TL;DR
This paper introduces a novel methodology to numerically assess 5G electromagnetic field (EMF) exposure for children, teenagers, schools, and hospitals. Their findings indicate that while 5G exposure will increase, it remains well below international safety limits, and building attenuation significantly impacts these levels, especially for higher 5G frequencies.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The widespread deployment of 5G technology raises public concern about potential health impacts, particularly for vulnerable groups like children and in sensitive locations like schools and hospitals. While regulations exist for EMF exposure, there's a need for detailed, scenario-specific assessments that account for the unique characteristics of 5G, such as its higher frequencies and advanced antenna technologies (MIMO, beamforming). Existing studies often focus on pre-5G technologies or lack the granular detail to assess exposure in these specific "sensitive" environments. This paper aims to bridge this gap by providing a robust methodology and applying it to real-world scenarios to quantify 5G exposure for these groups.
Methods
The authors developed an end-to-end geospatial methodology for EMF exposure assessment. Key steps include:
- Building Modeling: Creating 3D models of buildings, including their altitude, height, shape, and type (school, medical center, other).
- Population Modeling: Estimating the number of children, teenagers, and adults within each building based on census data and building volume.
- Tower Characterization: Collecting real-world data on cellular tower locations, operators, antenna orientations, and heights.
- 5G Radio Configuration Modeling: Defining realistic 5G radio configurations, including the deployment of quadri-band (2G/4G/sub-GHz 5G), 5G mid-band, and 5G mm-Wave panels. This accounts for the technical features of 5G antennas.
- Pixel Exposure Computation: Dividing building eaves into small pixels and numerically evaluating the EMF exposure from each radiating source to each pixel. This involves complex calculations of antenna gain, distance, and attenuation.
- Building and Population Metrics Derivation: Calculating average exposure levels for buildings (schools, medical centers, all buildings) and for different population groups (children/teenagers, adults, total population).
A novel aspect is the integration of 5G-specific parameters like MIMO and dynamic beamforming, and the use of realistic radio configurations. They also consider building attenuation and, in a separate analysis, weather conditions.
Datasets
The study utilized real-world data for two scenarios in Rome, Italy:
- Spinaceto: A sparse district with lower and less uniform building density.
- Ponte-Parione: A dense city-center neighborhood.
Building data was sourced from the national geoportal database. Population data was obtained from the 2011 ISTAT census. Tower data was collected through a driving-based approach using a Rohde&Schwarz TSMA6 network scanner, cross-referenced with operator authorization documents.
Key Insights and Ideas
- 5G Exposure Will Increase, But Remains Safe: As 5G adoption grows, exposure levels from cellular towers will naturally increase. However, these levels are consistently found to be well below international safety limits.
- Building Attenuation is Crucial: The impact of buildings on EMF exposure is significant, particularly for higher 5G frequencies (mm-Wave). This attenuation can substantially reduce the received exposure, especially for "thermally-efficient" buildings.
- Children and Teenagers Exposure Mirrors General Population: The exposure levels for children and teenagers are found to be similar to those of the general population, suggesting that specific protective measures beyond those for the general public might not be immediately necessary based on these findings.
- Sensitive Buildings Show Varied Exposure: Exposure in schools and medical centers can be lower than the average for all buildings, likely due to their specific locations and construction.
- Pre-5G vs. 5G Dynamics: In the early stages of 5G adoption, pre-5G technologies contribute more to the overall exposure. As 5G matures, its contribution increases, eventually becoming the dominant source, especially in dense areas.
Key Results
- Exposure Levels Below Limits: In both Spinaceto and Ponte-Parione scenarios, all calculated exposure levels (total, 5G, pre-5G) remained significantly below the ICNIRP whole-body limits for the general public (28 V/m for general public, 61 V/m for specific frequencies).
- Ponte-Parione Higher Exposure: Due to higher tower density, Ponte-Parione generally exhibited higher average exposure levels compared to Spinaceto, even with stronger statistical power reduction factors applied in the denser area.
- Building Type Matters: Traditional buildings showed a larger reduction in EMF exposure due to attenuation compared to thermally-efficient buildings, especially for 5G frequencies.
- Rain Impact is Limited: While rain can affect path loss, its impact on overall exposure levels was found to be relatively minor, particularly for sub-6 GHz frequencies, due to the short distances between towers and pixels.
Limitations and Future Work
- Indoor Exposure Coarseness: The study acknowledges that its indoor exposure assessment is coarse, primarily focusing on eaves level. A detailed floor-by-floor and room-by-room analysis would require significantly more building detail than available in the scenarios.
- Temporal Variation: The methodology focuses on long-term average exposure rather than instantaneous variations due to traffic.
- User Equipment Mobility: The analysis assumes a low-mobility scenario for 5G antennas. Increased mobility could lead to lower exposure, but this was not deeply explored.
- Future Work: The authors suggest extending the assessment to entire municipalities, including 5G small cells. They also propose performing extensive EMF measurements, especially indoors, and investigating joint uplink and downlink 5G exposure.
Summary updated