Harvesting Full-Duplex Rate Gains in Cellular Networks with Half-Duplex User Terminals

Ahmad AlAmmouri, Hesham ElSawy, Mohamed-Slim Alouini

Abstract: Full-Duplex (FD) transceivers are often too complex and power-hungry for widespread implementation in user terminals. This paper investigates the 3-node topology (3NT), a configuration where an FD-capable base station (BS) simultaneously serves two half-duplex (HD) users—one on the uplink and one on the downlink. Using a tractable mathematical framework based on stochastic geometry, the authors demonstrate that 3NT can achieve performance remarkably close to a full FD network (2-node topology). Results show that with efficient self-interference cancellation (SIC), 3NT suffers only a 5% rate loss compared to 2NT. Crucially, if UE-side SIC is imperfect, 3NT becomes the superior architecture. This suggests that FD gains can be harvested primarily through base station upgrades, regardless of the user terminal's duplexing scheme.

Introduction

The demand for higher data rates in cellular networks has pushed researchers toward Full-Duplex (FD) communication, which allows for simultaneous transmission and reception on the same frequency. While theoretically doubling capacity, FD faces significant hurdles: self-interference (SI) at the transceiver and increased network-wide interference. While base stations can accommodate the bulky and expensive hardware required for high-performance SI cancellation, doing so for every consumer smartphone is economically and technically challenging. This paper addresses whether we can achieve FD-level performance by upgrading only the infrastructure, keeping user equipment (UE) in traditional Half-Duplex (HD) mode.

The 3-Node Topology and α-Duplex Design

The core of this research is the 3-node topology (3NT). In this setup, an FD base station manages two separate HD users: one transmitting (UL) and one receiving (DL) in the same time-frequency resource. To analyze this, the authors developed a unified framework using Stochastic Geometry, modeling base station and user locations as a Poisson Point Process (PPP).

3-Node Topology and α-Duplex Spectrum Allocation

A key innovation is the α-duplex scheme, which introduces a parameter α to represent the degree of overlap between UL and DL channels. When α=0, the system behaves as a standard HD network; when α=1, it operates in full in-band FD. This flexibility allows for fine-tuning the balance between UL and DL rates. Furthermore, the model incorporates realistic pulse shaping (rectangular and triangular) and matched filtering, accounting for the spectral leakage that occurs in real-world hardware.

Performance Analysis and Key Insights

The study rigorously compares 3NT against the 2-node topology (2NT), where the base station communicates with a single FD-capable user. The results challenge the assumption that FD hardware is necessary at both ends of the link.

Rate Performance Comparison: 3NT vs. 2NT

The analysis yields several critical insights:

  1. Diminishing Returns for FD UEs: The performance gap between 3NT and 2NT is surprisingly small. Even with perfect SI cancellation in FD phones, 3NT only loses about 5% of the total rate.
  2. The SIC Threshold: The graph above illustrates that 3NT is highly robust. If an FD phone's SI cancellation is not near-perfect (e.g., βu = -75 dBm), the 3NT approach with HD phones actually provides a higher downlink rate (ℛd) because HD phones are inherently immune to self-interference.
  3. Infrastructure-Centric Gains: The findings suggest that the duplexing capability of the base station is the dominant factor in harvesting network-wide rate gains.

Conclusion

This research provides a strong argument for prioritizing Full-Duplex upgrades at the base station level. By utilizing the 3-node topology and optimizing channel overlap via the α-duplex scheme, network operators can deliver near-FD speeds to existing half-duplex user terminals. This path avoids the cost and complexity of integrating FD hardware into mobile devices while still realizing the capacity benefits of next-generation wireless communication.

Reference: AlAmmouri, A., ElSawy, H., & Alouini, M. S. (2016). Harvesting Full-Duplex Rate Gains in Cellular Networks with Half-Duplex User Terminals. arXiv:1511.00207v2 [cs.IT].

Summary updated

Abstract

Full-Duplex (FD) transceivers may be expensive in terms of complexity, power consumption, and price to be implemented in all user terminals. Therefore, techniques to exploit in-band full-duplex communication with FD base stations (BSs) and half-duplex (HD) users' equipment (UEs) are required. In this context, 3-node topology (3NT) has been recently proposed for FD BSs to reuse the uplink (UL) and downlink (DL) channels with HD terminals within the same cell. In this paper, we present a tractable mathematical framework, based on stochastic geometry, for 3NT in cellular networks. To this end, we propose a design paradigm via pulse-shaping and partial overlap between UL and DL channels to maximize the harvested rate gains in 3NT. The results show that 3NT achieves a close performance to networks with FD BSs and FD UEs, denoted by 2-node topology (2NT) networks. A maximum of 5$\%$ rate loss is reported when 3NT is compared to 2NT with efficient self-interference cancellation (SIC). If the SIC in 2NT is not efficient, 3NT highly outperforms 2NT. Consequently, we conclude that, irrespective to the UE duplexing scheme, it is sufficient to have FD BSs to harvest FD rate gains.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{alammouri2016harvesting,
  author = {Ahmad AlAmmouri and Hesham ElSawy and Mohamed-Slim Alouini},
  title = {{Harvesting Full-Duplex Rate Gains in Cellular Networks with Half-Duplex User Terminals}},
  booktitle = {ICC},
  year = {2016},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=K6EyzOtcUUR},
}
Figure