Highly non-Gaussian tails and primordial black holes from single-field inflation

Yi-Fu Cai, Xiao-Han Ma, Misao Sasaki, Dong-Gang Wang, Zihan Zhou

TL;DR

This paper demonstrates that tiny upward steps in the inflaton potential can create "heavy tails" in the probability distribution of primordial fluctuations. Even if the universe looks perfectly Gaussian on large scales, these non-perturbative effects can boost the formation of Primordial Black Holes (PBHs) by several orders of magnitude, providing a novel mechanism for generating dark matter candidates.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the standard model of cosmology, the "seeds" of all structures in the universe are primordial curvature perturbations ($\mathcal{R}$) generated during inflation. Usually, we assume these fluctuations follow a Gaussian distribution. While this works perfectly for the small fluctuations we see in the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB), it might fail for the rare, large fluctuations that lead to the formation of Primordial Black Holes.

The problem is that standard tools—like the non-linearity parameter $f_{NL}$—only describe the "bulk" of the distribution (small perturbations). However, PBHs are born from the "tails" (extreme perturbations). Theoretical physicists have long suspected that the physics governing these rare events might be non-perturbative and independent of the bulk statistics. This paper seeks to find a concrete, single-field inflation model where the tail becomes highly non-Gaussian while the bulk remains nearly Gaussian.

Methods

The authors employ the $\delta N$ formalism, a powerful non-perturbative tool that relates fluctuations in the inflaton field to the local duration of inflation. By calculating the total number of e-folds ($N$) along different phase-space trajectories, they can map Gaussian field fluctuations ($\delta\phi$) to non-Gaussian curvature perturbations ($\mathcal{R}$).

They analyze two specific scenarios:

  1. USR-SR Transition: An Ultra-Slow-Roll (non-attractor) stage followed by a standard Slow-Roll stage, separated by a tiny upward potential step.
  2. SR-SR Transition: Two distinct Slow-Roll stages connected by an upward step.

To calculate the power spectrum, they use mode function matching, solving the equations of motion for fluctuations across the potential step to see how different wavelengths are amplified or mixed.

Datasets

As a theoretical study in high-energy cosmology, this paper does not use observational datasets. Instead, it relies on analytical derivations and numerical simulations of inflationary trajectories to validate the proposed theoretical framework.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Power of the "Off-Attractor": The authors identify that "off-attractor" trajectories—paths the inflaton takes that haven't yet settled into the standard "terminal velocity" of slow-roll—are the secret sauce. These trajectories are highly sensitive to tiny features in the potential, like a small upward step.
  • Decoupling the Bulk from the Tail: A major "aha moment" is the discovery that the tail of the distribution can have a sharp cutoff or a massive boost even if the perturbative $f_{NL}$ is small. This means we cannot rely on CMB-scale observations to predict the abundance of PBHs accurately.
  • Inflaton Trapping: The paper introduces a fascinating secondary mechanism for PBH formation. If a region of space has a large enough field fluctuation, the inflaton might lack the kinetic energy to "climb" the potential step. This region gets "trapped" at a higher potential energy, continues to inflate longer than its surroundings, and eventually collapses into a black hole.

Key Results

  • Non-Perturbative Mapping: The authors derived a specific non-linear relation: $\mathcal{R} \simeq -\frac{2}{|h|} (\sqrt{1-|h|\mathcal{R}_G} - 1)$, where $\mathcal{R}_G$ is the Gaussian part. This formula explicitly shows a "cutoff" in the distribution that standard perturbation theory misses.
  • PBH Abundance Boost: For certain parameters ($|h| \sim \mathcal{O}(1)$), the non-Gaussian tail enhances the PBH mass fraction ($\beta_{PBH}$) by several orders of magnitude compared to the Gaussian assumption.
  • Power Spectrum Scaling: They confirmed that the power spectrum scales as $k^4$ during the transition, a hallmark of sharp features in single-field inflation that can lead to significant PBH production.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that they neglected quantum diffusion (stochastic effects). In a real-world scenario, quantum "kicks" might smooth out the sharp cutoffs they found in the probability distribution.

Future research directions include:

  • Incorporating stochastic $\delta N$ formalism to see how quantum noise affects the non-Gaussian tails.
  • Exploring the signatures of these non-Gaussian tails in scalar-induced gravitational waves, which could be detected by future observatories like LISA or Taiji.
  • Investigating if similar "trapping" mechanisms exist in multi-field inflation models.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract For primordial perturbations, deviations from Gaussian statistics on the tail of the probability distribution can be associated with non-perturbative effects of inflation. In this paper, we present some particular examples in which the tail of the distribution becomes highly non-Gaussian although the statistics remains almost Gaussian in the perturbative regime. We begin with an extension of the ultra-slow-roll inflation that incorporates a transition process, where the inflaton climbs up a tiny potential step at the end of the non-attractor stage before it converges to the slow-roll attractor. Through this example, we identify the key role of the off-attractor behaviour for the upward-step transition, and then extend the analysis to another type of the transition with two slow-roll stages connected by a tiny step. We perform both the perturbative and non-perturbative analyses of primordial fluctuations generated around the step in detail, and show that the tiny but nontrivial transition may affect large perturbations in the tail of the distribution, while the perturbative non-Gaussianity remains small. Our result indicates that the non-Gaussian tails can have rich phenomenology which has been overlooked in conventional analyses. We also study the implications of this non-Gaussian tail for the formation of primordial black holes, and find that their mass fraction can be parametrically amplified by several orders of magnitudes in comparison with the case of the Gaussian distribution. Additionally, we also discuss a mechanism of primordial black holes formation for this upward step inflation model by trapping the inflaton in the bottom of the step.
BibTeX
@article{cai2022highly,
  author = {Yi-Fu Cai and Xiao-Han Ma and Misao Sasaki and Dong-Gang Wang and Zihan Zhou},
  title = {{Highly non-Gaussian tails and primordial black holes from single-field inflation}},
  journal = {Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1088/1475-7516/2022/12/034},
}

Loading related content...

Figure