High-Throughput Exploration of NV-like Color Centers Across Host Materials

Oscar Groppfeldt, Joel Davidsson, Rickard ArmientoarXiv 2025 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Point defects in semiconductors offer a promising platform for advancing quantum technologies due to their localized energy states and controllable spin properties. Prior research has focused on a limited set of defects within materials such as diamond, silicon carbide, and hexagonal boron nitride. We present a high-throughput study to systematically identify and evaluate point defects across a diverse range of host materials, aiming to uncover previously unexplored defects in novel host materials suitable for use in quantum applications. A range of host materials are selected for their desirable properties, such as appropriate bandgaps, crystal structure, and absence of d- or f-electrons. The Automatic Defect Analysis and Qualification (ADAQ) software framework is used to generate vacancies, substitutions with s- and p-elements, and interstitials in these materials and use density functional theory to calculate key properties such as Zero-Phonon Lines (ZPLs), ionic displacements, Transition Dipole Moments (TDMs), and formation energies. Special attention is given to charge correction methods for materials with dielectric anisotropy. We uncover new defect-host combinations with advantageous properties for quantum applications: 28 defects across 11 isotropic and 2 anisotropic host materials show properties similar to the nitrogen-vacancy (NV) center in diamond. Beryllium (Be) substitutional defects in SrS, MgS, and SrO emerge as particularly promising. These findings contribute to diversifying and enhancing the materials available for quantum technologies.

Introduction

Quantum communication and sensing rely on "color centers"—point defects in a crystal lattice that can trap a single electron spin and interact with light. While the nitrogen-vacancy (NV) center in diamond is the current gold standard, diamond is expensive, difficult to integrate into standard semiconductor fabrication, and its specific optical properties aren't always ideal for every application.

To date, research has been heavily "siloed" around a few materials: diamond, silicon carbide (SiC), and hexagonal boron nitride (hBN). This study addresses the lack of diversity in host materials by systematically searching for unexplored defects in a wider range of bulk crystals that might offer better coherence times, easier manufacturing, or more favorable optical transitions.

Methodology: The ADAQ Framework

The researchers employed a high-throughput computational pipeline centered on the ADAQ (Automatic Defect Analysis and Qualification) framework. The process began with a broad database of 541 potential host materials from the Materials Project, which were systematically filtered down to a manageable set of 29 candidates.

The multi-stage filtering process used to identify 29 promising host materials from an initial pool of 541.

The filtering criteria included:

  1. Thermodynamic Stability: Ensuring the materials are on the convex hull.
  2. Electronic Structure: Selecting materials with a bandgap > 1.0 eV and the absence of problematic $d$- or $f$-electrons.
  3. Symmetry: Prioritizing specific crystallographic point groups (tetragonal, trigonal, hexagonal, or cubic) that allow for "essential" orbital degeneracies, ensuring defect states are robust against small local distortions.

Using the VASP code, key magneto-optical properties were calculated, including Zero-Phonon Lines (ZPL), Huang-Rhys factors ($S$), and Transition Dipole Moments (TDM). A technical highlight was the adaptation of the Lany-Zunger charge correction method for dielectrically anisotropic materials, using an effective dielectric constant to mitigate artificial periodic interactions.

Results and Key Insights

The screening resulted in a detailed dataset of defects across 29 host materials, including various oxides, sulfides, and selenides.

Distribution of identified defects across different space groups and host materials, categorized by spin state and NV-like characteristics.

The Beryllium "Sweet Spot"

Beryllium (Be) emerged as a particularly promising dopant. When Be substitutes for a cation in SrS, MgS, or SrO, it consistently creates defects with properties remarkably similar to the NV center in diamond. These include high spin ($S=1$) and ZPLs in the visible red spectrum (~2 eV). Specifically, Be-substitutional defects in SrS, MgS, and SrO showed ZPLs of 2.06 eV, 1.94 eV, and 1.95 eV respectively—very close to the NV center's 1.945 eV.

Host Material Performance

Strontium oxide (SrO) stood out as an exceptionally fertile ground, hosting 11 different high-spin NV-like defects. Its high dielectric constant helps isolate the defect from the surrounding environment. Furthermore, many identified hosts, like CaS and $CaCO_3$, have predicted $T_2$ (coherence) times exceeding 10 milliseconds, making them highly competitive for quantum sensing.

Symmetry and Pseudo-Symmetry

While "essential" symmetry enforced by the crystal lattice is vital for protecting quantum states, the authors discovered that "accidental" or "pseudo-symmetries" are also powerful. In $Mg_3TeO_6$, for instance, the local environment around the defect is nearly octahedral, creating high-spin states despite the lower bulk crystal symmetry.

Discussion and Future Outlook

Out of thousands of possible configurations, the study identified 13 defects that sit on the "defect hull" (thermodynamically stable) and meet strict quantum criteria: ZPL > 0.5 eV, Spin ≥ 1, and a TDM > 3 Debye.

The authors acknowledge that this is a "screening-level" study. The calculations used the PBE functional, which is computationally efficient but can underestimate bandgaps. Future high-accuracy evaluations using HSE06 hybrid functionals are recommended for the top candidates. Additionally, while this study focused on single point defects, future work will likely expand this high-throughput approach to complex multi-atom defect clusters, which may offer even superior quantum performance.

Summary updated

Abstract

Point defects in semiconductors offer a promising platform for advancing quantum technologies due to their localized energy states and controllable spin properties. Prior research has focused on a limited set of defects within materials such as diamond, silicon carbide, and hexagonal boron nitride. We present a high-throughput study to systematically identify and evaluate point defects across a diverse range of host materials, aiming to uncover previously unexplored defects in novel host materials suitable for use in quantum applications. A range of host materials are selected for their desirable properties, such as appropriate bandgaps, crystal structure, and absence of d- or f-electrons. The Automatic Defect Analysis and Qualification (ADAQ) software framework is used to generate vacancies, substitutions with s- and p-elements, and interstitials in these materials and use density functional theory to calculate key properties such as Zero-Phonon Lines (ZPLs), ionic displacements, Transition Dipole Moments (TDMs), and formation energies. Special attention is given to charge correction methods for materials with dielectric anisotropy. We uncover new defect-host combinations with advantageous properties for quantum applications: 28 defects across 11 isotropic and 2 anisotropic host materials show properties similar to the nitrogen-vacancy (NV) center in diamond. Beryllium (Be) substitutional defects in SrS, MgS, and SrO emerge as particularly promising. These findings contribute to diversifying and enhancing the materials available for quantum technologies.
BibTeX
@misc{groppfeldt2025high,
  author = {Oscar Groppfeldt and Joel Davidsson and Rickard Armiento},
  title = {{High-Throughput Exploration of NV-like Color Centers Across Host Materials}},
  year = {2025},
  eprint = {2503.23828},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2503.23828},
  howpublished = {arXiv},
}
Figure