Abstract
Cellular operators are continuously densifying their networks to cope with the ever-increasing capacity demand. Furthermore, an extreme densification phase for cellular networks is foreseen to fulfill the ambitious fifth generation (5G) performance requirements. Network densification improves spectrum utilization and network capacity by shrinking base stations' (BSs) footprints and reusing the same spectrum more frequently over the spatial domain. However, network densification also increases the handover (HO) rate, which may diminish the capacity gains for mobile users due to HO delays. In highly dense 5G cellular networks, HO delays may neutralize or even negate the gains offered by network densification. In this paper, we present an analytical paradigm, based on stochastic geometry, to quantify the effect of HO delay on the average user rate in cellular networks. To this end, we propose a flexible handover scheme to reduce HO delay in case of highly dense cellular networks. This scheme allows skipping the HO procedure with some BSs along users' trajectories. The performance evaluation and testing of this scheme for only single HO skipping shows considerable gains in many practical scenarios.
The Densification Paradox
To meet the massive capacity demands of 5G, cellular operators are "densifying" networks by deploying a high concentration of small base stations (BSs). While this improves spectrum reuse and theoretical capacity, it creates a significant challenge for mobile users known as the "densification paradox."
As a user moves through a dense network, they must constantly perform a handover (HO) to the nearest BS to maintain the best signal quality. Each handover involves complex signaling between the user, the BSs, and the core network, introducing a time delay ($d$) during which no data is transmitted. In a very dense network, a high-speed user might spend so much time performing handovers that their actual throughput drops, even if the theoretical signal strength is high. This research seeks to quantify this effect and proposes a novel strategy to mitigate it.
The Handover Skipping Strategy
The authors propose a flexible HO Skipping Scheme to address the overhead of frequent switching. In this scheme, a user connects to their best BS but then intentionally "skips" the next optimal BS along their trajectory, remaining connected to the previous one for a longer duration. This effectively cuts the number of handovers in half, trading off a temporary decrease in signal quality for a massive reduction in connection overhead.
This strategy introduces a "blackout" period—the time when a user is connected to a farther BS while passing closer to a skipped one. During this time, the skipped BS becomes a strong source of interference. To make this viable, the authors analyze the role of Interference Cancellation (IC), which allows the user's device to mathematically "cancel out" the signal from the skipped BS, maintaining acceptable performance during the blackout state.
Analytical Framework: Stochastic Geometry
To evaluate these trade-offs, the researchers utilized Stochastic Geometry, a mathematical framework that models base station locations as a random pattern (specifically, a Poisson Point Process). This allows for the derivation of closed-form equations for network performance, such as coverage probability and average user rate, without the need for exhaustive site-specific simulations. The analytical results were validated using Monte Carlo simulations, confirming that stationary snapshots of the network accurately capture the performance of mobile users.
Key Results: Throughput and Velocity
The study reveals that the benefits of handover skipping are highly dependent on user mobility and network density. While skipping reduces the average spectral efficiency (due to the blackout periods), the "time saved" from fewer handovers results in a higher net throughput in dense scenarios.
Key findings include:
- Handover Cost Reduction: The single HO skipping scheme reduces the handover delay cost by exactly 50%.
- Mobility Thresholds: In a dense network ($\\lambda = 70$ BS/km²), the skipping scheme begins to outperform the conventional approach once user speeds exceed 40 km/h for high-delay BSs ($d=2s$) or 110 km/h for low-delay BSs ($d=0.7s$).
- The Critical Role of IC: Without Interference Cancellation, the drop in signal quality during the blackout state often outweighs the benefits of reduced delay. IC is essential for making skipping a net positive for throughput.
Conclusion and Future Work
This research demonstrates that being "best-connected" is not always optimal in the context of high-speed mobility and dense 5G infrastructure. By intentionally skipping handovers, networks can significantly improve the experience for mobile users. Future work will look to extend this model to multi-tier heterogeneous networks and explore more complex skipping rules (e.g., skipping multiple BSs) to further optimize performance in the ultra-dense environments of the future.
Summary updated