How Much and When Do We Need Higher-order Informationin Hypergraphs? A Case Study on Hyperedge Prediction

Se-eun Yoon, HyungSeok Song, Kijung Shin, Yung Yi

Abstract

Hypergraphs are increasingly used to model group interactions, such as research collaborations or protein complexes, where standard graphs fail to capture the "group-ness" of the data. However, processing higher-order relations is computationally demanding. This study introduces the $n$-projected graph framework to systematically evaluate the necessity of higher-order information for hyperedge prediction. Through an analysis of 15 real-world datasets, we demonstrate a law of diminishing returns: the transition from pairwise to triadic interactions provides the most significant accuracy boost, while further complexity often yields marginal improvements.

Introduction

In network science, hypergraphs offer a more nuanced representation of data by allowing edges (hyperedges) to connect any number of nodes. While powerful, they introduce significant computational overhead. A common simplification is "clique expansion," which reduces group interactions to a set of pairwise edges. However, this abstraction loses the higher-order context—the unique dynamics that occur only when a specific group acts as a unit. The central challenge lies in the complexity-accuracy trade-off: how much "order" is truly necessary for tasks like hyperedge prediction?

Methodology: $n$-Projected Graphs

To address this, we propose the $n$-projected graph ($G_n$) framework. This approach allows for an incremental increase in the order of information modeled:

  • $G_2$ (2-projected graph): A standard graph where nodes represent individuals.
  • $G_3$ (3-projected graph): Nodes represent pairs of individuals. An edge exists between two pairs if they share a common member and all three individuals appeared together in a hyperedge.
  • $G_n$ (n-order expansion): This generalizes to higher orders, creating a hierarchy of representations that "dial up" complexity.
The n-projected graph framework allows for systematic expansion of hypergraph information into lower-order graph structures.

We generalized classic link prediction metrics—such as the Jaccard Coefficient and Adamic-Adar—to operate on these higher-order projections. A logistic regression classifier was then employed to measure the performance gain (AUC-PR) as the order $n$ increased.

Experimental Results

The framework was tested on 15 real-world datasets across domains including communication, biology, and social networks.

The Law of Diminishing Returns

The most striking finding is the significant impact of triadic information. Moving from $n=2$ (pairwise) to $n=3$ (triadic) improved prediction performance by an average of 61% for size-4 hyperedges and 94% for size-5. In contrast, the step from $n=3$ to $n=4$ yielded only a 6% average improvement.

Performance comparison (AUC-PR) between different orders of information, illustrating the diminishing returns beyond 3rd-order data.

The "Troubleshooter" Effect

Higher-order information becomes indispensable in "hard" prediction scenarios. For instance, pairwise data cannot distinguish a true hyperedge from a "clique" (a group where all members are connected in pairs but do not form a functional group). In these cases, higher-order data acts as a vital troubleshooter to break the tie.

Irreducibility and Group Formation

Information-theoretic analysis revealed that some networks are "irreducible," meaning higher-order interactions contain unique information that cannot be inferred from pairs. In coauthorship data, a performance jump at $n=8$ or $9$ for predicting 10-person papers suggests an "invitation" phenomenon, where a large existing core invites a few new members.

Conclusion

Our study suggests that modeling the full, infinite complexity of a hypergraph is often unnecessary. For most practical applications, stopping at $n=3$ or $n=4$ provides a near-perfect approximation of group dynamics. While future work should explore whether deep learning models can better exploit higher-order data, the current evidence points to triadic interactions as the "sweet spot" for hyperedge prediction.

Summary updated

Abstract

Hypergraphs provide a natural way of representing group relations, whose complexity motivates an extensive array of prior work to adopt some form of abstraction and simplification of higher-order interactions. However, the following question has yet to be addressed: How much abstraction of group interactions is sufficient in solving a hypergraph task, and how different such results become across datasets? This question, if properly answered, provides a useful engineering guideline on how to trade off between complexity and accuracy of solving a downstream task. To this end, we propose a method of incrementally representing group interactions using a notion of n-projected graph whose accumulation contains information on up to n-way interactions, and quantify the accuracy of solving a task as n grows for various datasets. As a downstream task, we consider hyperedge prediction, an extension of link prediction, which is a canonical task for evaluating graph models. Through experiments on 15 real-world datasets, we draw the following messages: (a) Diminishing returns: small n is enough to achieve accuracy comparable with near-perfect approximations, (b) Troubleshooter: as the task becomes more challenging, larger n brings more benefit, and (c) Irreducibility: datasets whose pairwise interactions do not tell much about higher-order interactions lose much accuracy when reduced to pairwise abstractions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yoon2020how,
  author = {Se-eun Yoon and HyungSeok Song and Kijung Shin and Yung Yi},
  title = {{How Much and When Do We Need Higher-order Informationin Hypergraphs? A Case Study on Hyperedge Prediction}},
  booktitle = {The Web Conference},
  year = {2020},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=ou_iKgP88M},
}
Figure