Homogeneous Multiplicative Polynomial Laws are Determinants

Francesco Vaccarino

Abstract

Let $R$ be a ring and let $B$ be a commutative ring. Let $p$ be a homogeneous multiplicative polynomial law of degree $n$ from $R$ to $B$. We show that $p$ is essentially a determinant, in the sense that $p$ is obtained from a determinant by left and right composition with ring homomorphisms.

Introduction

In the study of ring theory and algebraic geometry, we frequently encounter maps that preserve the underlying structure of algebraic objects. A "polynomial law" represents a sophisticated generalization of a polynomial map, specifically designed to remain robust even when the underlying modules are not free. When such a law preserves both the multiplicative product and the identity element, it is classified as a "multiplicative polynomial law."

The canonical example of a homogeneous multiplicative polynomial law of degree $n$ is the determinant of an $n \times n$ matrix. For decades, a fundamental question persisted in algebra: is the determinant the unique archetype for such laws, or do other exotic examples exist? This paper provides a definitive answer to this universality problem, proving that the determinant is indeed the fundamental building block for all such laws across any commutative ring.

Theoretical Framework

To establish this result, the research synthesizes two deep areas of algebra: the theory of divided powers and the invariant theory of matrices.

Divided Power Algebras

The author utilizes a foundational result by Roby, which establishes that homogeneous multiplicative polynomial laws of degree $n$ from a ring $R$ are in one-to-one correspondence with ring homomorphisms originating from the $n$-th divided power algebra of $R$, denoted as $\Gamma_n(R)$. This correspondence effectively "linearizes" the problem, transforming the search for complex maps into the study of a specific, well-defined algebraic object.

Invariant Theory of Matrices

The proof relies heavily on the work of S. Donkin and A. Zubkov regarding the invariants of matrices under simultaneous conjugation. Specifically, the paper examines the ring of invariants $C_S(n)$, which consists of functions on sets of matrices that remain invariant under a change of basis. By focusing on these invariants, the author connects abstract polynomial laws to the concrete behavior of matrix entries.

Methodology: Generic Representations

The author constructs a bridge between abstract algebra and matrix theory through "generic representations." By mapping a free ring $F_S$ to a ring of generic matrices, the author demonstrates that the divided power algebra of the free ring is isomorphic to the ring of matrix invariants. This isomorphism forces every multiplicative law to factor through the determinant, establishing its universality.

Key Results

The Main Theorem

The central result of the paper states that for any homogeneous multiplicative polynomial law $p: R \to B$ of degree $n$, there exists a unique ring homomorphism such that $p$ is obtained by composing the determinant of a generic representation with that homomorphism. In essence, $p = \phi \circ \det$, where $\phi$ is a unique ring homomorphism.

The Isomorphism Theorem

The author proves that the map $\pi_n: \Gamma_n(F_S)^{ab} \to C_S(n)$ is an isomorphism of graded rings. This confirms that the coefficients of characteristic polynomials—which generate $C_S(n)$—serve as the fundamental coordinates for all multiplicative laws. This connection bridges abstract homological tools (divided powers) with the classical study of characteristic polynomials.

Universality Across Characteristics

A significant contribution of this work is its validity in positive characteristic. By utilizing results from Donkin and Zubkov that are not restricted to characteristic zero, the author ensures the theorem holds true over any commutative ring, including those where traditional methods involving the field of rational numbers might fail.

Discussion and Future Directions

While this paper provides a definitive characterization of homogeneous laws, it opens several avenues for further inquiry. The current findings are constrained to homogeneous laws of a fixed degree $n$; non-homogeneous multiplicative laws remain to be explicitly characterized. Additionally, the target ring $B$ is assumed to be commutative. Future research could explore the behavior of these laws when the target is non-commutative, potentially deepening our understanding of Azumaya algebras and general central simple algebras through the lens of determinantal laws.

Summary updated

Abstract

Let R be a ring and let B be a commutative ring. Let p be a homogeneous multiplicative polynomial law of degree n from R to B. We show that p is essentially a determinant, in the sense that p is obtained from a determinant by left and right composition with ring homomorphisms.
BibTeX
@article{vaccarino2009homogeneous,
  author = {Francesco Vaccarino},
  title = {{Homogeneous Multiplicative Polynomial Laws are Determinants}},
  journal = {Journal of Pure and Applied Algebra},
  year = {2009},
  doi = {10.1016/j.jpaa.2008.11.036},
}
Figure