Herd Routes: A Preventative IoT-Based System for Improving Female Pedestrian Safety on City Streets

Madeleine Woodburn, Wynita M. Griggs, Jakub Marecek, Robert N. Shorten

Abstract

"Herd Routes" is a preventative IoT-based system designed to improve female pedestrian safety by incentivizing people to walk along specific "busy" routes. By combining a dynamic pricing controller (PID) with a zero-fee distributed ledger (IOTA Tangle), the system creates a "safety in numbers" effect through societal incentivization rather than reactive emergency alerts. This paper presents the architecture, simulation results, and hardware-in-the-loop testing of the proposed system.

Introduction

Despite the prevalence of location-based safety apps, most existing solutions are reactive, relying on "panic buttons" or triggers that activate only after a threat is perceived. Furthermore, these tools often place the burden of safety entirely on the potential victim. Research indicates that pedestrians, particularly women, feel significantly safer on busier, well-lit streets. This paper addresses the challenge of "preventative safety" by proposing a system to proactively orchestrate urban pedestrian flow, ensuring individuals do not have to walk alone on quiet, high-risk streets.

System Architecture and Methods

The proposed system utilizes a three-layer architecture: User, Application, and Ledger. This structure facilitates a seamless transition from user onboarding to routine use, where the app calculates routes and manages token incentives.

The three-layer architecture and user workflow for the Herd Routes system.

Dynamic Incentivization

The core of the system is a Proportional-Integral-Derivative (PID) controller used to manage pedestrian density. If a specific route is under-populated, the "token price" (reward) for walking that route increases to attract more users. As the route reaches a target density, the reward decreases to maintain stability.

Block diagram of the PID controller used for dynamic pedestrian density regulation.

Distributed Ledger Technology

To handle micro-payments and maintain a secure, immutable record of user locations, the authors selected the IOTA Tangle. Unlike traditional blockchains, IOTA is designed for IoT; its fee-less structure is essential for high-frequency messaging and micro-incentives where transaction fees would otherwise exceed the reward value.

Hardware-in-the-Loop (HIL) Testing

The system was validated through an Android app integrated with the Simulation of Urban Mobility (SUMO). This allowed real-world users to interact with a simulated crowd of 750 agents, testing technical feasibility and user desirability within a map of the Imperial College London campus derived from OpenStreetMap (OSM).

Results

Experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of the PID controller in regulating pedestrian density. The error signal—the difference between actual and target density—consistently trended toward zero across 2,000-step simulations. The system successfully achieved a "critical mass" benchmark (roughly 5 users per street) in the majority of test cases. On average, it took 174.64 simulation steps for the first agent to navigate onto an incentivized route once the system was active. User validation through HIL tests indicated that participants felt more aware of others and perceived themselves as part of a community.

Discussion and Future Work

While the system shows promise, several challenges remain. Data privacy is a primary concern, though 63% of study participants felt location sharing was justified for safety. Potential "honey pot" risks could be mitigated through a referral-based trust system. Future work will explore sustainable financing models (e.g., local business or city council sponsorship) and integrate environmental data such as lighting and CCTV coverage into the routing intelligence.

Summary updated

Abstract

Over two thirds of women of all ages in the UK have experienced some form of sexual harassment in a public space. Recent tragic incidents involving female pedestrians have highlighted some of the personal safety issues that women still face in cities today. There exist many popular location-based safety applications as a result of this; however, these applications tend to take a reactive approach where action is taken only after an incident has occurred. This paper proposes a preventative approach to the problem by creating safer public environments through societal incentivisation. The proposed system, called "Herd Routes", improves the safety of female pedestrians by generating busier pedestrian routes as a result of route incentivisation. A novel application of distributed ledgers is proposed to provide security and trust, a record of system users' locations and IDs, and a platform for token exchange. A proof-of-concept was developed using the simulation package SUMO (Simulation of Urban Mobility), and a smartphone app. was built in Android Studio so that pedestrian Hardware-in-the-Loop testing could be carried out to validate the technical feasibility and desirability of the system. With positive results from the initial testing of the proof-of-concept, further development could significantly contribute towards creating safer pedestrian routes through cities, and tackle the societal change that is required to improve female pedestrian safety in the long term.
BibTeX
@article{woodburn2025herd,
  author = {Madeleine Woodburn and Wynita M. Griggs and Jakub Marecek and Robert N. Shorten},
  title = {{Herd Routes: A Preventative IoT-Based System for Improving Female Pedestrian Safety on City Streets}},
  journal = {Int. J. Control},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1080/00207179.2024.2380025},
}
Figure