In Situ Electron Microscopy Investigation of Sodiation of Titanium Disulfide Nanoflakes

Xiuzhen Wang, Zhenpeng Yao, Sooyeon Hwang, Ying Pan, Hui Dong, Maosen Fu, Na Li, Ke Sun, Hong Gan, Yan Yao, Alán Aspuru‐Guzik, Qingyu Xu, Dong SuACS 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper uses advanced in situ electron microscopy and theoretical calculations to reveal the detailed, step-by-step mechanism of how titanium disulfide (TiS₂) nanoflakes react with sodium ions during battery charging. They discovered distinct intermediate phases and a unique "extrusion" reaction that transforms the 2D material into a 3D structure while maintaining its integrity, offering crucial insights for designing better sodium-ion batteries.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Sodium-ion batteries (NIBs) are a promising alternative to lithium-ion batteries due to the abundance and lower cost of sodium. Two-dimensional (2D) layered metal sulfides, like titanium disulfide (TiS₂), are attractive electrode materials for NIBs because their layered structure allows for easy insertion and removal of sodium ions. However, the exact process by which these materials undergo "sodiation" (the insertion of sodium ions) and how their structure changes during this process is not well understood. This lack of understanding hinders the optimization of NIB performance, particularly concerning capacity, rate capability, and long-term stability. This paper aims to fill this knowledge gap by providing a detailed, real-time view of the sodiation mechanism in TiS₂ nanoflakes.

Methods

The researchers employed a powerful combination of experimental and theoretical techniques:

  • In Situ Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM) and Scanning TEM (STEM): This is the core experimental technique. By performing TEM/STEM during the electrochemical sodiation process, the authors could directly observe structural and morphological changes at the nanoscale in real-time. This allowed them to track the propagation of reaction fronts and identify intermediate phases as they formed.
  • In Situ Selected Area Electron Diffraction (SAED): Coupled with TEM/STEM, SAED provided crystallographic information about the phases present at each stage of the sodiation process, helping to identify the specific crystal structures of the intermediate phases.
  • First-Principles Calculations (Density Functional Theory - DFT): These calculations were used to predict the thermodynamic stability of various Na-Ti-S phases and to understand the underlying energetics of the observed intercalation and extrusion reactions. This theoretical framework helped validate the experimental findings and explain why certain phases are preferred.
  • Galvanostatic Charge/Discharge Testing: Standard electrochemical tests were performed to measure the capacity and voltage profiles of the TiS₂ electrode, providing macroscopic performance data that could be correlated with the microscopic observations.

The novelty lies in the in situ nature of the TEM/STEM observations, allowing for direct visualization of dynamic processes that are typically inferred from ex situ analysis.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental measurements and theoretical simulations rather than pre-existing datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Distinct Sodiation Pathways: The sodiation of TiS₂ proceeds through multiple intermediate phases (II, Ib, and Ia) with unique sodium occupation sites and interlayer stacking sequences, which differ from the lithiation process of similar materials.
  • Multi-Step Extrusion Reaction: Beyond intercalation, further sodium insertion triggers an "extrusion" reaction. This leads to the phase separation of Ti metal from the Na₂S matrix, transforming the 2D nanoflakes into a 3D structure.
  • Structural Integrity Maintained: Unlike many conversion electrodes that decompose into amorphous composites, TiS₂ maintains a relatively compact structure even after full sodiation, which is crucial for long-term cycling stability.
  • Thermodynamic Favorability: DFT calculations confirm that the experimentally observed intermediate phases are thermodynamically stable under the sodiation conditions, providing a strong theoretical basis for the observed phenomena.
  • In-Plane Intercalation: The intercalation reactions occur primarily within the plane of the TiS₂ layers, preserving the overall layered structure during this stage.

Key Results

  • Identification of Three Intermediate Phases: The study clearly identified and characterized three distinct intermediate phases (II, Ib, and Ia) during the intercalation process, with specific Na content ranges (e.g., 0.17<x<0.33 for phase II).
  • Observation of 2D to 3D Morphological Transformation: In situ STEM imaging directly visualized the expansion of TiS₂ nanoflakes from a 2D layered structure to a 3D bulk-like morphology during the extrusion reaction.
  • Confirmation of Extrusion Mechanism: SAED patterns and HRTEM images confirmed the formation of Ti and Na₂S phases, supporting the proposed extrusion reaction mechanism.
  • Quantitative Kinetic Data: The in situ STEM analysis allowed for the estimation of phase propagation speeds, providing quantitative insights into the reaction kinetics.
  • Agreement with DFT Predictions: The experimentally observed phases and reaction pathways were found to be in good agreement with DFT calculations, validating the theoretical models.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sodiation Inhomogeneity: The authors acknowledge that sodiation can be inhomogeneous within a single nanoflake, which can lead to shifting of the calculated voltage profiles compared to experimental ones.
  • Kinetic Differences with Nanoflake Size: While the revealed mechanism is expected to be generally applicable, the authors note that kinetic differences might exist for nanoflakes of different sizes.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that understanding the structural integrity during sodiation is crucial for improving cycling stability. Future work could focus on enhancing this integrity to mitigate morphological pulverization and contact failure, thereby improving battery performance. Further investigation into the precise role of Na ion ordering and its impact on the electrochemical properties would also be valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

Two-dimensional (2D) metal sulfides show great promise for their potential applications as electrode materials of sodium ion-batteries because of the weak interlayer van der Waals interactions, which allow the reversible accommodation and extraction of sodium ions. The sodiation of metal sulfides can undergo a distinct process compared to that of lithiation, which is determined by their metal and structural types. However, the structural and morphological evolution during their electrochemical sodiation is still unclear. Here, we studied the sodiation reaction dynamics of TiS<sub>2</sub> by employing <i>in situ</i> transmission electron microscopy and first-principles calculations. During the sodium-ion intercalation process, we observed multiple intermediate phases (phase II, phase Ib, and phase Ia), different from its lithiation counterpart, with varied sodium occupation sites and interlayer stacking sequences. Further insertion of Na ions prompted a multistep extrusion reaction, which led to the phase separation of Ti metal from the Na<sub>2</sub>S matrix, with its 2D morphology expanded to a 3D morphology. In contrast to regular conversion electrodes, TiS<sub>2</sub> still maintained a compact structure after a full sodiation. First-principles calculations reveal that the as-identified phases are thermodynamically preferred at corresponding intercalation/extrusion stages compared to other possible phases. The present work provides the fundamental mechanistic understanding of the sodiation process of 2D transition metal sulfides.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2019i,
  author = {Xiuzhen Wang and Zhenpeng Yao and Sooyeon Hwang and Ying Pan and Hui Dong and Maosen Fu and Na Li and Ke Sun and Hong Gan and Yan Yao and Alán Aspuru‐Guzik and Qingyu Xu and Dong Su},
  title = {{<i>In Situ</i> Electron Microscopy Investigation of Sodiation of Titanium Disulfide Nanoflakes}},
  booktitle = {ACS},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1021/acsnano.9b04222},
}
Figure