Hardware Limitations and Optimization Approach in 1-Bit RIS Design at 28 GHz

Hossein Rezaei, Mehmet Emin Arslan, George Yammine, Niels Neumann, Norman FranchiarXiv 2025 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Reconfigurable intelligent surfaces (RIS) have emerged as a transformative technology for electromagnetic (EM) wave manipulation, offering unprecedented control over wave reflections compared to traditional metallic reflectors. By utilizing an array of tunable elements, RIS can steer and shape electromagnetic waves to enhance signal quality in wireless communication and radar systems. However, practical implementations face significant challenges due to hardware limitations and phase quantization errors. In this work, a 1-bit RIS prototype operating at 28 GHz is developed to experimentally evaluate the impact of hardware constraints on RIS performance. Unlike conventional studies that model RIS as an ideal phase-shift matrix, this study accounts for physical parameters that influence the actual reflection pattern. In particular, the presence of specular reflection due to hardware limitations is investigated. Additionally, the effects of phase quantization errors, which stem from the discrete nature of RIS elements, are analyzed, and a genetic algorithm (GA)-based optimization is introduced to mitigate these errors. The proposed optimization strategy effectively reduces gain degradation at the desired angle caused by 1-bit quantization, enhancing the overall performance of RIS. The effectiveness of the approach is validated through measurements, underscoring the importance of advanced phase control techniques in improving the functionality of RIS.

Introduction

Reconfigurable Intelligent Surfaces (RIS) act as programmable smart mirrors for electromagnetic waves, using arrays of tunable unit cells to reflect signals in specific directions. This is a highly anticipated technology for 5G/6G networks to eliminate dead zones and improve channel capacity. However, a massive gap exists between theoretical RIS models and physical reality. Most theoretical studies model RIS as an ideal matrix capable of continuous, perfect phase shifts. In reality—especially at high frequencies like 28 GHz (mmWave)—hardware is constrained by size, cost, and mechanical stability.

To make RIS practical, engineers often use 1-bit phase shifters, such as PIN diodes, that only offer two states (ON and OFF). This discrete binary nature introduces severe phase quantization errors. Furthermore, physical imperfections cause unintended "specular" reflections—bouncing off the surface's back layer like a standard mirror—and deviations from the ideal 180° phase difference between the ON/OFF states. This paper explores how to maximize the performance of a physically constrained 1-bit RIS despite these real-world hardware limitations.

Hardware Design and Unit Cell Architecture

The authors developed a 1-bit RIS prototype operating at 28 GHz using patch antennas and PIN diodes. The design process involved full-wave Finite Element Method (FEM) simulations to accurately model electromagnetic interactions, specifically analyzing how varying the microstrip line length impacts the phase difference between the ON and OFF states.

Unit cell design for the 28 GHz RIS, illustrating (a) the radiating patch and (b) the integrated biasing network with a PIN diode and RF choke.

The unit cell architecture is divided into a radiating top layer and a biasing bottom layer. The biasing network is critical for controlling the PIN diode states without interfering with the RF signal. This is achieved through the integration of an RF choke and a specific microstrip (MS) line layout.

The biasing mechanism of the unit cell, showing (a) the equivalent circuit with DC source and (b) the corresponding physical layout.

Optimization via Genetic Algorithm

Instead of using standard uniform quantization, which simply rounds the ideal continuous phase to the nearest available 1-bit state, the authors deployed a Genetic Algorithm (GA). The GA treats the binary phase states of the RIS elements as a "chromosome" and iteratively evolves the phase distribution to maximize the coherent summation of reflected signals at the target angle.

This heuristic approach effectively works around the hardware's phase errors by finding a globally optimal binary pattern. Even if the hardware only achieves a 110° or 150° phase difference (rather than the ideal 180°), smart surface-level phase distribution can recover a significant portion of the lost performance.

Key Results and Discussion

The study yielded several critical insights into the behavior of physical RIS arrays:

  • The "Back Layer" Effect: Real-world RIS performance is heavily degraded by passive components like connectors and ground planes acting as a standard mirror. This causes a strong, unintended specular reflection at 0° that cannot be programmed away.
  • Simulation Performance: In simulations targeting a 60° reflection angle, standard 1-bit quantization caused a 4 dB drop in gain compared to an ideal continuous phase shifter. The GA optimization recovered 2 dB of that lost gain and perfectly realigned the main lobe to the target angle.
  • Experimental Validation: A 100-element (10x10) RIS prototype was tested in an anechoic chamber. When reflecting a normally incident wave to a 60° angle, the GA-optimized phase distribution achieved a 2.82 dB increase in received power compared to the standard quantization method.

Conclusion

While the GA successfully improves the gain at the desired reflection angle, it fundamentally cannot eliminate specular reflection caused by the physical back layer. This highlights a fundamental trade-off in low-cost RIS design. Future work will focus on extending the optimization framework to allow for the simultaneous control of both the main lobe and side lobes, as well as testing these systems in dynamic, real-world deployment environments to better understand environmental multipath challenges.

Summary updated

Abstract

Reconfigurable intelligent surfaces (RIS) have emerged as a transformative technology for electromagnetic (EM) wave manipulation, offering unprecedented control over wave reflections compared to traditional metallic reflectors. By utilizing an array of tunable elements, RIS can steer and shape electromagnetic waves to enhance signal quality in wireless communication and radar systems. However, practical implementations face significant challenges due to hardware limitations and phase quantization errors. In this work, a 1-bit RIS prototype operating at 28 GHz is developed to experimentally evaluate the impact of hardware constraints on RIS performance. Unlike conventional studies that model RIS as an ideal phase-shift matrix, this study accounts for physical parameters that influence the actual reflection pattern. In particular, the presence of specular reflection due to hardware limitations is investigated. Additionally, the effects of phase quantization errors, which stem from the discrete nature of RIS elements, are analyzed, and a genetic algorithm (GA)-based optimization is introduced to mitigate these errors. The proposed optimization strategy effectively reduces gain degradation at the desired angle caused by 1-bit quantization, enhancing the overall performance of RIS. The effectiveness of the approach is validated through measurements, underscoring the importance of advanced phase control techniques in improving the functionality of RIS.
BibTeX
@misc{rezaei2025hardware,
  author = {Hossein Rezaei and Mehmet Emin Arslan and George Yammine and Niels Neumann and Norman Franchi},
  title = {{Hardware Limitations and Optimization Approach in 1-Bit RIS Design at 28 GHz}},
  year = {2025},
  eprint = {2506.08930},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2506.08930},
  howpublished = {arXiv},
}
Figure