How Retroactivity Affects the Behavior of Incoherent Feed-Forward Loops

Junmin Wang, Călin Belta, Samuel A. Isaacson

Abstract

An incoherent feed-forward loop (IFFL) is a network motif known for its ability to accelerate responses and generate pulses. Though functions of IFFLs are well studied, most previous computational analysis of IFFLs used ordinary differential equation (ODE) models where retroactivity—the effect downstream binding sites exert on the dynamics of an upstream transcription factor (TF)—was not considered. It remains an open question to understand the behavior of IFFLs in contexts with high levels of retroactivity, e.g., in cells transformed/transfected with high-copy plasmids, or in eukaryotic cells where a TF binds to numerous high-affinity binding sites in addition to one or more functional target sites. Here we study the behavior of IFFLs by simulating and comparing ODE models with different levels of retroactivity. We find that increasing retroactivity in an IFFL can increase, decrease, or keep the network's response time and pulse amplitude constant. This suggests that increasing retroactivity, traditionally considered as an impediment to designing robust synthetic systems, could be exploited to improve the performance of IFFLs. We compare the behaviors of IFFLs to negative autoregulatory loops, another sign-sensitive response-accelerating network motif, and find that increasing retroactivity in a negative autoregulated circuit can only slow the response. The inability of a negative autoregulatory loop to flexibly handle retroactivity may have contributed to its lower abundance in eukaryotic relative to bacterial regulatory networks, a sharp contrast to the significant abundance of IFFLs in both cell types.

Introduction: Modularity vs. Retroactivity

In synthetic and systems biology, a common assumption is "modularity"—the idea that a gene's behavior depends only on its inputs, not its outputs. However, real biological systems experience retroactivity. This phenomenon occurs when a transcription factor (TF) binds to its target DNA or "decoy" sites, effectively sequestering the protein and slowing its concentration dynamics. While often viewed as a nuisance in circuit design, this study explores whether retroactivity can be leveraged to enhance the performance of common network motifs, specifically the Incoherent Feed-Forward Loop (IFFL).

Schematic of Incoherent Feed-Forward Loop (IFFL) motifs (I1-I4) where Node A activates Node C directly and indirectly via Node B.

Methods

The researchers employed a computational framework using Ordinary Differential Equations (ODEs) modified with a "retroactivity matrix" to simulate protein production and decay under varying loads. They used Latin Hypercube Sampling to explore vast parameter spaces and validated their evolutionary hypotheses using transcriptional regulatory data from E. coli (RegulonDB) and mammalian systems (TTRUST).

Key Results: Turning a Bug into a Feature

The study's most significant finding is that retroactivity can paradoxically improve circuit performance. In an I1-FFL, Node A activates both Node B and Node C, while Node B inhibits Node C. When retroactivity is applied to the intermediate regulator (Node B), it delays the inhibitory signal. This "regulatory delay advantage" allows Node C to reach its halfway point faster and peak at a higher concentration before the inhibition takes effect.

Overview of IFFL network motifs, temporal response metrics (Response Time and Pulse Amplitude), and the mechanistic model of retroactivity involving TF sequestration.

Key performance impacts include:

  • Response Acceleration: Increasing retroactivity on Node B consistently shortened the response time (RT) of the output.
  • Pulse Amplification: Retroactivity on Node B was proven to always increase the pulse amplitude (PA) of the output.
  • Functional Versatility: Unlike Negative Autoregulatory (NAR) loops, which only slow down under retroactivity, IFFLs can speed up, slow down, or maintain their response time depending on where the load is applied.

Evolutionary Implications

The flexibility of IFFLs in handling retroactivity may explain their ubiquity across different domains of life. While NAR loops are common in bacteria, they are rare in eukaryotes, which possess a high "genomic load" of decoy binding sites. IFFLs, by contrast, are abundant in both, suggesting they were evolutionarily favored for their ability to function—and even thrive—in high-retroactivity environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

An incoherent feed-forward loop (IFFL) is a network motif known for its ability to accelerate responses and generate pulses. Though functions of IFFLs are well studied, most previous computational analysis of IFFLs used ordinary differential equation (ODE) models where retroactivity, the effect downstream binding sites exert on the dynamics of an upstream transcription factor (TF), was not considered. It remains an open question to understand the behavior of IFFLs in contexts with high levels of retroactivity, e.g., in cells transformed/transfected with high-copy plasmids, or in eukaryotic cells where a TF binds to numerous high-affinity binding sites in addition to one or more functional target sites. Here we study the behavior of IFFLs by simulating and comparing ODE models with different levels of retroactivity. We find that increasing retroactivity in an IFFL can increase, decrease, or keep the network's response time and pulse amplitude constant. This suggests that increasing retroactivity, traditionally considered as an impediment to designing robust synthetic systems, could be exploited to improve the performance of IFFLs. We compare the behaviors of IFFLs to negative autoregulatory loops, another sign-sensitive response-accelerating network motif, and find that increasing retroactivity in a negative autoregulated circuit can only slow the response. The inability of a negative autoregulatory loop to flexibly handle retroactivity may have contributed to its lower abundance in eukaryotic relative to bacterial regulatory networks, a sharp contrast to the significant abundance of IFFLs in both cell types.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2020how,
  author = {Junmin Wang and Călin Belta and Samuel A. Isaacson},
  title = {{How Retroactivity Affects the Behavior of Incoherent Feed-Forward Loops}},
  booktitle = {iScience},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1016/j.isci.2020.101779},
}
Figure