HiCSR: a Hi-C super-resolution framework for producing highly realistic contact maps

Michael C. Dimmick, Leo J. Lee, Brendan J. FreybioRxiv 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

High-resolution Hi-C data is crucial for understanding genome architecture but is expensive to generate. This paper introduces HiCSR, a deep learning framework that uses a novel loss function combining adversarial, feature reconstruction, and pixel-wise losses to accurately enhance low-resolution Hi-C data into high-resolution maps. HiCSR outperforms existing methods in generating realistic contact maps and recovering biologically significant features like TAD boundaries.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The 3D organization of the genome plays a vital role in gene regulation and function. Hi-C experiments generate contact maps that reveal this organization, with higher resolution maps being essential for studying fine-grained structures like chromatin loops and topologically associating domains (TADs). However, obtaining high-resolution Hi-C data requires extensive sequencing, making it a significant experimental bottleneck. While machine learning, particularly deep learning, offers a promising solution to computationally enhance low-resolution data, existing methods often produce blurred outputs or introduce artifacts. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a more accurate and realistic Hi-C super-resolution framework.

Methods

The core of the HiCSR framework is a Generative Adversarial Network (GAN) architecture. What makes HiCSR novel is its custom loss function, which combines three components:

  • Adversarial Loss: This component, standard in GANs, trains a discriminator network to distinguish between real high-resolution Hi-C maps and the super-resolved maps generated by HiCSR. This encourages the generator to produce visually convincing outputs.
  • Feature Reconstruction Loss: This is a key innovation. HiCSR uses a pre-trained denoising autoencoder to extract feature representations from both the true high-resolution and the generated super-resolved Hi-C maps. The loss is calculated based on the similarity of these feature representations, ensuring that the generated maps capture essential structural information.
  • Pixel-wise L1 Loss: This standard loss function directly minimizes the difference between individual pixels (interaction frequencies) in the generated and true high-resolution maps, promoting pixel-level accuracy.

The generator network itself is a deep convolutional network with residual blocks and skip connections, designed for efficient feature propagation.

Datasets

The primary dataset used for training and evaluation is Hi-C data from the GM12878 cell type, obtained from the Gene Expression Omnibus (GEO) database (accession GSE63525). For evaluating cross-cell type and cross-species transferability, Hi-C data from NHEK (human) and CH12LX (mouse) cell types were also utilized.

The paper introduces a novel benchmark by evaluating Hi-C enhancement methods using a suite of Hi-C specific reproducibility metrics developed by the ENCODE Consortium (GenomeDISCO, HiC-Spector, HiCRep, and QUASAR-Rep). This is presented as a more biologically relevant evaluation than traditional image-based metrics like MSE or correlation coefficients, which can be misleading for Hi-C data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The importance of a multi-faceted loss function: HiCSR's success stems from combining adversarial, feature reconstruction, and pixel-wise losses. This holistic approach addresses different aspects of "realism" – visual plausibility, structural fidelity, and pixel accuracy – which single-loss approaches often miss.
  • Denoising autoencoders as feature extractors for biological data: The paper demonstrates that denoising autoencoders can learn meaningful, interpretable features from Hi-C data, such as textures, self-interacting loci, TADs, and even chromatin loops. This suggests their utility beyond just denoising, acting as a powerful tool for unsupervised representation learning in biological contexts.
  • Hi-C specific metrics are crucial for evaluation: Traditional image quality metrics are insufficient for evaluating Hi-C super-resolution. The paper strongly advocates for and demonstrates the superiority of reproducibility metrics that account for the unique spatial structure and "distance effect" inherent in Hi-C data.
  • Transferability of learned Hi-C structures: HiCSR shows remarkable ability to transfer learned super-resolution mappings across different cell types and even species, indicating that fundamental principles of chromatin organization are captured by the model.

Key Results

  • HiCSR significantly outperforms existing Hi-C super-resolution methods (HiCPlus, HiCNN, hicGAN, DeepHiC) on a suite of four Hi-C specific reproducibility metrics, achieving an average score of 0.958 compared to the next best (HiCNN) at 0.931.
  • Visually, HiCSR-enhanced maps are more realistic, avoiding the blurriness of HiCPlus/HiCNN, the errors of hicGAN, and the unnatural "wave-like" artifacts of DeepHiC.
  • HiCSR effectively recovers biologically significant features, such as TAD boundaries, with significantly reduced error in insulation scores compared to low-resolution data.
  • The framework demonstrates strong performance in transferring learned mappings across cell types (GM12878, NHEK) and species (human, mouse), maintaining high reproducibility scores.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Cross-cell type performance degradation: While HiCSR shows good transferability, there is a slight performance degradation when training on one cell type and testing on another, especially with very low sequence depth.
  • Ensemble methods: The authors suggest exploring ensemble methods by training HiCSR on larger, more varied datasets to improve cross-cell super-resolution predictions.
  • Incorporating side information: Future work could involve providing additional information (e.g., genomic distance) to the model during training and prediction to further enhance optimization.
  • Comparison with emerging methods: The paper calls for further research to compare HiCSR with other emerging Hi-C enhancement techniques, such as HIFI, to understand their respective strengths and optimal use cases.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Motivation Hi-C data has enabled the genome-wide study of chromatin folding and architecture, and has led to important discoveries in the structure and function of chromatin conformation. Here, high resolution data plays a particularly important role as many chromatin substructures such as Topologically Associating Domains (TADs) and chromatin loops cannot be adequately studied with low resolution contact maps. However, the high sequencing costs associated with the generation of high resolution Hi-C data has become an experimental barrier. Data driven machine learning models, which allow low resolution Hi-C data to be computationally enhanced, offer a promising avenue to address this challenge. Results By carefully examining the properties of Hi-C maps and integrating various recent advances in deep learning, we developed a Hi-C Super-Resolution (HiCSR) framework capable of accurately recovering the fine details, textures, and substructures found in high resolution contact maps. This was achieved using a novel loss function tailored to the Hi-C enhancement problem which optimizes for an adversarial loss from a Generative Adversarial Network (GAN), a feature reconstruction loss derived from the latent representation of a denoising autoencoder, and a pixel-wise loss. Not only can the resulting framework generate enhanced Hi-C maps more visually similar to the original high resolution maps, it also excels on a suite of reproducibility metrics produced by members of the ENCODE Consortium compared to existing approaches, including HiCPlus, HiCNN, hicGAN and DeepHiC. Finally, we demonstrate that HiCSR is capable of enhancing Hi-C data across sequencing depth, cell types, and species, recovering biologically significant contact domain boundaries. Availability We make our implementation available for download at: https://github.com/PSI-Lab/HiCSR Contact [email protected] Supplementary information Available Online
BibTeX
@misc{dimmick2020hicsr,
  author = {Michael C. Dimmick and Leo J. Lee and Brendan J. Frey},
  title = {{HiCSR: a Hi-C super-resolution framework for producing highly realistic contact maps}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1101/2020.02.24.961714},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure