Holographic coherent states from random tensor networks

Xiao-Liang Qi, Yang Zhao, Yi‐Zhuang YouJournal of High Energy Physics 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces "holographic coherent states," a new framework that allows for quantum superpositions of different spatial geometries in the bulk, extending the capabilities of random tensor networks. This approach provides a novel way to understand holographic duality by mapping boundary states to a superposition of bulk geometries, with implications for quantum error correction and the emergence of spacetime.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The holographic principle, a cornerstone of modern theoretical physics, suggests a deep connection between gravity in higher dimensions (the "bulk") and quantum field theories in lower dimensions (the "boundary"). Tensor networks have emerged as powerful tools for modeling this duality, particularly in understanding how entanglement on the boundary encodes the geometry of the bulk. However, existing tensor network models typically describe a fixed bulk geometry. A crucial missing piece for a complete quantum theory of gravity is the ability to describe superpositions of different bulk geometries, which is essential for understanding quantum fluctuations of spacetime itself. This paper tackles this challenge by generalizing random tensor networks to allow for such quantum superpositions of geometries.

Methods

The authors generalize the random tensor network (RTN) approach by defining a framework where different bulk spatial geometries are represented by weighted adjacency matrices of graphs. These matrices are then mapped to the boundary Hilbert space, forming an "overcomplete basis" which they term "holographic coherent states." This means that any boundary state can be expressed as a superposition of these holographic coherent states, each corresponding to a different bulk geometry.

Key technical developments include:

  • Generalizing RTNs: The framework allows for superpositions of different graph structures, not just variations within a fixed graph.
  • Defining "Classical Geometries": They define classical geometries based on specific configurations of link variables (weights on graph edges), and "small fluctuations" around these as deviations from these configurations.
  • Code Subspaces: Small fluctuations around classical geometries are shown to form "code subspaces" that are mapped to the boundary isometrically and possess quantum error correction properties. This is a crucial step towards understanding how local bulk physics emerges.
  • Overlap Analysis: They analyze the overlap between states corresponding to different geometries, demonstrating that this overlap is exponentially suppressed with the "geometrical difference," measured in an area-law fashion.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Holographic Coherent States: The introduction of "holographic coherent states" provides a concrete mathematical object that bridges the gap between boundary states and superpositions of bulk geometries. This is analogous to coherent states in quantum mechanics, which represent superpositions of particle number states.
  • Geometry as a Quantum Superposition: The paper demonstrates that a single boundary state can encode information about multiple bulk geometries simultaneously, a fundamental requirement for a quantum theory of gravity.
  • Emergence of Locality and Error Correction: The identification of "code subspaces" associated with small fluctuations around classical geometries, which exhibit isometric mapping and error correction properties, is a significant insight. It suggests a mechanism for how local physics in the bulk might arise from the entanglement structure of the boundary.
  • Area Law for Geometric Overlap: The exponential suppression of overlap between different geometries, governed by an "area law," is a direct manifestation of the holographic principle. It implies that the "difference" between two geometries is measured by the boundary area of the region where they diverge, not their volume.

Key Results

  • Overcomplete Basis: The holographic coherent states form an overcomplete basis for the boundary Hilbert space, meaning any boundary state can be represented as a superposition of these geometry-encoded states.
  • Isometry and Error Correction: Small fluctuations around classical geometries define code subspaces that are mapped isometrically to the boundary and possess quantum error correction properties.
  • Exponentially Suppressed Overlap: The overlap between states corresponding to distinct geometries decays exponentially with the geometrical difference, measured by an area law. This implies that macroscopically different geometries are nearly orthogonal in the boundary Hilbert space.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Variational Wavefunctions: The authors suggest that holographic coherent states could be used as variational wavefunctions for a given boundary Hamiltonian, but acknowledge that the random averaging makes this technically challenging.
  • Bulk Equation of Motion: A natural next step is to derive the bulk equation of motion, analogous to Einstein's equation, from this framework.
  • Saddle Point Equation: They pose the question of whether the Einstein equation is a saddle point equation for a bulk action derived from this geometric basis.
  • General Relativity and Area Law: The paper raises the question of whether a similar area-law bound for state inner products exists in general relativity.
  • Technical Feasibility of Variational Procedures: The authors reserve the technical feasibility of variational procedures for future work.

Summary updated

Abstract

Random tensor networks provide useful models that incorporate various important features of holographic duality. A tensor network is usually defined for a fixed graph geometry specified by the connection of tensors. In this paper, we generalize the random tensor network approach to allow quantum superposition of different spatial geometries. We setup a framework in which all possible bulk spatial geometries, characterized by weighted adjacient matrices of all possible graphs, are mapped to the boundary Hilbert space and form an overcomplete basis of the boundary. We name such an overcomplete basis as holographic coherent states. A generic boundary state can be expanded in this basis, which describes the state as a superposition of different spatial geometries in the bulk. We discuss how to define distinct classical geometries and small fluctuations around them. We show that small fluctuations around classical geometries define “code subspaces” which are mapped to the boundary Hilbert space isometrically with quantum error correction properties. In addition, we also show that the overlap between different geometries is suppressed exponentially as a function of the geometrical difference between the two geometries. The geometrical difference is measured in an area law fashion, which is a manifestation of the holographic nature of the states considered.
BibTeX
@article{qi2017holographic,
  author = {Xiao-Liang Qi and Yang Zhao and Yi‐Zhuang You},
  title = {{Holographic coherent states from random tensor networks}},
  journal = {Journal of High Energy Physics},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1007/jhep08(2017)060},
}
Figure