Human Hippocampal Theta Oscillations Organise Distance to Goal Coding

Zimo Huang, James A. Bisby, Neil Burgess, Daniel R. BushbioRxiv 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that human hippocampal theta oscillations play a crucial role in spatial navigation by encoding the distance to a goal, both during planning and active movement. The findings suggest that theta oscillations, in conjunction with gamma band activity, help organize spatial information for flexible navigation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Navigating effectively requires knowing where you are, where you're going, and how far away your destination is. While the hippocampus is known to be vital for spatial memory and navigation, the precise neural mechanisms by which it encodes information like distance to a goal, especially in humans, remain an active area of research. Previous studies in rodents have shown that hippocampal theta oscillations (a type of brainwave) increase with movement and correlate with distance. This paper aims to investigate whether similar theta oscillations in humans, using non-invasive methods, also encode goal distance during both the planning and execution phases of navigation in an abstract environment.

Methods

The researchers used magnetoencephalography (MEG) to record brain activity from 23 healthy participants performing an abstract navigation task on a 4x4 grid. Participants had to learn the layout of the grid and navigate to a specific goal image.

Key analytical techniques included:

  • Time-frequency analysis: To examine changes in oscillatory power (theta and gamma bands) over time.
  • MEG Source Reconstruction: Using a linearly constrained minimum variance (LCMV) beamformer to estimate the location of brain activity.
  • Linear Regression: To correlate neural activity (theta power, theta-gamma phase-amplitude coupling) with behavioral variables like distance to the goal and path novelty.
  • Phase-Amplitude Coupling (PAC) Analysis: To investigate how the phase of theta oscillations modulates the amplitude of gamma oscillations, a mechanism thought to support sequential memory.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Hippocampal Theta as a "Distance Meter": The study provides strong evidence that hippocampal theta power directly reflects the distance to a goal, both when participants are planning their route and when they are actively navigating. This suggests a dedicated neural mechanism for estimating spatial proximity.
  • Planning vs. Execution: The relationship between theta power and goal distance differs between planning and navigation. During planning, theta power increases with distance, potentially reflecting the retrieval of spatial information. During navigation, theta power decreases as the goal gets closer, possibly reflecting a more direct representation of remaining distance.
  • Novelty Matters for Planning: During the planning phase, the encoding of goal distance by theta power was primarily observed for previously experienced paths, suggesting that retrieval of learned routes plays a key role in estimating distance.
  • Theta-Gamma Coupling for Navigation: The interplay between theta and gamma oscillations (phase-amplitude coupling) also changes with proximity to the goal. Specifically, theta-fast gamma coupling in the entorhinal cortex is linked to encoding new paths, while theta-slow gamma coupling in the hippocampus is associated with retrieving familiar paths. This highlights a sophisticated neural code for navigating different types of routes.

Key Results

  • Planning: Increased 2-5 Hz theta power in the right hippocampus correlated positively with the shortest path distance to the goal during the planning phase, but only when participants knew the shortest path.
  • Navigation: During navigation, hippocampal theta power (both 2-5 Hz and 6-9 Hz) decreased as participants approached the goal, and this decrease was more pronounced in correct trials where participants knew the shortest path. This distance-to-goal coding during navigation was not dependent on whether the path was novel or previously traversed.
  • Theta-Gamma Coupling: Theta-gamma phase-amplitude coupling increased as participants approached the goal. Fast gamma in the entorhinal cortex was linked to novel paths, while slow gamma in the hippocampus was linked to previously traversed paths.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Abstract Environment: The study used an abstract navigation task, which may not fully capture the complexities of real-world navigation. Future work could explore these findings in more naturalistic or virtual environments.
  • Causality: While the study shows strong correlations, it doesn't establish direct causality. Future research could employ techniques like transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) to directly manipulate theta activity and observe its effect on navigation.
  • Individual Differences: The study focused on healthy participants, and it would be interesting to investigate how these mechanisms differ in populations with spatial navigation deficits, such as those with Alzheimer's disease or hippocampal lesions.
  • Integration with Other Brain Areas: While the hippocampus and entorhinal cortex were highlighted, future research could explore the role of other brain regions in this goal-directed navigation network.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The rodent hippocampal local field potential is dominated by 6-12 Hz theta oscillations during active behaviour that are strongly implicated in spatial coding and memory function across species. Invasive electrophysiology in both rodents and humans has shown increases in hippocampal theta power immediately before the onset of translational movement that persists throughout subsequent motion, and the magnitude of this increase correlates with the distance subsequently travelled. Using non-invasive magnetoencephalography (MEG) and an abstract navigation task, we observed increased theta power during both spatial planning and subsequent navigation. Importantly, theta power in the right hippocampus covaried with subsequent path distance during planning, only when participants were aware of the distance to their goal. During subsequent navigation, hippocampal theta power decreased dynamically as participants approached the goal, only when they were aware of how far they still needed to travel. In addition, theta phase during navigation modulated 70-140 Hz fast gamma amplitude in the entorhinal cortex while traversing novel paths; and 30-70 Hz slow gamma amplitude in the right hippocampus while traversing previously experienced paths. In both cases, theta-gamma phase-amplitude coupling increased with proximity to the goal during navigation, consistent with the hypothesis that sequences of upcoming locations were represented by gamma bursts occurring at successive theta phases. In sum, these findings are consistent with the proposed role of hippocampal theta oscillation in flexible planning and goal-directed spatial navigation across mammalian species.
BibTeX
@misc{huang2024human,
  author = {Zimo Huang and James A. Bisby and Neil Burgess and Daniel R. Bush},
  title = {{Human Hippocampal Theta Oscillations Organise Distance to Goal Coding}},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1101/2024.12.12.628182},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure