Hybrid Data-Driven and Analytical Model for Kinematic Control of a Surgical Robotic Tool

Francesco Cursi, Anh Nguyen, Guang-Zhong Yang

Introduction

Precise control of surgical robots is a matter of millimeters, but the physics of these tools is notoriously difficult to model. Most minimally invasive surgical tools are tendon-driven—controlled by internal cables similar to high-tech puppets. Because these tools are miniaturized and flexible, they suffer from "intrinsic nonlinearities" such as tendon stretching, slack, friction, and hysteresis.

The Micro-IGES surgical tool, a 4-DOF tendon-driven instrument featuring complex joints.

Engineers typically face a trade-off between analytical models, which use clean mathematics (like Denavit-Hartenberg conventions) that generalize well but oversimplify messy physics, and data-driven models, which use machine learning to capture complex behaviors but can be "brittle" in untrained regions of the workspace. This paper proposes a hybrid framework that uses machine learning to "patch" the errors in analytical mathematics.

Methodology

The authors utilize Gaussian Process Regression (GPR) as their primary data-driven tool. GPR is particularly useful because it provides both a prediction and a confidence interval (uncertainty). The proposed Hybrid Kinematic Model combines the analytical prediction ($P_a$) and the data-driven prediction ($P_d$) using a dynamic weighting matrix ($W$):

$$P = (I - W)P_d + WP_a$$

The weight $W$ is calculated based on model uncertainty and discrepancy. If the GPR is highly uncertain about a specific region of the workspace, the system shifts weight toward the reliable analytical model. The authors tested three integration strategies: learning the error directly ($GP_\epsilon$), using the analytical model as a "prior" for the GP ($GP_p$), and a pure data-driven approach ($GP_{np}$).

Experimental Results

The method was evaluated using both simulated data and real-world data from the Micro-IGES robotic surgical tool. To obtain ground-truth positions for the physical tool, an Intel Realsense stereo camera and a CSRT Tracker were used to follow the tool tip in 3D space.

Comparison of different Gaussian Process integration strategies ($GP_\epsilon$, $GP_p$, $GP_{np}$) against real and analytical data under varying analytical model accuracy.

The most effective approach was $GP_\epsilon$, where the machine learning model was specifically tasked with learning the difference between the math and reality. In simulations with a correct analytical model, the hybrid approach achieved a Root Mean Square Error (RMSE) as low as 0.7mm to 1.4mm across different axes. On the physical tool, the hybrid model provided a reasonable compromise, smoothing out the jittery predictions of the GP while staying significantly closer to real-world camera data than the analytical model alone.

Discussion and Conclusion

By using the variance provided by GPR, the hybrid model acts as a safety net; in unexplored regions where data is sparse, the system defaults back to the "safe" analytical physics model. While hybridization significantly boosts performance when the underlying analytical model is decent, the results show that the "correctness" of the base math still matters for optimal performance.

Future work will address the computational scalability of GPR, which currently limits training set sizes, and the automation of parameter tuning for the weighting function. The ultimate goal is the implementation of this hybrid model into real-time, closed-loop control systems for autonomous surgical tasks.

Summary updated

Abstract

Accurate kinematic models are essential for effective control of surgical robots. For tendon driven robots, which is common for minimally invasive surgery, intrinsic nonlinearities are important to consider. Traditional analytical methods allow to build the kinematic model of the system by making certain assumptions and simplifications on the nonlinearities. Machine learning techniques, instead, allow to recover a more complex model based on the acquired data. However, analytical models are more generalisable, but can be over-simplified; data-driven models, on the other hand, can cater for more complex models, but are less generalisable and the result is highly affected by the training dataset. In this paper, we present a novel approach to combining analytical and data-driven approaches to model the kinematics of nonlinear tendon-driven surgical robots. Gaussian Process Regression (GPR) is used for learning the data-driven model and the proposed method is tested on both simulated data and real experimental data.
BibTeX
@misc{cursi2020hybrid,
  author = {Francesco Cursi and Anh Nguyen and Guang-Zhong Yang},
  title = {{Hybrid Data-Driven and Analytical Model for Kinematic Control of a Surgical Robotic Tool}},
  year = {2020},
  eprint = {2006.03159},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2006.03159},
}
Figure