Hierarchical High-Point Energy Flow Network for Jet Tagging

Wei Shen, Daohan Wang, Jin Min YangarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a new deep learning framework that "plugs" neural networks directly into the mathematical foundations of jet physics. By reorganizing Energy Flow Polynomials (EFPs) into a hierarchical structure, the authors created Hierarchical Energy Flow Networks (HEFNs) that are both high-performing and strictly Infrared and Collinear (IRC) safe—a critical requirement for robust particle physics analysis.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In high-energy physics, "jets" are sprays of particles produced in collisions. To identify the origin of these jets (e.g., a top quark vs. a gluon), physicists look at their "substructure."

There is a long-standing tension between two approaches:

  1. Traditional Physics Observables: Bases like Energy Flow Polynomials (EFPs) are systematic and IRC-safe (meaning the result doesn't change if a particle splits into two or emits very low-energy radiation). However, they are often limited to linear combinations and can be computationally expensive.
  2. Deep Learning: Models like ParticleNet achieve incredible accuracy but are often "black boxes" that may not strictly respect IRC-safety, making them harder to validate against theoretical QCD calculations.

This paper bridges the gap by showing how to insert non-linear neural networks inside the EFP summation logic without breaking the underlying physics constraints.

Methods

The authors introduce a "hierarchical" reorganization of EFPs. Instead of computing complex multi-particle correlations in one go, they break them down into recursive, energy-weighted steps.

  • HEFN (Hierarchical Energy Flow Network): This model uses Legendre polynomials to encode the angular distances between particles. These polynomials provide an orthogonal basis that ensures numerical stability. The model then uses Multi-Layer Perceptrons (MLPs) to process these features at each step of the hierarchy. Because the non-linearities are applied after energy-weighted summations, the model maintains "hierarchical IRC-safety."
  • LHEFN (Local HEFN): To solve the $O(M^2)$ computational complexity of looking at every particle pair, the authors proposed a "local" version. It uses neighbor aggregation (a "query ball" approach) to ignore distant particles, significantly boosting speed while maintaining comparable performance.

Datasets

The models were evaluated on two standard high-energy physics benchmarks:

  • Top Tagging Dataset: Distinguishing hadronic top quark decays (signal) from QCD di-jets (background). This dataset contains 1.2M training events.
  • Quark/Gluon Discrimination Dataset: Separating quark-initiated jets from gluon-initiated jets. This is a notoriously difficult task due to the subtle differences in radiation patterns.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Non-linearity within Safety: The "aha moment" is that IRC-safety is preserved as long as the neural network acts on the output of an energy-weighted sum. This allows the model to learn a much wider, non-linear space of observables than traditional EFPs.
  • Path-Graph Simplification: The authors focused on "path graphs"—the simplest class of EFPs. They demonstrated that even this subset, when enhanced with neural networks, is powerful enough to match or beat complex graph-based models.
  • Interpretability: Because the model is built on a basis of Legendre polynomials and energy fractions, the learned features have a clearer physical meaning compared to standard point-cloud networks.

Key Results

The HEFN and LHEFN architectures achieved performance competitive with state-of-the-art (SOTA) models like ParticleNet and LorentzNet, despite using only basic kinematic information ($p_T, \eta, \phi$).

  • Top Tagging: HEFN achieved an Area Under the Curve (AUC) of 0.9846, outperforming several established models like PFN and ResNeXt-50.
  • Quark/Gluon: HEFN reached an AUC of 0.9002, showing strong discrimination in a challenging task.
  • Efficiency: The LHEFN (Local) version showed a "remarkable boost in speed," making it more practical for real-time applications or large-scale data processing without a significant drop in accuracy.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Symmetry Constraints: In this work, the authors relaxed Lorentz invariance to SO(2) rotational symmetry around the jet axis. They suggest that future versions could achieve full Lorentz invariance by replacing angular distances with invariant mass quantities.
  • Information Gaps: The current model does not utilize Particle Identification (PID) information. Adding PID could further improve quark/gluon discrimination.
  • Graph Complexity: The study only utilized path-graph structures. Exploring more complex graph topologies (like trees or loops) within the hierarchical framework could unlock even more discriminative power.

Summary updated

Abstract

Jet substructure observable basis is a systematic and powerful tool for analyzing the internal energy distribution of constituent particles within a jet. In this work, we propose a novel method to insert neural networks into jet substructure basis as a simple yet efficient interpretable IRC-safe deep learning framework to discover discriminative jet observables. The Energy Flow Polynomial (EFP) could be computed with a certain summation order, resulting in a reorganized form which exhibits hierarchical IRC-safety. Thus inserting non-linear functions after the separate summation could significantly extend the scope of IRC-safe jet substructure observables, where neural networks can come into play as an important role. Based on the structure of the simplest class of EFPs which corresponds to path graphs, we propose the Hierarchical Energy Flow Networks and the Local Hierarchical Energy Flow Networks. These two architectures exhibit remarkable discrimination performance on the top tagging dataset and quark-gluon dataset compared to other benchmark algorithms even only utilizing the kinematic information of constituent particles.
BibTeX
@misc{shen2023hierarchical,
  author = {Wei Shen and Daohan Wang and Jin Min Yang},
  title = {{Hierarchical High-Point Energy Flow Network for Jet Tagging}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2308.08300},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2308.08300},
}

Loading related content...

Figure