Heart Rate Variability Parameters During Psychogenic Non-epileptic Seizures: Comparison Between Patients With Pure PNES and Comorbid Epilepsy

Andrea Romigi, Giada Ricciardo Rizzo, Francesca Izzi, Maria Guerrisi, Marco Caccamo, Federica Testa, Diego Centonze, Nicola Biagio Mercuri, Nicola ToschiFrontiers in Neurology 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Introduction: Psychogenic non-epileptic seizures (PNES) often resemble epileptic seizures, leading to frequent misdiagnosis. This study aimed to compare heart rate variability (HRV) parameters—indicators of autonomic nervous system (ANS) regulation—during PNES in patients with pure PNES (pPNES) versus those with comorbid epilepsy (PNES/ES). Methods: We analyzed HRV data from video-electroencephalography recordings of 22 patients (11 pPNES and 11 PNES/ES) across four conditions: basal (BAS), before PNES (PRE), during PNES (ICT), and after PNES (POST). Results: HRV analysis showed significantly higher ICT LF and LF/HF ratio compared to other conditions. We also found higher POST HF and RMSSD, lower RRI in ICT, and lower ICT ApEn. A sympathovagal imbalance was more evident in pPNES as compared to PNES/ES. Significance: Our data suggest a sympathetic overdrive during PNES followed by a post-PNES increase in vagal tone. This "autonomic rollercoaster" is more pronounced in patients with pure PNES.

Introduction

Psychogenic non-epileptic seizures (PNES) are episodes that superficially resemble epileptic seizures but are rooted in psychological processes rather than abnormal electrical discharges in the brain. Because of this clinical similarity, PNES are frequently misdiagnosed, often resulting in years of inappropriate treatment with anti-epileptic drugs. While it is well-established that epileptic seizures profoundly affect the Autonomic Nervous System (ANS), the "autonomic signature" of PNES is less understood. This study investigates whether the heart's reaction differs between patients who only have PNES (pPNES) and those with a "dual diagnosis" of both PNES and epilepsy (PNES/ES).

Methods

The researchers conducted a retrospective analysis of 22 patients (11 pPNES, 11 PNES/ES) recruited from the Outpatients Epilepsy Center at the University of Rome Tor Vergata. ECG data were extracted from video-electroencephalography (vEEG) recordings to calculate Heart Rate Variability (HRV) across four distinct phases: Basal (BAS), Pre-ictal (PRE, 2 minutes before), Ictal (ICT, during), and Post-ictal (POST, 2 minutes after).

Figure 1: Flow diagram of the study illustrating the recruitment and allocation of patients into pPNES and PNES/ES groups for analysis.

The study utilized a comprehensive battery of HRV metrics, including frequency domain (LF, HF, LF/HF ratio), time domain (RMSSD, SDNN), and non-linear dynamics such as Approximate Entropy (ApEn), which measures the complexity and regularity of the heart rhythm.

Key Results

The analysis revealed a significant "autonomic rollercoaster" during PNES events. During the seizure (ICT phase), the heart enters a state of "sympathetic overdrive," marked by a spike in Low Frequency (LF) power and the Cardiosympathetic Index (CSI), alongside a drop in the R-R interval (increased heart rate). Immediately following the seizure (POST phase), the body attempts to compensate with a vagal rebound, evidenced by significantly higher RMSSD and High Frequency (HF) power compared to the basal state.

Table 3: HRV parameters across the four study conditions (BAS, PRE, ICT, POST). Significant changes are observed in sympathetic and parasympathetic markers across the seizure phases.

Crucially, the study found that patients with pure PNES (pPNES) exhibited a significantly higher LF value than the PNES/ES group ($p = 0.00012$), indicating a more severe sympathovagal imbalance. Furthermore, the drop in Approximate Entropy (ApEn) during the seizure suggests the heart rhythm becomes more rigid and less adaptable under the stress of the event.

Discussion and Limitations

These findings suggest that the autonomic system in pPNES patients may be more reactive or less "habituated" to seizure-like events than in those who also suffer from true epilepsy. While the study is limited by its small sample size (n=22) and a significant gender bias (90% female), it points toward the potential use of HRV "signatures" as diagnostic markers. Future work using wearable technology could help clinicians differentiate PNES from epilepsy at the bedside and investigate whether the observed sympathetic overdrive correlates with long-term cardiovascular risk.

Summary updated

Abstract

<b>Introduction:</b> Psychogenic non-epileptic seizures (PNES) may resemble epileptic seizures. There are few data about ictal ANS activity alterations induced by PNES in patients with pure PNES (pPNES) compared to PNES with comorbid epilepsy (PNES/ES). We aimed to compare heart rate variability (HRV) parameters and hence autonomic regulation in PNES in epileptic and non-epileptic patients. <b>Methods</b>: We obtained HRV data from video-electroencephalography recordings in 22 patients presenting PNES (11 pPNES and 11 PNES/ES) in awake, and supine states. We calculated HRV parameters in both time and frequency domains including low frequency (LF) power, high frequency power (HF), LF/HF ratio, square root of the mean of the sum of the squares of differences between adjacent R wave intervals (RMSSD) and the standard deviation of all consecutive R wave intervals (SDNN). We also evaluated approximate entropy (ApEn), cardiosympathetic index (CSI), and cardiovagal index (CVI). Four conditions were considered: basal condition (BAS), before PNES (PRE), during PNES (ICT) and after PNES (POST). <b>Results:</b> HRV analysis showed significantly higher ICT LF and LF/HF ratio vs. each condition. We also found higher POST HF vs. PRE and BAS, lower RRI in ICT vs. each condition and PRE vs. BAS. POST RMSSD was significantly higher compared to all other states. ICT CSI was significantly higher compared to all other states, whereas CSI was significantly lower in POST vs. PRE and PRE CVI lower than ICT and higher in POST vs. BAS and PRE. Also, ICT ApEn was lower than in all other states. Higher LF in pPNES vs. PNES/ES was also evident when compared across groups. <b>Significance:</b> A few studies examined HRV alterations in PNES, reporting high sympathetic tone (although less evident than in epileptic seizures). Our data suggest a sympathetic overdrive before and during PNES followed by a post-PNES increase in vagal tone. A sympathovagal imbalance was more evident in pPNES as compared to PNES/ES.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{romigi2020heart,
  author = {Andrea Romigi and Giada Ricciardo Rizzo and Francesca Izzi and Maria Guerrisi and Marco Caccamo and Federica Testa and Diego Centonze and Nicola Biagio Mercuri and Nicola Toschi},
  title = {{Heart Rate Variability Parameters During Psychogenic Non-epileptic Seizures: Comparison Between Patients With Pure PNES and Comorbid Epilepsy}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Neurology},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3389/fneur.2020.00713},
}
Figure