Abstract
In the ongoing intense quest to increase the performance of perovskite solar cells, optimizing the morphology of perovskite material has become imperative to achieve high power conversion efficiencies. Despite the fact that nucleation plays a key role in controlling the crystal morphology, very little is known about the nucleation and crystal growth processes. Here, we perform metadynamics simulations of nucleation of methylammonium lead triiodide (MAPI) in order to unravel the atomistic details of perovskite crystallization from a γ-butyrolactone solution. The metadynamics trajectories show that the nucleation process takes place in several stages. Initially, dense amorphous clusters mainly consisting of lead and iodide appear from the homogeneous solution. These clusters evolve into lead iodide (PbI2)-like structures. Subsequently, methylammonium (MA+) ions diffuse into these PbI2-like aggregates triggering the transformation into a perovskite crystal through a solid–solid transformation. These enticing results allowed us to design new experimental strategies to rationally control the dimensions of MAPI grains using the spin-coating technique and to engineer homogeneous nucleation and growth of MAPI single crystals. The experimental results amply support our unprecedented observations related to the critical role of monovalent cations in inducing the nucleation process in lead halide perovskites.
Introduction: The Challenge of Morphology Control
Hybrid organic-inorganic perovskites, particularly methylammonium lead iodide (MAPI), have emerged as frontrunners in the field of next-generation photovoltaics. However, achieving high power conversion efficiency in real-world devices depends critically on the morphology of the perovskite thin films—specifically the size, shape, and crystallinity of the grains. This morphology is established during the initial stages of crystallization, starting with nucleation.
Nucleation is fundamentally a "rare event" on the molecular scale. It occurs rapidly and at dimensions too small for direct experimental observation, yet it involves energy barriers that make it computationally inaccessible for standard Molecular Dynamics (MD) simulations. Consequently, the atomistic pathway from a precursor solution to a structured crystal has remained largely a mystery, forcing researchers to rely on empirical trial-and-error methods for optimization.
Methodology: Well-Tempered Metadynamics
To overcome the limitations of standard MD, this study utilizes Well-Tempered Metadynamics (WTMetaD). This enhanced sampling technique applies a bias potential to the system's energy landscape, effectively "filling" local minima and allowing the simulation to explore configurations that would otherwise be trapped by high energy barriers.
A critical component of this approach was the development of a novel Collective Variable ($S_P$). Unlike traditional variables that might bias the system toward a specific, pre-defined crystal structure, $S_P$ tracks the local coordination between methylammonium (MA$^+$), lead (Pb$^{2+}$), and iodide (I$^-$) ions. This allowed the researchers to observe the natural, unbiased evolution of intermediate complexes as they transitioned toward the final perovskite phase.
The Multi-Stage Nucleation Pathway
The simulations revealed that MAPI nucleation is not a single spontaneous event but a multi-stage journey. The process begins with density fluctuations in the homogeneous precursor solution (PbI$_2$ and MAI in γ-butyrolactone), leading to the formation of amorphous clusters dominated by lead and iodide. These clusters then organize into an intermediate, edge-sharing "PbI$_2$-like" structure.
The transition to the final perovskite structure is triggered by a specific event: the diffusion of MA$^+$ cations into the spaces of these PbI$_2$-like intermediates. Initially, the organic cations merely surround the negatively charged Pb-I clusters to maintain charge neutrality. Once they penetrate the cluster, they trigger a solid-solid transformation from edge-sharing octahedra to the corner-sharing octahedra characteristic of the perovskite lattice.
Key Results and Structural Transformation
Analysis of the trajectories provided quantitative evidence for this mechanism. The researchers observed a sharp increase in the diffusion coefficient of MA$^+$ ions just before crystallization, followed by a drop to near-zero as the ions became locked into the rigid crystal lattice.
As shown in the data, the intermediate edge-sharing phase is a highly efficient stepping stone; approximately 95% of these octahedra successfully convert into the final corner-sharing perovskite structure. This high conversion rate confirms that the PbI$_2$-like clusters are direct precursors rather than off-pathway byproducts.
Implications for Crystal Engineering
Understanding that MA$^+$ diffusion is the bottleneck for nucleation provides a powerful lever for crystal engineering. By selecting solvents or chemical additives that interact strongly with the MA$^+$ cation, researchers can rationally tune the rate of nucleation. Slowing this process down allows for the growth of larger, higher-quality single crystals, which are essential for maximizing the efficiency and stability of perovskite solar cells. This work marks a transition from empirical manufacturing to a rationally designed chemical process based on fundamental atomistic insights.
Summary updated