them at different positions within the RNA transcript.
  • Reliability of Complex Gates: While self-cleavage was confirmed in more complex designs (e.g., with modules in RNA duplexes or multiple modules), the resulting gates were not always fully reliable in strand displacement reactions. Further work is needed to identify design rules for robust functional gates.
  • Kinetic Factors: The authors hypothesize that transient kinetics of gate folding during transcription might be a key factor in design, potentially trapping transcripts in local energy minima. Understanding and controlling these kinetics is an area for future investigation.
  • Reporter Systems: Currently, the output signal is detected using an exogenously supplied DNA probe. Future work aims to produce reporter components in situ using aptamer systems, moving towards a fully autonomous, cell-like environment.
  • Transfer to Living Cells: The ultimate goal is to transfer this gate motif to living cells, which will require addressing challenges related to cellular environments, RNAse activity, and achieving dynamic, non-equilibrium steady states.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Synthetic molecular circuits implementing DNA or RNA strand-displacement reactions can be used to build complex systems such as molecular computers and feedback control systems. Despite recent advances, application of nucleic acid-based circuits in vivo remains challenging due to a lack of efficient methods to produce their essential components – multi-stranded complexes known as “gates” – in situ , i.e. in living cells or other autonomous systems. Here, we propose the use of naturally occurring self-cleaving ribozymes to cut a single-stranded RNA transcript into a gate complex of shorter strands, thereby opening new possibilities for the autonomous and continuous production of RNA strands in a stoichiometrically and structurally controlled way.
BibTeX
@misc{bae2020i,
  author = {Wooli Bae and Guy‐Bart Stan and Thomas E. Ouldridge},
  title = {{<i>In situ</i> generation of RNA complexes for synthetic molecular strand displacement circuits in autonomous systems}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1101/2020.07.15.204438},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}

Loading related content...

Figure