Human-AI Coevolution (Abstract Reprint)

Dino Pedreschi, Luca Pappalardo, Emanuele Ferragina, Ricardo Baeza-Yates, Albert-László Barabási, Frank Dignum, Virginia Dignum, Tina Eliassi-Rad, Fosca Giannotti, János Kertész, Alistair Knott, Yannis E. Ioannidis, Paul Lukowicz, Andrea Passarella, Alex 'Sandy' Pentland, John Shawe-Taylor, Alessandro Vespignani

Introduction

In the traditional paradigm of computer science, Artificial Intelligence (AI) is often treated as a static tool—a discrete artifact evaluated by its performance on fixed benchmarks. However, as AI systems become increasingly integrated into the fabric of daily life, this perspective is becoming obsolete. This paper introduces the concept of Human-AI Coevolution, a critical new field of study situated at the intersection of AI and complexity science. It argues that we must shift our focus from individual models to the "endless feedback loop" where AI shapes human behavior and human data, in turn, reshapes the AI, leading to complex and often unintended systemic consequences.

The Problem: The Gap in Traditional Evaluation

Traditional AI evaluation typically occurs in a vacuum, measuring accuracy or efficiency on static datasets. In real-world applications—particularly within recommender systems and digital assistants—AI is not a passive observer but a dynamic participant.

When an algorithm suggests a news article or a product, it does more than predict a preference; it actively influences the user's future choices. These influenced choices then become the training data for the next iteration of the algorithm. This recursive relationship creates a dynamic system that traditional Human-Machine Interaction (HMI) frameworks are ill-equipped to analyze. Without a dedicated field to study these interactions, we remain unable to predict or mitigate systemic outcomes such as algorithmic bias, the formation of echo chambers, or the gradual erosion of human agency.

A Multi-Disciplinary Conceptual Framework

To address these challenges, the authors propose a foundational roadmap that merges three distinct pillars:

  1. Complexity Science: Utilized to model the emergent properties of large-scale systems where numerous agents (both human and AI) interact in non-linear ways.
  2. Artificial Intelligence: To provide a deep understanding of the underlying model architectures and learning mechanics.
  3. Mathematical Modeling: To formally map the dynamics of the human-AI feedback loop and identify potential points of equilibrium or divergence.

By evaluating existing methodologies, the paper identifies a significant shortfall in current research: the failure to capture the feedback mechanisms that define the intersection of technology and society.

Key Insights: The Dynamics of the Loop

The cornerstone of this research is the formalization of the Feedback Loop. The process is cyclical and self-reinforcing:

  • Data Generation: Users generate behavioral data.
  • Model Training: This data is used to train or update AI models.
  • Behavioral Shaping: The AI influences user preferences and decision-making.
  • Recursive Input: Users generate new, potentially biased data based on the AI’s influence, which feeds back into the system.

Because these systems are "complex" in a mathematical sense, their outcomes are often non-linear. This means that small changes in an algorithm can lead to massive, unpredictable shifts in societal behavior. Consequently, the authors argue that recommender systems are not merely mirrors of our interests; they are active agents in the evolution of human culture.

Systemic Results and Manifestos

The paper serves as a manifesto for a new research agenda, formalizing Human-AI Coevolution as a distinct area of inquiry. Its primary contributions include:

  • Identifying recommender systems as the most urgent and prominent example of coevolutionary dynamics in the modern world.
  • Providing a roadmap for investigating the theoretical and empirical aspects of these loops in real-world ecosystems rather than isolated laboratory simulations.
  • Asserting that the challenges of AI cannot be solved through engineering alone; they require a holistic "scientific, legal, and socio-political" conceptualization.

Limitations and Future Directions

The authors acknowledge that current scientific tools are insufficient for the task at hand. We currently lack the mathematical precision required to predict the long-term evolutionary path of human-AI systems. Furthermore, legal and policy frameworks often treat AI as a static product, creating a gap in accountability for harms that emerge from the coevolutionary process.

Future work must focus on developing new "feedback loop mechanisms" that can monitor and potentially steer these systems toward beneficial societal outcomes. The authors call for a cross-disciplinary bridge between complexity scientists and AI researchers to tackle the scientific and ethical hurdles of our coevolving digital future.

Summary updated

Abstract

Human-AI coevolution, defined as a process in which humans and AI algorithms continuously influence each other, increasingly characterises our society, but is understudied in artificial intelligence and complexity science literature. Recommender systems and assistants play a prominent role in human-AI coevolution, as they permeate many facets of daily life and influence human choices through online platforms. The interaction between users and AI results in a potentially endless feedback loop, wherein users' choices generate data to train AI models, which, in turn, shape subsequent user preferences. This human-AI feedback loop has peculiar characteristics compared to traditional human-machine interaction and gives rise to complex and often “unintended” systemic outcomes. This paper introduces human-AI coevolution as the cornerstone for a new field of study at the intersection between AI and complexity science focused on the theoretical, empirical, and mathematical investigation of the human-AI feedback loop. In doing so, we: (i) outline the pros and cons of existing methodologies and highlight shortcomings and potential ways for capturing feedback loop mechanisms; (ii) propose a reflection at the intersection between complexity science, AI and society; (iii) provide real-world examples for different human-AI ecosystems; and (iv) illustrate challenges to the creation of such a field of study, conceptualising them at increasing levels of abstraction, i.e., scientific, legal and socio-political.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{pedreschi2025human,
  author = {Dino Pedreschi and Luca Pappalardo and Emanuele Ferragina and Ricardo Baeza-Yates and Albert-László Barabási and Frank Dignum and Virginia Dignum and Tina Eliassi-Rad and Fosca Giannotti and János Kertész and Alistair Knott and Yannis E. Ioannidis and Paul Lukowicz and Andrea Passarella and Alex 'Sandy' Pentland and John Shawe-Taylor and Alessandro Vespignani},
  title = {{Human-AI Coevolution (Abstract Reprint)}},
  booktitle = {International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.24963/ijcai.2025/1231},
}
Figure