How cy pres promotes transdisciplinary convergence science: an academic health center for women’s cardiovascular and brain health

Amparo C. Villablanca, Brittany N. Dugger, Saivageethi Nuthikattu, Joohi Chauhan, Samson Cheung, Chen‐Nee Chuah, Siedah L. Garrison, Dragan Milenković, Jennifer Norman, Luca Cerny Oliveira, Bridgette P. Smith, Susan D. BrownJournal of Clinical and Translational Science 2024 · DOI

Abstract

Cardiovascular disease (CVD) is largely preventable, and the leading cause of death for men and women. Though women have increased life expectancy compared to men, there are marked sex disparities in prevalence and risk of CVD-associated mortality and dementia. Yet, the basis for these and female-male differences is not completely understood. It is increasingly recognized that heart and brain health represent a lifetime of exposures to shared risk factors (including obesity, hyperlipidemia, diabetes, and hypertension) that compromise cerebrovascular health. We describe the process and resources for establishing a new research Center for Women's Cardiovascular and Brain Health at the University of California, Davis as a model for: (1) use of the cy pres principle for funding science to improve health; (2) transdisciplinary collaboration to leapfrog progress in a convergence science approach that acknowledges and addresses social determinants of health; and (3) training the next generation of diverse researchers. This may serve as a blueprint for future Centers in academic health institutions, as the cy pres mechanism for funding research is a unique mechanism to leverage residual legal settlement funds to catalyze the pace of scientific discovery, maximize innovation, and promote health equity in addressing society's most vexing health problems.

Introduction: The Heart-Brain Connection in Women's Health

Cardiovascular disease remains the leading cause of death globally. While often perceived as a male-centric issue, women face unique risks and significant sex disparities in both CVD prevalence and mortality. Crucially, heart health is inextricably linked to brain health; a lifetime of exposure to shared risk factors—such as obesity, diabetes, and hypertension—compromises the cerebrovascular system, leading to increased rates of dementia in women.

The integrated approach to heart and brain health.

Despite these links, medical research has traditionally operated in silos, with cardiologists and neurologists working independently. The UC Davis Center for Women’s Cardiovascular and Brain Health was established to bridge this gap, utilizing a "convergence science" approach to address the social and biological determinants of these conditions.

The Cy Pres Principle: A Novel Funding Catalyst

One of the most innovative aspects of the Center is its funding model. The cy pres (French for "as close as possible") principle allows residual funds from class-action legal settlements to be directed toward charitable purposes that benefit the class members. In this instance, a settlement involving hormone replacement therapy provided the "catalyst" funding necessary to establish a transdisciplinary infrastructure that traditional, often risk-averse, federal grants might be slow to support. This mechanism allows academic health centers to leverage legal outcomes to promote health equity and scientific discovery.

A Convergence Science Framework

To move beyond simple multidisciplinary cooperation, the Center employs a convergence science framework. This model integrates disparate fields—from computer engineering to nutrition—into a unified intellectual space.

The Convergence Science framework integrating Basic Science, Behavioral Science, and Neuropathology.

The Center is organized into three synergistic Cores:

  • Behavioral and Implementation Science Core: This core focuses on the "biology of adversity," examining how social determinants of health (SDoH), such as food insecurity and discrimination, act as upstream factors for biological disruption. A primary focus is maternal health equity, investigating how adverse pregnancy outcomes predict long-term CVD risk.
  • Neuropathology and Machine Learning Core: To overcome the "Valley of Death" in human brain tissue research, this core utilizes artificial intelligence to automate the detection of microvascular injuries (microinfarcts). This AI-driven approach reduces human bias and increases the throughput of pathology studies.
  • Basic Science, Animal Modeling, and Multiomics Core: Using murine models, researchers study how metabolic stressors like high-sugar diets affect gene expression. By employing single-cell RNA sequencing, the team identifies sex-specific molecular targets that may explain why women’s brains and hearts respond differently to metabolic stress.

Key Insights and Results

The Center’s integrated approach has already yielded significant insights:

  • Automated Pathology: The development of computationally efficient AI frameworks for analyzing gigapixel histopathology images has significantly reduced inter-rater variability among pathologists, providing a more objective measure of brain health.
  • Sex-Specific Molecular Signatures: Preliminary basic science data indicates that metabolic stress induces distinct transcriptomic profiles in males versus females. Specifically, neuroprotective pathways appear more active in females, while neurodegenerative pathways dominated in males under identical stressors, suggesting a need for sex-specific therapeutic interventions.
  • Addressing the Microvasculature: While clinical focus often rests on large arteries, the Center highlights microvascular injury as the common link between heart and brain decline, offering a new target for early prevention.

Conclusion: A Blueprint for Future Innovation

The UC Davis Center for Women’s Cardiovascular and Brain Health serves as a replicable model for other institutions. By leveraging cy pres funding to break down academic silos and focus on the intersection of heart and brain health through a health-equity lens, the Center aims to leapfrog traditional research barriers. This blueprint demonstrates how legal settlements can be transformed into powerful engines for scientific innovation and public health improvement.

Summary updated

Abstract

Cardiovascular disease (CVD) is largely preventable, and the leading cause of death for men and women. Though women have increased life expectancy compared to men, there are marked sex disparities in prevalence and risk of CVD-associated mortality and dementia. Yet, the basis for these and female-male differences is not completely understood. It is increasingly recognized that heart and brain health represent a lifetime of exposures to shared risk factors (including obesity, hyperlipidemia, diabetes, and hypertension) that compromise cerebrovascular health. We describe the process and resources for establishing a new research Center for Women's Cardiovascular and Brain Health at the University of California, Davis as a model for: (1) use of the <i>cy pres</i> principle for funding science to improve health; (2) transdisciplinary collaboration to leapfrog progress in a convergence science approach that acknowledges and addresses social determinants of health; and (3) training the next generation of diverse researchers. This may serve as a blueprint for future Centers in academic health institutions, as the <i>cy pres</i> mechanism for funding research is a unique mechanism to leverage residual legal settlement funds to catalyze the pace of scientific discovery, maximize innovation, and promote health equity in addressing society's most vexing health problems.
BibTeX
@article{villablanca2024how,
  author = {Amparo C. Villablanca and Brittany N. Dugger and Saivageethi Nuthikattu and Joohi Chauhan and Samson Cheung and Chen‐Nee Chuah and Siedah L. Garrison and Dragan Milenković and Jennifer Norman and Luca Cerny Oliveira and Bridgette P. Smith and Susan D. Brown},
  title = {{How <i>cy pres</i> promotes transdisciplinary convergence science: an academic health center for women’s cardiovascular and brain health}},
  journal = {Journal of Clinical and Translational Science},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1017/cts.2023.705},
}
Figure