HAPS in the Non-Terrestrial Network Nexus: Prospective Architectures and Performance Insights

Zhengying Lou, Baha Eddine Youcef Belmekki, Mohamed-Slim Alouini

Introduction

As the telecommunications industry pivots toward 6G, the limitations of purely terrestrial networks have become increasingly apparent. Achieving ubiquitous coverage—reaching remote oceans, mountainous terrain, and disaster-stricken zones—requires a paradigm shift toward Non-Terrestrial Networks (NTN). Researchers at KAUST have identified High-Altitude Platform Stations (HAPS) as the "missing link" in this ecosystem. Operating in the stratosphere at approximately 20 km, HAPS bridge the functional gap between low-altitude Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs) and high-orbiting satellites, offering a unique combination of low latency, high capacity, and expansive coverage.

The NTN Nexus: Addressing the Coverage Gap

Traditional network layers face inherent trade-offs. Terrestrial Macro Base Stations (MBS) are limited by geography; satellites provide global reach but suffer from significant propagation delay and high deployment costs; and UAVs, while flexible, are constrained by limited payload capacity and battery life.

HAPS have recently emerged as a viable middle-tier solution due to advancements in lightweight materials and solar power efficiency. This paper models the "NTN Nexus"—the complex interconnection of satellites, HAPS, UAVs, and ground stations—to quantify how HAPS integration can resolve these long-standing bottlenecks.

Proposed Network Architectures

The research evaluates three distinct architectural frameworks for integrating HAPS into the broader network:

  1. HAPS-Centered Ad-hoc Networks: In this model, HAPS serve as central hubs for swarms of UAVs. By managing routing from a high-altitude vantage point, HAPS help UAVs avoid the "short-hop" delays and signal blockages (such as vegetation or urban canyons) typical in drone-only configurations.
  2. HAPS-Based Cell-Free Networks: Moving away from traditional cellular boundaries, this architecture utilizes multiple HAPS as distributed Access Points (APs) coordinated by a Central Processing Unit (CPU). This provides seamless coverage and eliminates the need for frequent handovers, which are often a source of packet loss and energy waste.
  3. HAPS-Aided Integrated Access and Backhaul (IAB): This hierarchical model uses HAPS to extend the reach of terrestrial MBS. HAPS act as a wireless backhaul bridge, effectively projecting high-speed "hotspot" capabilities into remote or underserved areas.

Methodology

The authors utilize stochastic geometry to model the spatial distribution of users and aerial platforms as point processes. This mathematical framework allows for a rigorous analysis of system-level performance across various channel conditions, including Nakagami-m and shadowed Rician fading. The study evaluates both Radio Frequency (RF) and Free Space Optics (FSO) to determine the most efficient links for high-speed data transmission.

Simulations were conducted using standardized 5G/6G parameters, including a density of 1000 UAVs within a 20 km radius and varying altitudes for users (0 km), UAVs (0.05 km), HAPS (20 km), and LEO satellites (550 km).

Key Performance Insights

The study’s findings highlight the transformative potential of HAPS in three critical areas:

  • Latency and Reliability: In a 40 km span, HAPS-mediated routing reduced total latency by nearly 50% compared to UAV-only strategies. This is largely due to the HAPS's ability to maintain a consistent Line-of-Sight (LoS), bypassing the "vegetation blockage" that can cause up to 20dB of signal loss in lower-altitude links.
  • Energy Efficiency: The cell-free HAPS architecture demonstrated a significant leap in efficiency, achieving an average of 250 Mb/J. In contrast, over 80% of traditional cellular transmissions in the same simulation failed to reach even 40 Mb/J, illustrating the benefits of dynamic user-to-signal association.
  • Throughput and Capacity: In the IAB scenario, HAPS integration supported aggregate downlink rates of up to 16.4 Gbps, proving that stratospheric platforms can effectively scale the capacity of ground-based infrastructure over vast geographic footprints.

Challenges and Future Directions

Despite the promising results, the researchers identify several hurdles to widespread HAPS adoption. The stratosphere is a harsh environment characterized by extreme temperatures (-65°C) and high winds, posing challenges for the structural stability of aerodynamic platforms. Furthermore, international regulatory frameworks for stratospheric flight and spectrum allocation remain underdeveloped.

Future research must also address security vulnerabilities. The reliance on wireless backhaul in an open stratospheric environment necessitates robust encryption and identity authentication protocols to protect the NTN Nexus from malicious interference. As these technical and regulatory barriers are addressed, HAPS are poised to become a cornerstone of the 6G era, providing the connectivity glue for a truly global network.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{lou2023haps,
  author = {Zhengying Lou and Baha Eddine Youcef Belmekki and Mohamed-Slim Alouini},
  title = {{HAPS in the Non-Terrestrial Network Nexus: Prospective Architectures and Performance Insights}},
  journal = {IEEE Wirel. Commun.},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1109/mwc.004.2300198},
}
Figure