Abstract
Sparse cutting-planes are often the ones used in mixed-integer programing (MIP) solvers, since they help in solving the linear programs encountered during branch-and-bound more efficiently. However, how well can we approximate the integer hull by just using sparse cutting-planes? In order to understand this question better, given a polytope $P$ (e.g. the integer hull of a MIP), let $P^k$ be its best approximation using cuts with at most $k$ non-zero coefficients. We consider $d(P, P^k) = \max_{x \in P^k} \left(\min_{y \in P} \| x - y\|\right)$ as a measure of the quality of sparse cuts. In our first result, we present general upper bounds on $d(P, P^k)$ which depend on the number of vertices in the polytope and exhibits three phases as $k$ increases. Our bounds imply that if $P$ has polynomially many vertices, using half sparsity already approximates it very well. Second, we present a lower bound on $d(P, P^k)$ for random polytopes that show that the upper bounds are quite tight. Third, we show that for a class of hard packing IPs, sparse cutting-planes do not approximate the integer hull well, that is $d(P, P^k)$ is large for such instances unless $k$ is very close to $n$. Finally, we show that using sparse cutting-planes in extended formulations is at least as good as using them in the original polyhedron, and give an example where the former is actually much better.
Introduction
In Mixed-Integer Programming (MIP), solvers like Gurobi or CPLEX balance mathematical strength with computational efficiency using cutting-planes. While dense cuts (many non-zero coefficients) are powerful, they significantly slow down linear programming solvers. Consequently, sparse cuts are preferred in practice. This research quantifies the geometric cost of this preference by measuring how well sparse cuts approximate the "integer hull" $P$.
The authors define $P^k$ as the best approximation of $P$ using cuts with at most $k$ non-zero coefficients. The quality of this approximation is measured by the maximum Euclidean distance $d(P, P^k)$ between the sparse approximation and the true hull.
Methodology
The study focuses on polytopes within the $[0, 1]^n$ hypercube and employs several analytical techniques:
- Theoretical Upper Bounds: Probabilistic methods, including Bernstein’s inequality, are used to bound $d(P, P^k)$ as a function of $k$ and the number of vertices $t$.
- Probabilistic Analysis: The authors analyze random 0/1 polytopes (convex hulls of $t$ random points) to test the tightness of their upper bounds.
- Hard Instance Evaluation: Packing Integer Programs (PIPs) are analyzed to identify cases where sparsity fails.
- Extended Formulations: The effectiveness of sparse cuts is compared between the original space and higher-dimensional "lifted" spaces.
Key Insights and Results
The effectiveness of sparse cuts exhibits three distinct phases as $k$ increases, transitioning from negligible progress to steady improvement and finally rapid convergence.
Vertex Count and Sparsity
A critical finding is that the number of vertices $t$ determines the effectiveness of sparse cuts. If a polytope has a polynomial number of vertices ($t = n^q$), then using "half-sparsity" ($k = n/2$) yields an excellent approximation: $d(P, P^{n/2}) \leq c \sqrt{\log n}$. This provides a theoretical basis for the empirical success of sparse cuts in many practical scenarios.
The Power of Lifting
The research demonstrates that sparse cuts in an extended formulation can be exponentially more powerful than in the original space. For example, 3-sparse cuts in a higher dimension can perfectly recover a polytope that $n/2$-sparse cuts in the original space fail to approximate well.
Limitations in Packing Problems
For certain "hard" packing problems, sparse cuts are shown to be largely ineffective. The distance $d(P, P^k)$ remains significant until $k$ is nearly equal to the total number of variables $n$, suggesting that some problems inherently require dense global information.
Conclusion
This work provides a rigorous geometric framework for understanding sparse cutting-planes. While sparse cuts are highly effective for "simple" polytopes with few vertices, they face a "hard wall" in complex packing problems. Future research may explore tighter bounds for structured polytopes beyond the random models analyzed here, potentially using tools like generic chaining.
Summary updated