In silico analysis of DNA re-replication across a complete genome reveals cell-to-cell heterogeneity and genome plasticity

Maria Anna Rapsomaniki, Stella Maxouri, Manuel Ramírez Garrastacho, Patroula Nathanailidou, Nickolaos Nikiforos Giakoumakis, Stavros Taraviras, John Lygeros, Zoi Lygerou

Introduction

In healthy eukaryotic cells, DNA replication is governed by a strict "once and only once" rule. This ensures that the entire genome is duplicated exactly once per cell cycle, maintaining genomic integrity across generations. However, when regulatory checkpoints fail—often through the overexpression of licensing factors such as Cdt1 or Cdc6—cells can enter a pathological state known as DNA re-replication. This phenomenon is a primary driver of genomic instability and is closely linked to oncogenesis.

Despite its importance, the global dynamics of re-replication have remained elusive. Traditional experimental methods typically rely on population-level averages, which obscure the stochastic nature of individual cellular behavior. This study addresses this gap by presenting the first genome-wide stochastic hybrid model of DNA re-replication, using the fission yeast (S. pombe) as a model organism to explore the interplay between deterministic mechanisms and inherent biological uncertainty.

The Stochastic Hybrid Model

To capture the complexity of re-replication, the researchers developed a model that integrates two distinct types of dynamics:

  1. Discrete Events: The "switch-like" firing of replication origins.
  2. Continuous Processes: The physical movement of replication forks along the DNA strand.

Unlike models of normal replication, this framework incorporates a "re-firing" mechanism. In this scenario, once an origin fires or is passively replicated, it can be re-licensed and fire again. This creates a positive feedback loop where newly synthesized DNA provides additional templates for further replication. The study compared two specific hypotheses: a "Limiting Factor" (LF) model, where a finite pool of proteins restricts firing, and an "Unlimited Factor" (UF) model.

Population Robustness vs. Single-Cell Chaos

A central finding of the research is a striking paradox: while re-replication profiles appear remarkably consistent and reproducible at the population level, they are incredibly chaotic at the single-cell level.

At the population scale, the model's simulated profiles showed a strong correlation with experimental Comparative Genomic Hybridization (CGH) data (Spearman $\rho \approx 0.5 - 0.61$). The model successfully predicted 64% of the major re-replication peaks observed in vivo. However, single-cell simulations and fluorescent imaging (using the LacO/LacI system) revealed that two cells with identical total DNA content could possess radically different genomic landscapes. This suggests that the "average" behavior of a tumor or cell population may hide a vast reservoir of genetic diversity.

Mechanistic Insights: In Cis and In Trans Effects

The model provided unique insights into how different regions of the genome interact during a re-replication event:

  • In Cis Positive Feedback: The firing of a strong origin replicates its neighboring sequences. This increases the local copy number of adjacent origins, providing them with more opportunities to fire. This leads to the formation of localized "hotspots" of massive DNA amplification.
  • In Trans Competition: The simulations revealed a competitive environment for replication machinery. If one genomic region (e.g., on Chromosome III) undergoes extensive amplification, it can suppress re-replication in distant regions by sequestering limiting replication factors. This global competition suggests that the amplification of one oncogene might come at the "expense" of replication in other parts of the genome.

Quantitative Results and Fork Dynamics

The study also shed light on the physical constraints of rogue replication. Simulations suggest that replication forks move significantly slower during re-replication (~0.5 kb/min) compared to normal mitosis (~1.6–3 kb/min). This deceleration is likely caused by the depletion of nucleotide pools or physical collisions between the myriad of forks moving simultaneously across the same DNA template.

Furthermore, the model highlighted the behavior of "weak" origins. While these origins rarely fire in a population-wide context, the stochastic nature of the system allows them to occasionally amplify to extreme copy numbers in individual cells, contributing to the overall genotypic heterogeneity.

Discussion: Re-replication as a Driver of Plasticity

The researchers propose that re-replication is more than just a cellular error; it is a mechanism for genome plasticity. By generating a wide array of diverse genotypes within a single population, re-replication allows for a form of biological "bet-hedging." In a changing environment—such as a patient undergoing chemotherapy—this diversity increases the probability that some cells will possess the genetic configurations necessary for survival and resistance.

While the model currently faces challenges in predicting amplification at subtelomeres (likely due to complex chromatin structures involving proteins like Rif1), it provides a robust foundation for future research. Expanding this stochastic hybrid approach to the larger, more complex human genome will be essential for understanding the mosaic of mutations that characterize human tumors and the evolutionary trajectories of cancer.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract DNA replication is a complex and remarkably robust process: despite its inherent uncertainty, manifested through stochastic replication timing at a single-cell level, multiple control mechanisms ensure its accurate and timely completion across a population. Disruptions in these mechanisms lead to DNA re-replication, closely connected to genomic instability and oncogenesis. We present a stochastic hybrid model of DNA re-replication that accurately portrays the interplay between discrete dynamics, continuous dynamics, and uncertainty. Using experimental data on the fission yeast genome, model simulations show how different regions respond to re-replication, and permit insight into the key mechanisms affecting re-replication dynamics. Simulated and experimental population-level profiles exhibit good correlation along the genome, which is robust to model parameters, validating our approach. At a single-cell level, copy numbers of individual loci are affected by intrinsic properties of each locus, in cis effects from adjoining loci and in trans effects from distant loci. In silico analysis and single-cell imaging reveal that cell-to-cell heterogeneity is inherent in re-replication and can lead to a plethora of genotypic variations. Our thorough in silico analysis of DNA re-replication across a complete genome reveals that heterogeneity at the single cell level and robustness at the population level are emerging and co-existing principles of DNA re-replication. Our results indicate that re-replication can promote genome plasticity by generating many diverse genotypes within a population, potentially offering an evolutionary advantage in cells with aberrations in replication control mechanisms.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{rapsomaniki2021i,
  author = {Maria Anna Rapsomaniki and Stella Maxouri and Manuel Ramírez Garrastacho and Patroula Nathanailidou and Nickolaos Nikiforos Giakoumakis and Stavros Taraviras and John Lygeros and Zoi Lygerou},
  title = {{<i>In silico</i> analysis of DNA re-replication across a complete genome reveals cell-to-cell heterogeneity and genome plasticity}},
  booktitle = {NAR},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1093/nargab/lqaa112},
}
Figure