E. coli 6S RNA complexed to RNA polymerase maintains product RNA synthesis at low cellular ATP levels by initiation with non-canonical initiator nucleotides

Christopher David Bonar, Jonathan Han, Robert Wang, S. Panchapakesan, Peter J. UnrauRNA 2022 · DOI

Abstract

The E. coli 6S RNA is an RNA polymerase (RNAP) inhibitor that competes with σ<sup>70</sup>-dependent DNA promoters for binding to RNAP holoenzyme (RNAP:σ<sup>70</sup>). The 6S RNA when bound is then used as a template to synthesize a short product RNA (pRNA; usually 13-nt-long). This pRNA changes the 6S RNA structure, triggering the 6S RNA:pRNA complex to release and allowing DNA-dependent housekeeping gene expression to resume. In high nutrient conditions, 6S RNA turnover is extremely rapid but becomes very slow in low nutrient environments. This leads to a large accumulation of inhibited RNAP:σ<sup>70</sup> in stationary phase. As pRNA initiates synthesis with ATP, we and others have proposed that the 6S RNA release rate strongly depends on ATP levels as a proxy for sensing the cellular metabolic state. By purifying endogenous 6S RNA:pRNA complexes using RNA Mango and using reverse transcriptase to generate pRNA-cDNA chimeras, we demonstrate that 6S RNA:pRNA formation can be simultaneous with 6S RNA 5' maturation. More importantly, we find a dramatic accumulation of capped pRNAs during stationary phase. This indicates that ATP levels in stationary phase are low enough for noncanonical initiator nucleotides (NCINs) such as NAD<sup>+</sup> and NADH to initiate pRNA synthesis. In vitro, mutation of the conserved 6S RNA template sequence immediately upstream of the pRNA transcriptional start site can increase or decrease the pRNA capping efficiency, suggesting that evolution has tuned the biological 6S RNA sequence for an optimal capping rate. NCIN-initiated pRNA synthesis may therefore be essential for cell viability in low nutrient conditions.

Introduction

In Escherichia coli, the transition from exponential growth to stationary phase requires a massive reorganization of the transcriptional landscape. A central regulator of this process is the 6S RNA, a small non-coding RNA that mimics the structure of an open DNA promoter. By binding to the RNA polymerase (RNAP) holoenzyme (RNAP:σ<sup>70</sup>), 6S RNA sequesters the enzyme and prevents the transcription of housekeeping genes.

To escape this inhibition, the RNAP uses the 6S RNA as a template to synthesize a short "product RNA" (pRNA), typically 13 nucleotides in length. The synthesis of pRNA induces a conformational change in the 6S RNA, leading to its release from the RNAP. Historically, this process was thought to be strictly dependent on ATP for initiation. However, during nutrient starvation (stationary phase), cellular ATP levels plummet. This creates a paradox: how can a cell release its inhibited RNAP to respond to new nutrients if it lacks sufficient ATP? This study investigates whether E. coli can use alternative molecules—specifically non-canonical initiator nucleotides (NCINs) like NAD<sup>+</sup>, NADH, and FAD—as "emergency starters" for pRNA synthesis.

Methods

To investigate the molecular mechanisms of pRNA synthesis in vivo, the researchers utilized a multi-faceted approach:

  • RNA Mango Affinity Purification: A Mango III aptamer was inserted into the ssrS (6S RNA) gene via CRISPR, allowing for the specific isolation of endogenous 6S RNA:pRNA complexes from E. coli cultures.
  • pRNA-cDNA Chimeras: Reverse transcription of the purified complexes generated chimeras that allowed for precise mapping of pRNA lengths and 5' end modifications.
  • APB-PAGE and Enzymatic Analysis: Acrylamido phenylboronic acid (APB) polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis was used to separate "capped" RNAs (those initiated with NCINs) from uncapped ones. The identity of these caps was confirmed using enzymes like NudC (specific for NAD<sup>+</sup> caps) and RppH.
Structural overview of 6S RNA, pRNA, and non-canonical initiator nucleotides (NCINs).

