HappyMap : A Generalized Multicalibration Method

Zhun Deng, Cynthia Dwork, Linjun Zhang

TL;DR

This paper introduces HappyMap, a novel generalization of "multicalibration" that unifies various algorithmic fairness notions and target-independent learning techniques. HappyMap offers a single meta-algorithm capable of addressing diverse challenges, including fair uncertainty quantification, robust prediction under covariate shift, and improved missing data analysis, while providing a unified theoretical framework.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Algorithmic fairness and reliable prediction in diverse, unseen environments are critical challenges. Existing methods like "multicalibration" aim to ensure fairness by requiring predictors to be indistinguishable from true outcomes across various subgroups. While successful, multicalibration has limitations and doesn't directly address broader issues like target-independent learning (where a model trained on one dataset performs well on another) or robust uncertainty quantification. This paper bridges this gap by proposing a more generalized framework that unifies these disparate concepts and offers new solutions to complex problems.

Methods

The core contribution is s-Happy Multicalibration, a generalization of multicalibration. Instead of just bounding the error of a predictor $f(x)$ against the true outcome $y$ using specific auditor functions $c(f(x), x)$, HappyMap introduces a flexible mapping $s(f(x), y)$. This allows for a richer set of error measures and applications.

The paper presents a single HappyMap meta-algorithm that captures all the proposed results. This algorithm is a gradient-descent-like procedure that iteratively refines a predictor. The theoretical guarantees rely on the concept of a "happy mapping," which ensures the existence of a potential function that bounds the number of iterations. The algorithm is designed to be computationally comparable to existing multicalibration methods.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical contributions and algorithmic frameworks, using generic distributions $D$ and $D_{so}, D_{ta}$ for source and target domains.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Unified Framework: HappyMap provides a single, elegant framework that unifies seemingly disparate concepts like multicalibration, multi-accuracy, target-independent learning, and various fairness notions. This unification simplifies understanding and opens doors for cross-pollination of ideas.
  • Flexibility of the Mapping: The introduction of the $s(f(x), y)$ mapping is a key innovation. It allows for a much broader range of problems to be framed within the multicalibration paradigm, moving beyond simple prediction error to encompass uncertainty quantification, distributional shift, and missing data.
  • "Happy" Mappings: The theoretical underpinning of the algorithm relies on "happy mappings," which are crucial for ensuring convergence. This concept provides a clear condition for when the HappyMap algorithm is guaranteed to succeed.
  • Macro-Learning: The paper frames its contribution within the broader vision of "macro-learning," where algorithms learn by interacting with auditors to identify and correct large errors, offering a more transparent and interpretable learning paradigm.

Key Results

  • HappyMap Meta-Algorithm: A single algorithm is presented that can solve problems related to fair uncertainty quantification, conformal prediction under covariate shift, and missing data analysis.
  • Theoretical Guarantees: The paper provides theoretical guarantees for the HappyMap algorithm, showing convergence and bounding the error under specific assumptions about the "happy mapping" and the function class $C$.
  • New Applications: HappyMap yields new algorithms for:
  • Fair uncertainty quantification (equalized coverage).
  • Target-independent learning beyond statistical estimation, including prediction and uncertainty quantification.
  • A novel approach to analyzing missing data.
  • Unified Understanding: The framework provides a unified understanding of several existing fairness notions and target-independent learning approaches.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Weak Learner Complexity: The paper, like prior work, does not address the computational complexity of the "weak learner" responsible for finding suitable auditor functions $c \in C$. This remains a significant practical challenge.
  • Richness of $C$ vs. Complexity: A richer class $C$ leads to more powerful guarantees but also increases the computational complexity of the weak learner. Understanding this trade-off is an open question.
  • Representation Learning: An interesting future direction is to extend HappyMap to learn low-dimensional representation functions, potentially leveraging pre-training and improving prediction accuracy.
  • Other Invariances: Exploring HappyMap for target-independent learning with other types of invariance, beyond covariate shift, is suggested.
  • Constrained Optimization: The paper hints at extensions of HappyMap for constrained optimization, particularly for scenarios involving statistical parity and equality of false positive/negative rates.

Summary updated

Abstract

Multi-calibration is a powerful and evolving concept originating in the field of algorithmic fairness. For a predictor $f$ that estimates the outcome $y$ given covariates $x$, and for a function class $\mathcal{C}$, multi-calibration requires that the predictor $f(x)$ and outcome $y$ are indistinguishable under the class of auditors in $\mathcal{C}$. Fairness is captured by incorporating demographic subgroups into the class of functions~$\mathcal{C}$. Recent work has shown that, by enriching the class $\mathcal{C}$ to incorporate appropriate propensity re-weighting functions, multi-calibration also yields target-independent learning, wherein a model trained on a source domain performs well on unseen, future, target domains(approximately) captured by the re-weightings. Formally, multi-calibration with respect to $\mathcal{C}$ bounds $\big|\mathbb{E}_{(x,y)\sim \mathcal{D}}[c(f(x),x)\cdot(f(x)-y)]\big|$ for all $c \in \mathcal{C}$. In this work, we view the term $(f(x)-y)$ as just one specific mapping, and explore the power of an enriched class of mappings. We propose \textit{HappyMap}, a generalization of multi-calibration, which yields a wide range of new applications, including a new fairness notion for uncertainty quantification (conformal prediction), a novel technique for conformal prediction under covariate shift, and a different approach to analyzing missing data, while also yielding a unified understanding of several existing seemingly disparate algorithmic fairness notions and target-independent learning approaches. We give a single \textit{HappyMap} meta-algorithm that captures all these results, together with a sufficiency condition for its success.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{deng2023happymap,
  author = {Zhun Deng and Cynthia Dwork and Linjun Zhang},
  title = {{HappyMap : A Generalized Multicalibration Method}},
  booktitle = {ITCS},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.4230/lipics.itcs.2023.41},
}
Figure