How crystallization additives govern halide perovskite grain growth

Timo Maschwitz, Lena Merten, Feray Ünlü, Martin Majewski, Fatemeh Haddadi Barzoki, Zijin Wu, Seren Dilara Öz, Cedric Kreusel, Manuel Theisen, Pang Wang, Maximilian Schiffer, Gianluca Boccarella, Gregor Marioth, Henrik Weidner, Sarah Schultheis, Tim Schieferstein, Dawid Gidaszewski, Zavkiddin Julliev, Ekaterina Kneschaurek, Valentin Munteanu, Ivan A. Zaluzhnyy, Florian Bertram, Anaël Jaffrès, Junjie He, N. R. Ashurov, Martin Stolterfoht, Christian M. Wolff, Eva Unger, Selina Olthof, Geert Brocks, Shuxia Tao, Helen Grüninger, Olivier J. J. Ronsin, Jens Harting, Andreas Kotthaus, Stefan F. Kirsch, Sanjay Mathur, Alexander Hinderhofer, Frank Schreiber, Thomas Riedl, Kai Oliver BrinkmannNature Communications 2025 · DOI

Abstract

The preparation of perovskite solar cells from the liquid phase is a cornerstone of their immense potential. However, a clear relationship between the precursor ink and the formation of the resulting perovskite is missing. Established theories, such as heterogeneous nucleation and lead complex colloid formation, often prove unreliable, which has led to an overreliance on heuristics. Most high-performing perovskites use additives to control crystallization. Their role during crystallization is, however, elusive. Here, we provide evidence that typical crystallization additives do not predominantly impact the nucleation phase but rather facilitate coarsening grain growth by increasing ion mobility across grain boundaries. Drawing from the insights of our broad, interdisciplinary study that combines ex and in situ characterization methods, devices, simulations, and density function theory calculation, we propose a concept that proves valid for various additives and perovskite formulations. Moreover, we establish a direct link between additive engineering and perovskite post-processing, offering a unified framework for advancing material design and process engineering.

Introduction

Halide perovskite solar cells have achieved remarkable efficiencies, now exceeding 27%. Despite this success, the manufacturing process—specifically the use of crystallization additives—has often been treated as a "black magic" art. The prevailing scientific consensus suggested that these additives work by altering the chemistry of the liquid precursor ink or by controlling the initial nucleation phase. However, these theories frequently fail to predict experimental outcomes consistently. This study provides a new perspective, demonstrating that the primary impact of additives occurs during the annealing stage through a mechanism termed "ion shuttling."

Characterizing the Precursor Ink: Debunking the Nucleation Myth

To identify the true role of additives, the researchers first conducted a comprehensive analysis of the precursor ink state. Using techniques such as Electrical Conductance (EC) and UV-Vis spectroscopy, they mapped the transition of lead-complexes from simple monomers to more complex dimers and trimers as the ink concentration increases during the drying process.

Schematic of lead-complex formation and electrical conductance measurements of precursor inks.

As illustrated in the figure above, the electrical conductance provides a clear signature of the ink's chemical state. Crucially, the study found that the presence of common additives like thiourea does not significantly deviate from these predictable ink behaviors. This suggests that the liquid-phase chemistry and initial nucleation density are remarkably similar regardless of additive presence, debunking the myth that additives primarily function by "seeding" the initial crystals.

Further evidence was gathered using Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) spectroscopy to probe the chemical environment of the lead atoms ($^{207}Pb$).

NMR chemical shifts of lead in different solvent systems as a function of ink concentration.

The NMR data confirms that the solvent (DMF, DMSO, or NMP) and the concentration are the dominant factors determining the lead's chemical environment. The additives do not fundamentally restructure the precursor complexes in the liquid phase, reinforcing the need to look at later stages of film formation for the "magic" effect.

The Ion Shuttle Mechanism and Coarsening Growth

The study identifies the annealing step as the critical window for additive action. During heating, additives facilitate "coarsening"—a process where larger grains grow by consuming smaller ones. The researchers propose an "ion shuttle" mechanism: additives bond to lead atoms at grain boundaries and, at high temperatures, act as lubricants that help ions move across the boundary between grains.

Key findings include:

  • Mobility Boost: Thiourea was found to increase ion mobility across grain boundaries by approximately 50-fold compared to additive-free films.
  • Grain Size: This increased mobility allows for the growth of micrometer-scale grains with beneficial crystallographic orientations.
  • Effectiveness Hierarchy: The study established a sequence of effectiveness (Thiourea > Urea > MACl) based on the additives' detachment energy. Thiourea is most effective because it balances strong surface bonding with the ability to detach and "shuttle" ions during heating.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

By shifting the focus from nucleation to coarsening, this research provides a unified framework for understanding additive engineering. The discovery that additives can be equally effective when applied via post-processing confirms that their role is independent of the initial ink state. This "ion shuttle" model offers a predictive tool for designing new molecules that can optimize grain growth at lower temperatures, paving the way for more scalable and efficient perovskite solar cell manufacturing.

Summary updated

Abstract

The preparation of perovskite solar cells from the liquid phase is a cornerstone of their immense potential. However, a clear relationship between the precursor ink and the formation of the resulting perovskite is missing. Established theories, such as heterogeneous nucleation and lead complex colloid formation, often prove unreliable, which has led to an overreliance on heuristics. Most high-performing perovskites use additives to control crystallization. Their role during crystallization is, however, elusive. Here, we provide evidence that typical crystallization additives do not predominantly impact the nucleation phase but rather facilitate coarsening grain growth by increasing ion mobility across grain boundaries. Drawing from the insights of our broad, interdisciplinary study that combines ex and in situ characterization methods, devices, simulations, and density function theory calculation, we propose a concept that proves valid for various additives and perovskite formulations. Moreover, we establish a direct link between additive engineering and perovskite post-processing, offering a unified framework for advancing material design and process engineering.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{maschwitz2025how,
  author = {Timo Maschwitz and Lena Merten and Feray Ünlü and Martin Majewski and Fatemeh Haddadi Barzoki and Zijin Wu and Seren Dilara Öz and Cedric Kreusel and Manuel Theisen and Pang Wang and Maximilian Schiffer and Gianluca Boccarella and Gregor Marioth and Henrik Weidner and Sarah Schultheis and Tim Schieferstein and Dawid Gidaszewski and Zavkiddin Julliev and Ekaterina Kneschaurek and Valentin Munteanu and Ivan A. Zaluzhnyy and Florian Bertram and Anaël Jaffrès and Junjie He and N. R. Ashurov and Martin Stolterfoht and Christian M. Wolff and Eva Unger and Selina Olthof and Geert Brocks and Shuxia Tao and Helen Grüninger and Olivier J. J. Ronsin and Jens Harting and Andreas Kotthaus and Stefan F. Kirsch and Sanjay Mathur and Alexander Hinderhofer and Frank Schreiber and Thomas Riedl and Kai Oliver Brinkmann},
  title = {{How crystallization additives govern halide perovskite grain growth}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-025-65484-7},
}
Figure