Personal Narratives Empower Politically Disinclined Individuals to Engage in Political Discussions

Tejasvi Chebrolu, Ponnurangam Kumaraguru, Ashwin Rajadesingan

Introduction

Online political discourse is frequently dominated by a vocal minority of hyperpartisan individuals, often leading to echo chambers and the marginalization of the "politically disinclined" (PDI)—the moderate majority who avoid political engagement due to perceived knowledge gaps, fear of conflict, or a sense of disconnection. This study investigates how personal narratives—short, first-person accounts of lived experiences—can serve as a "low-barrier" entry point for these individuals, empowering them to participate in democratic discussions.

Methodology

The researchers analyzed approximately 26.3 million Reddit users across 483 political subreddits from 2020 to 2021 using the Pushshift Reddit Archive. They employed a BERT-based transformer model, fine-tuned on a custom dataset of 2,000 manually annotated comments, to classify personal narratives. To handle the rarity of narratives, they used a "pseudo-labeling" strategy to identify candidates before manual verification. Users were stratified into groups: "Most active" (top 25th percentile), "Least active" (bottom 25th percentile), and "Newcomers" (active on Reddit but new to political subreddits). Statistical significance was determined using random-effects logistic and linear regressions to control for subreddit-specific factors and post visibility.

Key Findings

Personal Narratives as an Entry Point

The data reveals that PDIs and newcomers rely heavily on personal stories to enter political conversations. Newcomers were found to use narratives at a rate of 15.31%, compared to only 7.57% for the most active users. This suggests that when individuals lack formal argumentative expertise or deep policy knowledge, they default to sharing personal experiences as a legitimate and accessible form of contribution.

Mean personal narrative usage across user groups.

Impact on Retention and Engagement

Sharing a personal narrative is a strong predictor of sustained participation. PDIs who utilized narratives had a significantly higher probability (~28.8%) of returning to the political community the following month compared to those who did not (~21.5%). Furthermore, narrative-based comments were approximately 30% more likely to receive responses from other PDIs, suggesting that these stories foster a more inclusive and less intimidating environment for the moderate majority.

Community Reception and the Perception Gap

One of the most striking findings is the effect of narratives on community reception. While "power users" typically receive higher karma scores (a proxy for community value), the use of personal narratives significantly boosts the scores of PDIs. This shift effectively reduces the "perception gap"—the difference in community valuation between power users and PDIs—by roughly 40%.

Mean karma scores for different user groups, comparing personal narratives to other comments.

Discussion and Limitations

Personal narratives appear to humanize the speaker, making their contributions harder to dismiss and more respected across partisan lines. Unlike data-heavy arguments, narratives rely on situated knowledge that is difficult to refute with traditional counter-arguments. However, the study notes several limitations. The findings are platform-specific to Reddit's karma system and were collected during the unique socio-political climate of the COVID-19 pandemic. Additionally, while narratives increase engagement, they can also be vehicles for anecdotal fallacies or misinformation. Future research should explore whether these online engagement patterns translate into tangible offline political actions, such as increased voter turnout.

Conclusion

By lowering the barrier to entry and improving community reception, personal narratives provide a vital mechanism for re-engaging the "reclusive" majority in political discourse. Encouraging narrative-based communication may be a key strategy for reducing affective polarization and fostering a more representative democratic dialogue in digital spaces.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{chebrolu2025personal,
  author = {Tejasvi Chebrolu and Ponnurangam Kumaraguru and Ashwin Rajadesingan},
  title = {{Personal Narratives Empower Politically Disinclined Individuals to Engage in Political Discussions}},
  booktitle = {WebSci},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1145/3717867.3717899},
}
Figure