How free trade pilot zones enhance agricultural green total factor productivity? Theory and evidence from China

Huasheng Zeng, Cheng Long, Guoqun Ma, Yuxi LuoFrontiers in Sustainable Food Systems 2024 · DOI

Abstract

Introduction: Given the dual constraints of limited resources and environmental concerns, achieving green development in agriculture helps to enhance national food security, resource security, and ecological security. Methods: Utilizing panel data sourced from 30 provinces within China, spanning the years from 2001 to 2021, this paper employs the super-efficiency Slack-Based Measure (SBM) model and the Global Malmquist-Luenberger (GML) index to measure agricultural green total factor productivity (AGTFP). It utilizes methods such as the stepwise Differences in Differences (DID), mediation effect models, and moderating effect models to systematically explore the impact of the implementation of Free Trade Pilot Zones (FTPZs) on AGTFP and its mechanisms of action. Results: The study finds: (1) Establishing FTPZs significantly boosts AGTFP, indicating a profound positive influence; (2) The promotional effect of FTPZs on AGTFP is stronger in the eastern and central regions, as well as in major grain-producing areas; (3) FTPZs may enhance AGTFP by promoting the effect of agricultural structure upgrading; (4) The agricultural scale effect plays a positive moderating role in the impact of FTPZs on AGTFP. Discussion: It is advisable to optimize agricultural measures related to FTPZs, promote agricultural structural upgrading and scale enhancement, and adapt strategies to local conditions to advance green agricultural development.

Introduction

Agriculture in China faces a difficult "dual constraint": the need to ensure national food security for a massive population while grappling with severe environmental degradation caused by traditional high-input farming (excessive fertilizers and pesticides). While traditional metrics of productivity—Total Factor Productivity (TFP)—focus solely on output, they often ignore "undesired outputs" like carbon emissions and chemical runoff. This paper tackles the challenge of measuring and improving Agricultural Green Total Factor Productivity (AGTFP), investigating whether Free Trade Pilot Zones (FTPZs) can serve as catalysts for greening the countryside.

Theoretical Framework

Beyond just lowering tariffs, FTPZs act as bridges for international agricultural technology exchange. They introduce high-tech seeds, precision farming equipment, and "green finance" products that facilitate sustainable practices. A key transmission mechanism is the agricultural structure upgrading effect, where FTPZs encourage a shift from low-value, high-pollution crops to high-value, service-oriented agriculture.

Analysis framework of FTPZs and AGTFP

Methods

The study utilizes a comprehensive panel dataset covering 30 provincial-level regions in China from 2001 to 2021. To calculate AGTFP, the authors use a Super-efficiency Slacks-Based Measure (SBM) model combined with the Global Malmquist-Luenberger (GML) index, accounting for environmental pollutants as undesired outputs. To establish causality, the researchers treat the staggered rollout of 22 FTPZs as a "quasi-natural experiment" using a Differences-in-Differences (DID) approach.

Key Results

From 2001 to 2021, China’s AGTFP grew at an average annual rate of 1.65%, driven primarily by technological progress. The baseline regression shows that establishing an FTPZ significantly boosts AGTFP at the 1% significance level. To ensure the validity of the DID model, a parallel trend test was conducted, confirming that treatment and control groups followed similar trajectories prior to policy implementation.

Parallel trend test for the DID model

Furthermore, the "agricultural scale effect" acts as a positive moderator; the benefits of an FTPZ are amplified in regions with larger, consolidated farms that possess the capital to implement advanced green technologies. However, regional heterogeneity exists: the impact is significantly stronger in the Eastern and Central regions compared to the West.

Discussion and Conclusion

While FTPZs are effective "green" incubators, the study notes limitations in data granularity, as provincial data may dilute localized effects within specific cities. Additionally, the lack of significant impact in Western China suggests that trade policies require local adaptation to account for challenging topography and smaller populations. Future policy should focus on optimizing agricultural measures within FTPZs to promote coordinated structural upgrading and scale enhancement across all regions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Introduction Given the dual constraints of limited resources and environmental concerns, achieving green development in agriculture helps to enhance national food security, resource security, and ecological security. Methods Utilizing panel data sourced from 30 provinces within China, spanning the years from 2001 to 2021, this paper employs the super-efficiency Slack-Based Measure (SBM) model and the Global Malmquist-Luenberger (GML) index to measure agricultural green total factor productivity (AGTFP). It utilizes methods such as the stepwise Differences in Differences (DID), mediation effect models, and moderating effect models to systematically explore the impact of the implementation of Free Trade Pilot Zones (FTPZs) on AGTFP and its mechanisms of action. Results The study finds: (1) Establishing FTPZs significantly boosts AGTFP, indicating a profound positive influence; (2) The promotional effect of FTPZs on AGTFP is stronger in the eastern and central regions, as well as in major grain-producing areas; (3) FTPZs may enhance AGTFP by promoting the effect of agricultural structure upgrading, i.e., a transmission mechanism exists from FTPZs to the agricultural structure upgrading effect to AGTFP; (4) The agricultural scale effect plays a positive moderating role in the impact of FTPZs on AGTFP. Discussion It is advisable to optimize agricultural measures related to FTPZs, promote agricultural structural upgrading and scale enhancement, adapt strategies to local conditions to advance green agricultural development, and thereby promote the coordinated development of FTPZs and AGTFP.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zeng2024how,
  author = {Huasheng Zeng and Cheng Long and Guoqun Ma and Yuxi Luo},
  title = {{How free trade pilot zones enhance agricultural green total factor productivity? Theory and evidence from China}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3389/fsufs.2024.1429687},
}
Figure