Have You Been a Victim of COVID-19-Related Cyber Incidents? Survey, Taxonomy, and Mitigation Strategies

Saqib Hakak, Wazir Zada Khan, Muhammad Imran, Kim-Kwang Raymond Choo, Muhammad Shoaib

Introduction

The COVID-19 pandemic necessitated a rapid global transition to remote work and online education. This shift created a "perfect storm" for cybercriminals, as security perimeters moved from managed corporate offices to unpatched, consumer-grade home networks. Attackers exploited not only technical vulnerabilities but also the psychological state of the public—leveraging fear and urgency to bypass security instincts.

The causal chain from COVID-19 effects to increased cyberattack risks.

Taxonomy of Pandemic-Era Cyber Threats

To address the lack of structured understanding regarding these weaponized incidents, this research proposes a comprehensive taxonomy. This framework links fundamental security principles (the CIA triad) to attacker motivations, specific threat methods, and potential mitigation strategies.

A hierarchical taxonomy of security goals, purposes, threats, and mitigation strategies.

The study categorizes threats based on four distinct layers:

  1. Security Goals: The fundamental principles being attacked, such as Availability, Confidentiality, Authenticity, and Integrity.
  2. Purpose: The attacker's motivation, ranging from financial gain to disrupting essential services.
  3. Threats: Specific methods used, including Vishing, Ransomware, DDoS, and Disinformation.
  4. Mitigation Strategies: Proposed technical and policy-based solutions like international collaboration and rapid risk management frameworks.

Data Synthesis and Methodology

The authors conducted a qualitative analysis of real-world incidents reported during the first half of 2020. Data was synthesized from diverse sources, including:

  • Governmental Reports: Data from the US Federal Trade Commission (FTC), Australia’s Scamwatch, and Singapore’s Ministry for Home Affairs.
  • Cyber Intelligence: Reports from Europol, RiskIQ, Google, and NETSCOUT.
  • Incident Tracking: Analysis of specific malware like CovidLock and AZORult, alongside targeted attacks on organizations like the WHO and Hammersmith Medicines Research.

Key Insights: The Shift to "Fearware"

A critical finding is the rise of "Fearware"—disinformation campaigns designed to induce panic. By spreading fake cures or alarming news, attackers drive users to install spyware disguised as trackers. Furthermore, the "Enterprise-to-Home Shift" transferred the security burden to individual users who often lack the tools or knowledge to secure "Bring Your Own Device" (BYOD) setups.

The healthcare sector emerged as the most vulnerable target. DDoS and ransomware attacks on hospitals during the pandemic have had life-or-death consequences, delaying urgent surgeries and chemotherapy treatments.

Quantitative Impact

The scale of the problem in early 2020 was immense:

  • Financial Loss: By April 2020, the US FTC reported over $12 million lost to fraud; Australia reported losses exceeding AUD 16 million.
  • Attack Volume: RiskIQ detected over 309,000 pandemic-themed spam emails in a single three-day window in April 2020.
  • Malware Diversity: Specific threats included CovidLock (screen-locking ransomware) and AZORult (info-stealing malware targeting coronavirus maps).

Future Directions

While this study captures the early pandemic landscape, future research must address the evolution of these threats, such as Advanced Persistent Threats (APTs) targeting vaccine research. Key recommendations include:

  • Developing Rapid Risk Management Frameworks for dynamic emergency environments where traditional audits are too slow.
  • Integrating basic cybersecurity curriculum into medical education for frontline workers.
  • Utilizing AI-based defenses, such as automated bots to counter Vishing (voice phishing) for non-technical users.

Summary updated

Abstract

Cybercriminals are constantly on the lookout for new attack vectors, and the recent COVID-19 pandemic is no exception. For example, social distancing measures have resulted in travel bans, lockdowns, and stay-at-home orders, consequently increasing the reliance on information and communications technologies, such as Zoom. Cybercriminals have also attempted to exploit the pandemic to facilitate a broad range of malicious activities, such as attempting to take over videoconferencing platforms used in online meetings/educational activities, information theft, and other fraudulent activities. This study briefly reviews some of the malicious cyber activities associated with COVID-19 and the potential mitigation solutions. We also propose an attack taxonomy, which (optimistically) will help guide future risk management and mitigation responses.
BibTeX
@article{hakak2020have,
  author = {Saqib Hakak and Wazir Zada Khan and Muhammad Imran and Kim-Kwang Raymond Choo and Muhammad Shoaib},
  title = {{Have You Been a Victim of COVID-19-Related Cyber Incidents? Survey, Taxonomy, and Mitigation Strategies}},
  journal = {IEEE Access},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1109/access.2020.3006172},
}
Figure