Holistic Specification of the Human Digital Twin: Stakeholders, Users, Functionalities, and Applications

Nils Mandischer, Alexander Atanasyan, Ulrich Dahmen, Michael Schluse, Jürgen Rossmann, Lars Mikelsons

Introduction

While Digital Twins (DTs) are a mature concept in manufacturing—providing virtual replicas of physical assets like jet engines—the Human Digital Twin (HDT) remains a fragmented and often vague buzzword. Current implementations are typically "isolated partial solutions," such as a fitness tracker monitoring heart rate or a clinical model predicting a specific drug response, which lack interoperability. This research moves the HDT from a fragmented concept to a rigorous engineering framework, defining a holistic vision that spans healthcare, smart homes, and industrial environments.

Methodology: A Systems-Engineering Approach

To move beyond isolated solutions, the researchers employed a structured systems-engineering approach. This involved expert brainstorming and a "Sailboat Retrospective" to envision a future where HDTs are ubiquitous. The process followed a logical flow from initial definitions and thought experiments to the derivation of stakeholders, users, and specific functionalities.

The structured systems-engineering process used to derive the HDT specification.

Through this process, the team established a comprehensive list of 25 generic requirements categorized by Safety & Security, Reliability, Legal & Regulatory, Structure & Functionality, Connectivity, and Accessibility.

The Functional Hierarchy of HDTs

A core contribution of this paper is the definition of a six-level hierarchy of functionality (Levels 0 to V). This roadmap allows developers to categorize the complexity and purpose of an HDT implementation:

  • Level 0: Store – Basic data storage (data lake).
  • Level I: Analyze – Evaluation and linking of data points.
  • Level II: Personalize – Preemptive, static configuration based on individual data.
  • Level III: Predict – Forecasting future physical or psychological states.
  • Level IV: Control – Dynamic, closed-loop influence on the environment or individual.
  • Level V: Optimize – System-wide efficiency regarding cost, energy, or human strain.
The six-level hierarchy of Human Digital Twin functionality, ranging from simple storage to complex system optimization.

Crucially, the authors argue that "communication" is not a level itself but an orthogonal requirement; an HDT at any level must be able to communicate its state to humans or other machines.

Key Insights and Requirements

Several unique "human-centric" requirements emerged from the specification:

  • The "Singleton" HDT: Requirement D4 specifies that there should be only one unique HDT per person to avoid fragmented digital identities and ensure a "single source of truth."
  • The "Experimentable" Entity: The HDT is envisioned as an entity that can be independently simulated to test "what-if" scenarios without risking the physical person.
  • Plannable Death: Addressing the digital afterlife, the framework specifies that an HDT must be "purgeable" or follow a digital "will" upon the death of the physical individual.

Applications and Validation

The framework was validated against three distinct application scenarios, demonstrating how complexity increases as functionality moves from Level III to Level V:

  1. Individualized Therapy (Level III): Predicting side effects and treatment outcomes in a medical context.
  2. Smart Home (Level IV): Dynamically controlling environmental variables like light and heat based on the inhabitant's real-time physiological state.
  3. Factory Productivity (Level V): Optimizing entire workstations to maximize profit while simultaneously reducing worker strain and absenteeism.

Challenges and Future Outlook

Despite the rigorous framework, significant hurdles remain. Modeling mental and emotional well-being is far less advanced than physiological modeling. Furthermore, integrating sophisticated HDTs into "Brown Field" environments—older, non-standardized industrial or medical systems—presents a major technical challenge. Finally, the ethical implications of continuous human monitoring, particularly in the workplace, require deeper investigation to ensure compliance with legal frameworks like GDPR while maintaining individual privacy.

Summary updated

Abstract

The digital twin of humans is a relatively new concept. While many diverse definitions, architectures, and applications exist, a clear picture is missing on what, in fact, makes a human digital twin. Within this context, researchers and industrial use-case owners alike are unaware about the market potential of the-at the moment-rather theoretical construct. In this work, we draw a holistic vision of the human digital twin, and derive the specification of this holistic human digital twin in form of requirements, stakeholders, and users. For each group of users, we define exemplary applications that fall into the six levels of functionality: store, analyze, personalize, predict, control, and optimize. The functionality levels facilitate an abstraction of abilities of the human digital twin. From the manifold applications, we discuss three in detail to showcase the feasibility of the abstraction levels and the analysis of stakeholders and users. Based on the deep discussion, we derive a comprehensive list of requirements on the holistic human digital twin. These considerations shall be used as a guideline for research and industries for the implementation of human digital twins, particularly in context of reusability in multiple target applications.
BibTeX
@misc{mandischer2025holistic,
  author = {Nils Mandischer and Alexander Atanasyan and Ulrich Dahmen and Michael Schluse and Jürgen Rossmann and Lars Mikelsons},
  title = {{Holistic Specification of the Human Digital Twin: Stakeholders, Users, Functionalities, and Applications}},
  year = {2025},
  eprint = {2507.14859},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2507.14859},
}
Figure