Results and Discussion

The NCIN Switch

The study revealed that E. coli utilizes NCINs such as NAD<sup>+</sup>, NADH, and FAD as alternative starters for pRNA synthesis. While only ~5% of pRNAs are capped with NCINs during exponential growth, this proportion increases to approximately 30% in stationary phase. This shift suggests that NCINs serve as a metabolic "fail-safe," allowing pRNA synthesis to continue even when ATP levels are critically low (estimated at ~1 µM in some stationary phase cells).

Simultaneous Maturation and Evolutionary Tuning

The researchers found that 6S RNA can initiate pRNA synthesis even before its own 5' end maturation is complete. Furthermore, they identified a critical residue, A45, located just upstream of the pRNA transcriptional start site (TSS). In vitro experiments demonstrated that mutations at this position could drastically alter capping efficiency. The natural conservation of this sequence suggests that the 6S RNA has been evolutionarily tuned to balance the use of ATP and NCINs, optimizing the cell's response to varying metabolic states.

Double-Sensing Mechanism

The pRNA synthesis process appears to involve a "double-sensing" of cellular energy. The first checkpoint occurs at initiation, where NCINs can substitute for ATP. A second checkpoint occurs at position +9 of the pRNA sequence, where the RNAP again samples the local nucleotide pool. This ensures that the full release of RNAP only occurs if the cell has sufficient resources to complete the pRNA and sustain subsequent transcription.

Conclusion

This work identifies NCIN-mediated initiation as a vital survival strategy for E. coli. By decoupling the release of inhibited RNAP from absolute ATP concentrations, the cell maintains transcriptional flexibility during periods of extreme nutrient stress. Future research will explore if this mechanism is conserved across other bacterial species and if these NCIN caps play additional roles in RNA stability or signaling.

Summary updated

Abstract

The <i>E. coli</i> 6S RNA is an RNA polymerase (RNAP) inhibitor that competes with σ<sup>70</sup>-dependent DNA promoters for binding to RNAP holoenzyme (RNAP:σ<sup>70</sup>). The 6S RNA when bound is then used as a template to synthesize a short product RNA (pRNA; usually 13-nt-long). This pRNA changes the 6S RNA structure, triggering the 6S RNA:pRNA complex to release and allowing DNA-dependent housekeeping gene expression to resume. In high nutrient conditions, 6S RNA turnover is extremely rapid but becomes very slow in low nutrient environments. This leads to a large accumulation of inhibited RNAP:σ<sup>70</sup> in stationary phase. As pRNA initiates synthesis with ATP, we and others have proposed that the 6S RNA release rate strongly depends on ATP levels as a proxy for sensing the cellular metabolic state. By purifying endogenous 6S RNA:pRNA complexes using RNA Mango and using reverse transcriptase to generate pRNA-cDNA chimeras, we demonstrate that 6S RNA:pRNA formation can be simultaneous with 6S RNA 5' maturation. More importantly, we find a dramatic accumulation of capped pRNAs during stationary phase. This indicates that ATP levels in stationary phase are low enough for noncanonical initiator nucleotides (NCINs) such as NAD<sup>+</sup> and NADH to initiate pRNA synthesis. In vitro, mutation of the conserved 6S RNA template sequence immediately upstream of the pRNA transcriptional start site can increase or decrease the pRNA capping efficiency, suggesting that evolution has tuned the biological 6S RNA sequence for an optimal capping rate. NCIN-initiated pRNA synthesis may therefore be essential for cell viability in low nutrient conditions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bonar2022i,
  author = {Christopher David Bonar and Jonathan Han and Robert Wang and S. Panchapakesan and Peter J. Unrau},
  title = {{<i>E. coli</i> 6S RNA complexed to RNA polymerase maintains product RNA synthesis at low cellular ATP levels by initiation with non-canonical initiator nucleotides}},
  booktitle = {RNA},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1261/rna.079356.122},
}
Figure