How does the brain navigate knowledge of social relations? Testing for shared neural mechanisms for shifting attention in space and social knowledge

Meng Du, Ruby Basyouni, Carolyn Parkinson

TL;DR

This study investigates how the brain navigates social hierarchies, finding that the superior parietal lobule (SPL) plays a role in both spatial attention and mentally shifting through social relationships. While overlapping brain regions are involved, the neural codes for spatial and social attention appear to be distinct, suggesting specialized mechanisms within shared neural real estate.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Humans are adept at understanding complex social structures like hierarchies and friendships. A key question is how the brain accomplishes this, and whether it reuses neural machinery evolved for more basic functions, such as spatial navigation. Theories suggest that our ability to "navigate" social relationships might co-opt the same neural circuits used for attending to and moving through physical space. However, direct evidence for shared neural mechanisms and how they operate has been limited, particularly regarding the direction of attention within these domains. This paper aims to bridge this gap by examining if the brain encodes shifts of attention in social knowledge and spatial attention using similar neural patterns.

Methods

The researchers employed a combination of behavioral tasks and fMRI. Participants first learned a fictional social hierarchy of nine individuals. Then, during fMRI scanning, they performed two main tasks:

  1. Social Hierarchy Navigation (Task II): Participants mentally shifted their attention "up" (towards more powerful individuals) or "down" (towards less powerful individuals) within the learned social hierarchy.
  2. Spatial Attention (Task III): Participants tracked a visual target moving in different directions (up, down, left, right) in space.

Crucially, they used multivoxel pattern analysis (MVPA) to examine the spatial patterns of brain activity. This technique is sensitive to how information is encoded in the distributed activity of voxels within a brain region, going beyond simply looking at overall activation levels. They compared pattern similarity for shifts in the same direction ("matching") versus opposite directions ("mismatching") within each task and across tasks. Exploratory whole-brain analyses and cross-domain classification were also performed.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study used data collected from human participants performing the described tasks.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The SPL is a Social Navigator: The superior parietal lobule (SPL), long known for its role in spatial attention, also appears to encode the direction of mental shifts within social hierarchies. This suggests a shared neural substrate for navigating both physical and abstract relational spaces.
  • Overlapping Regions, Distinct Codes: While regions like the posterior parietal and occipital cortex show overlap in encoding spatial and social attention shifts, the way this information is encoded seems to be distinct. This implies that even within shared brain areas, specialized neural mechanisms are at play for different types of mental operations.
  • "Up" in Space Isn't Always "Up" in Social Hierarchy: The study found that while participants might map "higher" positions in a social hierarchy to "higher" positions in space (e.g., top of the hierarchy = top of the screen), the neural codes for these directional shifts are not identical. This highlights the complexity of how abstract concepts are represented in the brain.

Key Results

  • SPL Encodes Direction: MVPA revealed that multivoxel response patterns in both the left and right SPL significantly distinguished between matching and mismatching directions of attentional shifts within the social hierarchy. The same was true for shifts of attention in external space.
  • Cross-Domain Dissimilarity: Despite the overlap in brain regions involved, cross-domain pattern similarity analyses showed no brain regions where attentional shifts in matching directions (e.g., "up" in space and "more powerful" in hierarchy) were encoded similarly. Bayesian hypothesis tests further supported the idea of distinct coding schemes.
  • Exploratory Findings: Broader analyses implicated other regions in the posterior parietal and occipital cortex in encoding these directional shifts, but again, without evidence for a shared encoding mechanism across domains.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Single Social Domain: The study focused on social hierarchy knowledge. Future research could explore other types of social relations (e.g., friendships) and compare them to other abstract domains (e.g., numerical magnitude) to see if these findings generalize.
  • Constrained Tasks: The tasks were highly controlled to isolate specific cognitive operations. Future work could use more ecologically valid paradigms, such as naturalistic social interactions, to see how these processes unfold in more complex, real-world settings.
  • Task Distinctness: The social and spatial tasks were intentionally made very different to avoid confounding results. Future studies could explore how matching task difficulty, dimensionality, and other factors might influence cross-domain encoding.
  • Mapping Ambiguity: The study acknowledges that participants' post-scan spatial arrangements of the hierarchy might not perfectly reflect their actual mental representations during the task. Future research could employ methods to better capture these dynamic internal representations.
  • Strength of Evidence: While results suggest distinct codes, the Bayesian hypothesis tests showed only moderate evidence for the null hypothesis (i.e., distinct codes) in some regions, leaving room for further investigation with different analytical methods.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract How does the human brain support reasoning about social relations (e.g., social status, friendships)? Converging theories suggest that navigating knowledge of social relations may co-opt neural circuitry with evolutionarily older functions (e.g., shifting attention in space). Here, we analyzed multivoxel response patterns of fMRI data to examine the neural mechanisms for shifting attention in knowledge of a social hierarchy. The “directions” in which participants mentally navigated social knowledge were encoded in multivoxel patterns in superior parietal cortex, which also encoded directions of attentional shifts in space. Exploratory analyses implicated additional regions of posterior parietal and occipital cortex in encoding analogous mental operations in space and social knowledge. However, cross-domain analyses suggested that attentional shifts in space and social knowledge may be encoded in functionally independent response patterns. These results elucidate the neural basis for navigating abstract knowledge of social relations, and its connection to more basic mental operations.
BibTeX
@article{du2021how,
  author = {Meng Du and Ruby Basyouni and Carolyn Parkinson},
  title = {{How does the brain navigate knowledge of social relations? Testing for shared neural mechanisms for shifting attention in space and social knowledge}},
  journal = {NeuroImage},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1016/j.neuroimage.2021.118019},
}
Figure