How Do Plant Landscapes Provide Health Benefits to Residents in Urban Green Spaces? Exploring the Role of Restorative Experiences

Yuling Zhang, Yuting Fang, Mengqing Wang, Wenjing LiForests 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how specific attributes of urban plant landscapes (aesthetics, functionality, and vegetation density) contribute to residents' perceived health benefits through restorative experiences. Surprisingly, personal stress levels do not appear to moderate this relationship, suggesting a universal benefit of green spaces for mental and physical well-being.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As urbanization accelerates, urban health issues like depression and chronic diseases are on the rise. While access to green spaces is known to mitigate these problems, the precise mechanisms by which plant landscapes in these spaces promote health remain unclear. Specifically, this paper aims to identify which aspects of plant landscapes are most effective in fostering restorative experiences and, consequently, improving perceived health, and whether individual stress levels play a role in this process.

Methods

The researchers employed a mixed-methods approach, combining theoretical frameworks with empirical data analysis. They utilized Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) to test hypothesized relationships between plant landscape attributes (stimulus), restorative experiences (organism), and perceived health benefits (response), drawing on the Stimulus-Organism-Response (SOR) theory and Attention Restoration Theory (ART). To further investigate the nuances of these relationships, they employed SPSS PROCESS for mediation and moderation analyses. Exploratory and confirmatory factor analyses were used to validate the measurement models for the scales.

Datasets

The study was conducted in 13 urban parks in Foshan, China, a city designated as a "forest city." Data was collected from 324 participants through questionnaires. The scales used measured plant landscape attributes, restorative experiences, perceived health benefits, and personal stress.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond Just "Green": The study moves beyond a general appreciation for green spaces to pinpoint specific plant landscape features that matter. It's not just about having plants, but how they are designed and presented.
  • Aesthetics and Density Drive Restoration: The visual appeal and functional design of plant landscapes, along with how dense the vegetation is, are key drivers of restorative experiences. This suggests that thoughtful design can actively enhance the healing power of urban nature.
  • Stress Doesn't Dampen the Effect: Perhaps the most surprising finding is that personal stress levels don't seem to alter the positive impact of restorative experiences from green spaces on health. This implies that urban green spaces offer a robust buffer against stress, benefiting everyone regardless of their current stress load.
  • "Being Away" and "Compatibility" are Key Mediators: The restorative experiences that most effectively bridge the gap between plant landscapes and health benefits are those related to feeling "away" from daily stressors and experiencing a sense of "compatibility" with the environment.

Key Results

  • Plant Landscape Attributes and Restorative Experiences: Landscape aesthetics/functionality and vegetation density significantly influenced all four dimensions of restorative experience (fascination, compatibility, incongruity, and being-away). However, the growth status of plants did not show a significant effect.
  • Restorative Experiences and Perceived Health: Compatibility and being-away experiences were found to significantly mediate the relationship between plant landscapes and perceived health benefits. Fascination and incongruity experiences did not show a significant mediating effect.
  • Stress as a Moderator: The study found no significant moderating effect of personal stress on the mediating role of restorative experiences. This means that the positive impact of plant landscapes on health, mediated by restorative experiences, holds true regardless of an individual's stress level.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the study is limited to 13 urban parks in Foshan, China, which may limit the generalizability of the findings to other geographical and cultural contexts. They suggest future research should expand the scope to include parks in different latitudinal zones and explore cultural backgrounds more broadly. While SEM is a powerful tool, its limitations in handling control variables and model complexity are noted. The authors also point out that while stress didn't moderate the relationship in this study, other factors like environmental quality, individual psychological state, cultural background, and lifestyle habits likely play a complex role. Future research should aim to develop more sophisticated methods to explore these interactions and validate the proposed model across a wider range of influencing factors.

Summary updated

Abstract

Plants are considered important elements of ecosystems and benefit the health of human society. However, it is unclear which attributes of plant landscapes effectively influence residents’ health in urban areas and whether this influence is moderated by other factors, such as stress. This study considers the link between the plant landscape and residents’ experiences and health benefit perceptions. The possible structural relationships between them are verified with structural equation modeling on the basis of stimulus–organism–response theory and attention restoration theory. In addition, the mediating effect and moderating effect are tested via the SPSS Process program. The results indicate that two dimensions of plant landscapes, landscape esthetics/ functionality and vegetation density, influence residents’ restorative experiences and, in turn, impact health. Only the compatibility experience and the being-away experience mediate the relationship between the plant landscape and perceived health benefits. Stress does not moderate the mediating effect of restorative experiences on the relationship between plant landscapes and perceived health benefits. On the basis of these findings, valuable information is offered concerning forest city construction and urban green space planning for the purpose of generating desirable public health and well-being.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2024how,
  author = {Yuling Zhang and Yuting Fang and Mengqing Wang and Wenjing Li},
  title = {{How Do Plant Landscapes Provide Health Benefits to Residents in Urban Green Spaces? Exploring the Role of Restorative Experiences}},
  booktitle = {Forests},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/f15081424},
}
Figure