Gravitational Waves Produced by Domain Walls During Inflation

Haipeng An, Yang ChenarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

This paper, recently published by Haipeng An and Chen Yang from Tsinghua and Peking Universities, explores a novel mechanism for generating a stochastic gravitational wave background (SGWB) during the universe's earliest moments. By looking at domain walls (DWs) formed during inflation rather than after it, the authors uncover a signal that could be the "smoking gun" for high-energy physics near the Planck scale.

TL;DR

Domain walls created during cosmic inflation—even if they don't form a collapsing network—generate a detectable gravitational wave background because the rapid expansion of space breaks time-translation symmetry. This signal can explain recent pulsar timing array (PTA) observations and offers a unique way to probe the universe's evolution between the end of inflation and the start of the Big Bang nucleosynthesis.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cosmologists have long studied domain walls—2D topological defects that form when a discrete symmetry is spontaneously broken (think of the boundaries between different magnetic domains in a fridge magnet). Usually, researchers look at DW networks that form after inflation during the Radiation Domination (RD) era. However, these models face a "Goldilocks" problem: if the walls disappear too early, their signal is too weak to detect; if they last too long, they contain so much energy they would "overclose" the universe, contradicting our observations.

This paper shifts the timeline. What if these walls formed during inflation? In a static or flat universe, a stationary wall wouldn't radiate gravitational waves (GWs) because of energy conservation. But inflation is different. The rapid expansion of the Hubble scale means that even "comovingly static" sources—objects that aren't moving relative to the expanding grid of space—can produce GWs. The authors set out to model this process and determine if the resulting signal is actually reachable by our current and future detectors.

Methods

The researchers employed a mix of theoretical derivation and high-resolution numerical simulations:

  • Model: They used a "spectator sector" (a field that exists alongside the inflaton but doesn't drive inflation itself) with a Landau-Ginzburg type potential to trigger a second-order phase transition.
  • Lattice Simulation: They performed 3D numerical simulations on a massive $1000 \times 1000 \times 1000$ lattice. This allowed them to track the "tachyonic growth" (rapid, unstable growth) of the field as it formed domain walls.
  • GW Calculation: Using a Green’s function method, they calculated the tensor perturbations (GWs) produced by the energy-momentum tensor of these walls.
  • Kibble-Zurek Mechanism: They used this standard framework to describe how the size and density of the topological defects relate to the speed of the phase transition.

Datasets

As a theoretical physics paper, it does not use external training datasets. Instead, it generates its own data through lattice simulations. The results are evaluated against the sensitivity curves of several major GW experiments:

  • PTAs: NANOGrav, EPTA, PPTA, and the future SKA.
  • Space-based Interferometers: LISA, Taiji, Tianqin, BBO, and DECIGO.
  • Terrestrial Detectors: Einstein Telescope (ET) and Cosmic Explorer (CE).
  • CMB Experiments: BICEP/KECK (for B-mode polarization).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Symmetry Breaking as a Source: The "aha moment" is that the violation of time-translation symmetry during inflation allows static sources to radiate. This bypasses the need for complex, high-velocity wall collisions typically required in post-inflation models.
  • The "Frozen" Signal: After a few e-folds (exponential doublings of the universe's size), Hubble friction effectively freezes the domain wall configuration. The GW production stops shortly after, meaning the signal is a "snapshot" of that specific era.
  • Post-Inflation "Memory": The peak of the GW spectrum is determined by the wall thickness and the Hubble scale during inflation. However, the slope of the spectrum after the peak changes depending on whether the universe went through an era of "kination" (kinetic energy dominance) or "matter domination" before reheating. This makes the SGWB a probe of the "dark ages" of the early universe.
  • Explaining NANOGrav: The authors found that if the phase transition happened about 40 e-folds before the end of inflation, the signal perfectly matches the "common noise" recently reported by Pulsar Timing Arrays like NANOGrav.

Key Results

  • Empirical Formula: The authors derived a semi-analytical formula for the peak strength of the SGWB ($\Omega_{GW}^{peak}$), showing it is proportional to the square of the energy density change ($\Delta\rho/\rho_{inf}$) and the square of the Hubble scale ($H$).
  • Spectral Shape: The spectrum follows a $k^3$ power law in the far infrared, transitions to $k^1$ near the peak, and decays as $k^{-4}$ in the ultraviolet.
  • Detectability:
    • If the transition occurred 60 e-folds before the end of inflation, it leaves a signature in the CMB B-mode spectrum detectable by CMB-S4.
  • If it occurred 40 e-folds before, it explains the PTA signals.
  • If it occurred 10–25 e-folds before, it falls right into the sweet spot for LISA, ET, and CE.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their model assumes the domain walls decay quickly enough after inflation so they don't dominate the universe's energy budget later. They also note that the interaction between the spectator field and the inflaton could lead to "back-reaction" effects, potentially producing primordial black holes—a fascinating avenue for future research. Additionally, the study assumes a specific type of phase transition; exploring different potentials or "warm inflation" scenarios remains an open task.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study the properties of the stochastic gravitational wave background (SGWB) produced by domain walls (DWs) during inflation without forming a network. We numerically simulate the DW production caused by a second-order phase transition and calculate the SGWB spectrum using a $1000\times1000\times1000$ lattice. We show that the SGWB can be observed directly by future terrestrial and spatial gravitational wave detectors and through the B-mode spectrum in CMB. This signal can also explain the common noise process observed by pulsar timing array experiments. With numerical simulations, we derive an empirical formula for the strength and qualitative features of the SGWB spectrum. The details of the SGWB spectrum also contain information about the later evolution of the universe.
BibTeX
@misc{an2023gravitational,
  author = {Haipeng An and Yang Chen},
  title = {{Gravitational Waves Produced by Domain Walls During Inflation}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2304.02361},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02361},
}

Loading related content...

Figure