H$_{2}$-H$_{2}$O demixing in Uranus and Neptune: Adiabatic structure models

Marina Cano Amoros, Nadine Nettelmann, Nicola Tosi, Philipp Baumeister, H. Rauer

Abstract

Demixing properties of planetary major constituents influence the interior structure and evolution of planets. Comparing experimental and computational data on the miscibility of hydrogen and water to adiabatic profiles suggests phase separation between these components occurs in the ice giants Uranus and Neptune. We aim to predict the atmospheric water abundance and transition pressure between the water-poor outer envelope and the water-rich deep interior in Uranus and Neptune. We construct seven H2-H2O phase diagrams from the available experimental and computational data. We compute interior adiabatic structure models and compare these to the phase diagrams to infer whether demixing is occurring. We obtain a strong water depletion in the top layer due to rain-out of water and find upper limits on the atmospheric water mass fraction Z_atm of 0.21 for Uranus and 0.16 for Neptune. The transition from the water-poor to the water-rich layer is sharp and occurs at pressures P_Z between 4 and 11 GPa. Using these constraints on Z_atm and P_Z, we find that the observed gravitational harmonics J2 and J4 can be reproduced if P_Z > 10 GPa in Uranus and > 5 GPa in Neptune, and if the deep interior has a high primordial water mass fraction of 0.8, unless rocks are also present. These findings confirm classical few-layer models and suggest that a layered structure may result from a combination of primordial mass accretion and subsequent phase separation.

Introduction: The Mystery of Ice Giant Interiors

Uranus and Neptune, the solar system's "ice giants," possess internal structures that remain largely enigmatic. Unlike the gas giants Jupiter and Saturn, which are mostly hydrogen and helium, these planets are thought to be rich in "ices" like water, methane, and ammonia. A fundamental question in planetary science is whether these materials are well-mixed or separated into distinct layers.

While standard models often assume a three-layer structure (a gas envelope, an icy mantle, and a rocky core), a robust physical mechanism for maintaining such separation over billions of years has been lacking. This research investigates immiscibility: the phenomenon where hydrogen ($H_2$) and water ($H_2O$) simply refuse to mix at specific temperatures and pressures, leading to a natural "rain-out" of water that shapes the planet's interior.

Schematic representation of the interior structure of an ice giant, showing the H2-H2O immiscibility layer and the resulting water rain-out into a water-rich deep interior.

Methodology: Mapping the Phase Space

The study employs a multi-step approach to model the planetary interiors by combining experimental laboratory data with advanced computer simulations to map out the phase diagrams of $H_2-H_2O$ mixtures.

  1. Phase Diagram Construction: The researchers synthesized seven distinct $H_2-H_2O$ phase diagrams using data from high-pressure diamond anvil cell experiments and Density Functional Theory (DFT) simulations.
  2. Adiabatic Modeling: Using a 1D interior structure code called TATOOINE, they calculated "adiabats"—temperature-pressure profiles that assume the planet's interior is churning via convection.
  3. Equilibrium Calculation: By comparing the adiabats to the phase diagrams, they determined where water would condense and sink.
  4. Gravity Field Matching: Finally, they used the MOGROP code to calculate the expected gravitational harmonics ($J_2$ and $J_4$) and compared them to real-world data collected by the Voyager 2 spacecraft.
Comparison of experimental and computational data points for H2-H2O mixing and demixing from various studies, used to construct the phase diagrams for the interior models.

Key Insights: The Mechanics of Stratification

The comparison between adiabatic profiles and phase diagrams reveals several critical features of ice giant interiors:

  • Sharp Compositional Boundaries: Unlike some chemical gradients that might be gradual, $H_2-H_2O$ demixing creates a very sharp boundary. Once the pressure hits a critical point (the "transition pressure"), water droplets form and sink rapidly, leaving a water-depleted envelope behind.
  • Atmospheric "Dryness": The models suggest that the upper atmospheres of these planets are significantly drier than their deep interiors. This "rain-out" provides a physical justification for the low metallicity observed in the outer envelopes of ice giant models.
  • The Role of Rocks: To match the observed gravity data ($J_4$), the models work best if rocks (silicates) are not just in a central core but are also present in the deep water-rich layer, potentially forming "silicate clouds" at temperatures around 2000 K.

Key Results

The study establishes specific physical constraints for Uranus and Neptune:

  • Water Limits: Upper limits for the atmospheric water mass fraction ($Z_{atm}$) are 0.21 for Uranus and 0.16 for Neptune.
  • Transition Pressures: The boundary between the water-poor envelope and water-rich interior occurs at pressures ($P_Z$) between 4 and 11 GPa.
  • Gravity Fit: To match Voyager 2's gravity observations, the transition must be relatively deep: $P_Z \gtrsim 10$ GPa for Uranus and $\gtrsim 5$ GPa for Neptune.

Conclusion and Future Work

The primary hurdle remains observational uncertainty. Our best gravity data for these planets comes from single flybys in the 1980s, and the "wind contribution" to the gravity field is poorly constrained.

The authors emphasize the need for a dedicated mission, such as the proposed Uranus Orbiter and Probe (UOP). An atmospheric probe could measure the actual water abundance ($Z_{atm}$) directly, providing a "ground truth" to validate these phase separation models. Additionally, future work must investigate more complex mixtures involving helium, methane, and ammonia, as multi-component mixing may behave differently than the pure $H_2-H_2O$ system.

Summary updated

Abstract

Demixing properties of planetary major constituents influence the interior structure and evolution of planets. Comparing experimental and computational data on the miscibility of hydrogen and water to adiabatic profiles suggests phase separation between these components occurs in the ice giants Uranus and Neptune. We aim to predict the atmospheric water abundance and transition pressure between the water-poor outer envelope and the water-rich deep interior in Uranus and Neptune. We construct seven H2-H2O phase diagrams from the available experimental and computational data. We compute interior adiabatic structure models and compare these to the phase diagrams to infer whether demixing is occurring. We obtain a strong water depletion in the top layer due to rain-out of water and find upper limits on the atmospheric water mass fraction Z_atm of 0.21 for Uranus and 0.16 for Neptune. The transition from the water-poor to the water-rich layer is sharp and occurs at pressures P_Z between 4 and 11 GPa. Using these constraints on Z_atm and P_Z, we find that the observed gravitational harmonics J2 and J4 can be reproduced if P_Z > 10 GPa in Uranus and > 5 GPa in Neptune, and if the deep interior has a high primordial water mass fraction of 0.8, unless rocks are also present. The agreement with J4 is improved if rocks are confined deeper than P_Z, for instance below a rock cloud level at 2000 K (20-30 GPa). These findings confirm classical few-layer models and suggest that a layered structure may result from a combination of primordial mass accretion and subsequent phase separation. Reduced observational uncertainty in J4 and its dynamic contribution, atmospheric water abundance measurements from an Orbiter with a Probe mission to Uranus (UOP) or Neptune, and better understanding of the mixing behaviour of constituents are needed to constrain the interiors of ice giants.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{amoros2024h,
  author = {Marina Cano Amoros and Nadine Nettelmann and Nicola Tosi and Philipp Baumeister and H. Rauer},
  title = {{H$\_\{2\}$-H$\_\{2\}$O demixing in Uranus and Neptune: Adiabatic structure models}},
  booktitle = {Astronomy},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1051/0004-6361/202452148},
}

Loading related content...

Figure