Graphene Coating of Nafion Membranes for Enhanced Fuel Cell Performance

Jasper Ruhkopf, Ulrich Plachetka, Michael Moeller, Oliver Pasdag, Ivan Radev, Volker Peinecke, Marco Hepp, Christian Wiktor, Martin R. Lohe, Xinliang Feng, Benjamin Butz, Max C. Lemme

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a novel method to enhance fuel cell performance by spray-coating Nafion membranes with electrochemically exfoliated graphene. This graphene layer acts as a selective barrier, significantly reducing fuel crossover and leading to a nearly four-fold increase in power density for direct methanol fuel cells (DMFCs), making them more suitable for portable applications.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Direct methanol fuel cells (DMFCs) hold promise for portable power applications due to their high energy density. However, their widespread adoption is hindered by several challenges, primarily related to the membrane material. State-of-the-art membranes, typically made of perfluorosulfonic acid (PFSA) like Nafion, suffer from poor selectivity. This means that fuel molecules (like methanol) can "crossover" from the anode to the cathode side, leading to parasitic reactions that reduce efficiency, lower voltage, decrease power density, and degrade the cell over time. While thicker membranes can reduce crossover, they also impede proton conductivity, thus limiting overall performance. The ideal membrane would block fuel crossover while maintaining high proton conductivity, a balance that has been difficult to achieve.

Methods

The core innovation in this work is the application of electrochemically exfoliated graphene (e-G) as a thin, selective barrier layer onto Nafion membranes. This was achieved through a facile and scalable spray-coating technique using aqueous dispersions of e-G. The researchers systematically varied graphene flake sizes and loadings to optimize performance.

To characterize the resulting membranes and their performance, a suite of advanced techniques was employed:

  • Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) and Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM): Used for top-view analysis of the graphene coating's morphology, smoothness, and coverage.
  • Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy (STEM) and Electron Energy-Loss Spectroscopy (EELS): Crucial for cross-sectional analysis, confirming the formation of a dense, percolated graphene network and providing detailed chemical information about the layers.
  • Raman Spectroscopy: Used to confirm the graphitic nature of the e-G films.
  • Mass Spectrometry (MS) and Liquid Methanol Sensors (LMS): Employed for ex-situ measurements of hydrogen and methanol permeability through the membranes.
  • Fuel Cell Testing: Polarization curves (I-V curves) were measured in DMFC configurations to evaluate the overall performance, including power density and open circuit potential (OCP), which serves as an indicator of methanol crossover.
  • Electrochemical Impedance Spectroscopy (EIS): Used to measure through-plane proton conductivity.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on experimental characterization and performance testing of fabricated membranes.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Graphene as a Selective Barrier: The study demonstrates that a thin, continuous graphene layer can act as an effective diffusion barrier for methanol and hydrogen without significantly hindering proton transport. This is a crucial step towards overcoming the inherent selectivity limitations of PFSA membranes.
  • Scalable Fabrication: The use of spray-coating for applying the graphene layer is a significant advantage, as it is a simple, inexpensive, and scalable method suitable for industrial manufacturing.
  • Flake Size Matters: The research highlights that larger graphene flakes (around 1 µm) are more effective at reducing methanol permeability compared to smaller flakes (300 nm). This suggests that the geometry and arrangement of the graphene network play a critical role in its barrier properties.
  • Concentration Dependence: The performance benefits of graphene coating are more pronounced at higher methanol concentrations. At low concentrations, proton conductivity is the dominant factor, while at high concentrations, methanol permeability becomes the bottleneck, where the graphene barrier excels.

Key Results

  • Significant Reduction in Fuel Permeability: Graphene-coated Nafion membranes showed a dramatic reduction in hydrogen permeability (up to a factor of 39) and methanol permeability (up to 20 times lower at 5M methanol concentration) compared to bare Nafion.
  • Enhanced DMFC Performance: The maximum power density of DMFCs using graphene-coated Nafion N115 membranes was 3.9 times higher than that of reference membranes (39 mW/cm² vs. 10 mW/cm² at 0.3V and 5M methanol).
  • Improved OCP: Graphene-coated membranes exhibited significantly higher open circuit potentials (OCPs) at 5M methanol concentration, indicating a substantial reduction in methanol crossover.
  • Optimized Loading: A graphene loading of 130 µg cm⁻² with 1 µm flakes provided the best balance of reduced permeability and maintained proton conductivity, leading to superior DMFC performance.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Flaw Impact: While the graphene films were generally dense, the authors acknowledge that individual flaws (pores or inclusions) can exist, and their exact impact on performance is difficult to quantify and beyond the scope of this publication.
  • Long-Term Stability: The paper focuses on initial performance and characterization. Long-term stability and durability of the graphene coating under continuous fuel cell operation, especially at elevated temperatures and varying humidity, would be important for practical applications.
  • Proton Conductivity Trade-off: While the graphene coating aims to minimize losses in proton conductivity, higher loadings can still lead to a progressive reduction. Further optimization to maximize barrier effect while preserving proton conductivity is an ongoing area.
  • Integration into MEAs: The study demonstrates the effectiveness of the coated membranes. Future work could focus on optimizing the integration of these membranes into complete Membrane Electrode Assemblies (MEAs) for commercial fuel cells.
  • Broader Applications: The findings suggest potential for both DMFCs and PEMFCs, and further exploration of their performance in different fuel cell types and operating conditions would be valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

Electrochemically exfoliated graphene (e-G) thin films on Nafion membranes exhibit a selective barrier effect against undesirable fuel crossover. This approach combines the high proton conductivity of state-of-the-art Nafion and the ability of e-G layers to effectively block the transport of methanol and hydrogen. Nafion membranes are coated with aqueous dispersions of e-G on the anode side, making use of a facile and scalable spray process. Scanning transmission electron microscopy and electron energy-loss spectroscopy confirm the formation of a dense percolated graphene flake network, which acts as a diffusion barrier. The maximum power density in direct methanol fuel cell (DMFC) operation with e-G-coated Nafion N115 is 3.9 times higher than that of the Nafion N115 reference (39 vs 10 mW cm<sup>-2</sup>@0.3 V) at a 5M methanol feed concentration. This suggests the application of e-G-coated Nafion membranes for portable DMFCs, where the use of highly concentrated methanol is desirable.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ruhkopf2023graphene,
  author = {Jasper Ruhkopf and Ulrich Plachetka and Michael Moeller and Oliver Pasdag and Ivan Radev and Volker Peinecke and Marco Hepp and Christian Wiktor and Martin R. Lohe and Xinliang Feng and Benjamin Butz and Max C. Lemme},
  title = {{Graphene Coating of Nafion Membranes for Enhanced Fuel Cell Performance}},
  booktitle = {ACS},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1021/acsaenm.2c00234},
}
Figure