How climate change may shift power demand in Japan: Insights from data-driven analysis

Léna Gurriaran, Katsumasa Tanaka, Kiyoshi Takahashi, Philippe Ciais

TL;DR

Researchers used machine learning to project how climate change will reshape Japan’s electricity landscape through 2100. While warming reduces winter heating needs, it triggers massive spikes in summer cooling demand—particularly during "shoulder seasons" like June and September—potentially pushing the power grid to its breaking point even as the national population declines.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Japan faces a dual challenge: a rapidly aging, shrinking population and an increasingly volatile climate. While we know that higher temperatures drive up air conditioning use, most previous models lacked the regional granularity to show where and when the grid will be most stressed.

The authors sought to bridge the gap between climate science and energy management. They specifically looked at how the "U-shaped" relationship between temperature and power demand (where we use more power during both extreme cold and extreme heat) will shift under different global warming scenarios. Understanding these shifts is critical for preventing future blackouts, like the near-miss power crisis Tokyo experienced in June 2022.

Methods

The study employed a data-driven approach using Random Forest models—a machine learning technique that excels at capturing non-linear relationships.

  1. Model Selection: The team compared three algorithms: Random Forest, Multivariate Adaptive Regression Splines (MARS), and Gradient Boosting. Random Forest proved the most accurate and efficient for this dataset.
  2. Predictors: The models didn't just look at raw temperature. They used 12 variables, including:
  3. Climate variables: Solar radiation, wind speed, and precipitation.
  4. Human exposure indices: The Discomfort Index (DI) and Humidex (Hx), which account for how humidity makes heat feel more intense to the human body.
  5. Human activity: A simple proxy for workdays vs. weekends.
  6. Future Scenarios: The models were run against three Shared Socioeconomic Pathways (SSPs), ranging from a "green" low-emission future (SSP1-2.6) to a high-fossil-fuel-development scenario (SSP5-8.5).

Datasets

  • Historical Climate: ERA5 reanalysis data (2016–2020) provided high-resolution historical weather patterns.
  • Future Climate: Projections from five different Earth System Models (from the CMIP6 suite) via the ISIMIP3b project.
  • Power Data: Daily power demand and energy mix data (fossil fuels vs. renewables) sourced directly from Japan’s ten regional power utilities.
  • Socioeconomic Data: Population and GDP projections from the National Institute for Environmental Studies (NIES) and the OECD.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Shoulder Season" Risk: The most surprising finding wasn't about mid-summer. Instead, the highest relative increases in power demand are projected for May, June, September, and October. In these "next-warmest months," the grid is often down for maintenance or not prepared for peak cooling loads, creating a high risk for regular power outages.
  • Regional Divergence: Climate change affects Japan's north and south very differently. In cold regions like Hokkaido, warming leads to a net decrease in annual power demand because the reduction in winter heating outweighs the increase in summer cooling. In tropical Okinawa, demand is projected to skyrocket by up to 11% due to relentless cooling needs.
  • The Humidity Factor: The study highlights that temperature alone is a poor predictor of demand. Using the Discomfort Index (DI) was crucial; once the DI exceeds a threshold of 21, power demand begins to climb sharply as residents switch on air conditioning.
  • Renewables and Weather: Carbon intensity (the CO2 emitted per kWh) is highly sensitive to daily weather. High solar radiation significantly lowers carbon intensity by boosting PV output, while high precipitation increases it by reducing renewable efficiency.

Key Results

  • Demand Shifts: Under the worst-case scenario (SSP5-8.5), annual power demand in Okinawa and Kyushu is projected to increase by 1.6% to 11.1%. Conversely, northern regions could see a decrease of up to 3.2%.
  • CO2 Emissions: Socioeconomic factors (population decline and aggressive decarbonization policies) are the primary drivers of long-term CO2 reduction. However, climate change acts as a "counter-force" in hot regions. In Okinawa, climate-driven demand increases could result in a 10% increase in CO2 emissions compared to a "no climate change" baseline.
  • Model Performance: The Random Forest models achieved high accuracy, explaining a significant portion of the daily variance in power demand across all ten regions.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several areas for further refinement:

  • Urban Heat Island (UHI): Current global climate models don't fully capture the localized "heat island" effect in cities like Tokyo, meaning future demand in urban centers might be even higher than projected here.
  • Air Conditioning Saturation: The model assumes current AC adoption rates. If 100% of households adopt AC (as some studies predict), the demand spikes will be even more severe.
  • Extreme Thresholds: As temperatures reach unprecedented highs, human behavior might change in ways current data cannot predict (e.g., a "tipping point" where cooling becomes a medical necessity rather than a comfort).
  • Policy Evolution: The study uses current energy mix trends; a more rapid shift toward nuclear or offshore wind could drastically alter the carbon intensity projections.

Summary updated

Abstract

The impact of climate change on power demand in Japan is a matter of concern for the Japanese authorities and power companies as it may have consequences on the power grid. We trained random forest models against daily power data in ten Japanese regions and for different types of power generation to project changes in future power production and its carbon intensity. To do so, we used twelve predictors: six climate variables, five variables accounting for human exposure to climate, and one variable for the level of human activities. We then used the models trained from the present-day period to estimate the future power demand, carbon intensity, and pertaining CO2 emissions over the period 2020-2100 under three SSPs scenarios (Shared Socioeconomic Pathways: SSP126, SSP370, and SSP585). The impact of climate change on CO2 emissions via power generation shows seasonal and regional disparities. In cold regions, a decrease in power demand during winter under future warming leads to an overall decrease in power demand over the year. In contrast, the decrease in winter power demand in hot regions can be overcompensated by an increase in summer power demand because of more frequent hot days, leading to an overall annual increase. From our regional models, the power demand should increase the most in most Japanese regions in May, June, September, and October and not in the middle of summer, as has been found in older studies. Such an increase could result in regular power outages during those months if not considered, as the power grid could be particularly tense. Overall, we observed that power demand in regions with extreme climates is more sensitive to global warming than in temperate regions. The impact of climate change on power demand induces a net annual decrease in CO emissions in all regions except for Okinawa, in which power demand strongly increases during the summer, resulting in a net annual increase in CO emissions. However, climate change’s impact on carbon intensity may reverse the trend in some regions (Shikoku, Tohoku). We also assessed the relative impacts of socioeconomic factors such as population, GDP, and environmental policies on CO emissions. When combined with these factors, we found that the climate change effect is more important than when considered individually and significantly impacts total CO emissions under SSP585.
BibTeX
@article{gurriaran2023how,
  author = {Léna Gurriaran and Katsumasa Tanaka and Kiyoshi Takahashi and Philippe Ciais},
  title = {{How climate change may shift power demand in Japan: Insights from data-driven analysis}},
  journal = {Journal of Environmental Management},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1016/j.jenvman.2023.118799},
}
Figure