Abstract
Toehold-mediated strand displacement (TMSD) is a nucleic acid-based reaction wherein an invader strand (I) replaces an incumbent strand (N) in a duplex with a target strand (T). TMSD is driven by toeholds, overhanging single-stranded domains in T recognised by I. Although TMSD is responsible for the outstanding potential of dynamic DNA nanotechnology, TMSD cannot implement templating, the central mechanism by which biological systems generate complex, far-from equilibrium assemblies like RNA or proteins. Therefore, we introduce handhold-mediated strand displacement (HMSD). Handholds are toehold analogues located in N and capable of implementing templating. We measure the kinetics of 98 different HMSD systems to demonstrate that handholds can accelerate the rate of invader-target (IT) binding by more than 4 orders of magnitude. Furthermore, handholds of moderate length accelerate reactions whilst allowing detachment of the product IT from N. We are thus able to experimentally demonstrate the use of HMSD-based templating to produce highly-specific far-from-equilibrium DNA duplexes.
Introduction
In dynamic DNA nanotechnology, Toehold-Mediated Strand Displacement (TMSD) serves as the fundamental building block for molecular circuits and reconfigurable structures. In a standard TMSD reaction, an "invader" strand (I) displaces an "incumbent" strand (N) from a "target" strand (T). This process is initiated by a "toehold"—a short, single-stranded recognition site on the target.
However, TMSD faces a significant limitation: the toehold remains part of the final product. Because the invader remains bound to the recognition site, the system inevitably reaches a thermodynamic equilibrium. In contrast, biological systems like transcription use templates to catalyze the formation of products (e.g., RNA) that subsequently detach. This "template-and-release" mechanism allows biology to maintain far-from-equilibrium states. To replicate this behavior synthetically, we developed Handhold-Mediated Strand Displacement (HMSD).
The HMSD Mechanism
The core innovation of HMSD is the relocation of the recognition domain—termed the "handhold" (h)—from the target strand (T) to the incumbent strand (N). This shift ensures that the interaction between the template and the product is inherently transient.
As shown in the mechanism above, the invader binds to the handhold on N, forming a transient three-stranded intermediate. This proximity facilitates the displacement of N by I. Once displacement is complete, the handhold interaction is the only remaining link between the product and the template; if the handhold is sufficiently short, it spontaneously detaches.
Experimental Characterization
To map the kinetic landscape of this new mechanism, we characterized 98 distinct HMSD systems. We systematically varied the lengths of the handholds (0–20 nucleotides) and proximal toeholds (0–7 nucleotides). Reaction rates were monitored using bulk fluorescence spectroscopy with specialized reporter duplexes (RQ) that provide a signal upon successful displacement and release.
We developed an Ordinary Differential Equation (ODE) model to extract rate constants for binding ($k_b$), detachment ($k_d$), and displacement ($k_m$). This allowed us to identify three distinct kinetic regimes: first-order, and second-order reversible or irreversible reactions.
Key Results
Our experimental data confirms that HMSD provides massive kinetic control over DNA assembly. We observed accelerations in invader-target binding of more than four orders of magnitude (>10,000x) compared to reactions lacking a handhold.
A critical finding is the existence of a "Goldilocks" handhold length. Handholds of approximately 8 nucleotides provide optimal kinetic acceleration while maintaining high release efficiency; for handholds shorter than 9 nucleotides, over 99% of products successfully detached from the template. Furthermore, we demonstrated selective templating, where a specific template could preferentially produce one of three thermodynamically similar duplexes from a mixture, proving that HMSD can drive systems toward specific far-from-equilibrium states.
Conclusion and Future Outlook
HMSD successfully bridges the gap between synthetic DNA strand displacement and biological templating. By placing recognition sites on the leaving strand, we enable the autonomous production and release of molecular assemblies. While this study establishes the principle using single-step displacement, future work will focus on creating true catalytic cycles where a single template can repeatedly generate multiple products, moving closer to the complexity of natural molecular machines like RNA polymerase.
Summary updated