Graph reduction with spectral and cut guarantees

Andreas Loukas

Abstract

Can one reduce the size of a graph without significantly altering its basic properties? This paper approaches the graph reduction problem through restricted spectral approximation, a modification of the spectral similarity measure used for graph sparsification. This choice is motivated by the observation that restricted approximation carries strong spectral and cut guarantees and implies approximation results for unsupervised learning problems relying on spectral embeddings. We derive sufficient conditions for a small graph to approximate a larger one and introduce nearly-linear algorithms that find coarse graphs of improved quality, often by a large margin, without sacrificing speed.

Introduction

As datasets grow, graphs with millions of nodes become computationally expensive to process. Researchers often use graph reduction—specifically coarsening—to simplify these structures for tasks like graph partitioning, visualization, and accelerating Graph Neural Networks (GNNs). While graph sparsification (removing edges) has a rich theoretical foundation, graph coarsening (merging vertices) has historically relied on heuristics. This paper bridges that gap, moving coarsening from an intuitive art to a rigorous science.

Restricted Spectral Approximation

The author, Andreas Loukas, approaches the problem through a new lens called restricted spectral approximation. Standard spectral similarity requires two graphs to behave similarly across all possible signals. This is impossible when reducing the number of vertices. Instead, Loukas requires the graphs to be similar only within a specific subspace, typically the low-frequency principal eigenspace.

Illustration of a graph $G$ partitioned into sets $\mathcal{V}_0^{(i)}$ for coarsening.

The paper defines Laplacian consistent coarsening, where the coarse graph remains a valid combinatorial Laplacian. This ensures the reduced graph is still interpretable as a graph.

Local Variation Algorithms

To make this practical, the paper introduces greedy algorithms that minimize a "local variation cost" ($\sigma$). Instead of global optimization, they make local decisions:

  • Edge-based: Merges pairs of adjacent vertices.
  • Neighborhood-based: Merges a vertex with its neighbors.
The resulting coarse graph $G'$ after merging nodes from the original graph.

Crucially, the paper proves a decoupling argument: the global error of the entire multi-level reduction is bounded by the sum of these local variation costs. Furthermore, every level of reduction strives to preserve the properties of the original graph, preventing error accumulation over many levels.

Experimental Results

The algorithms were evaluated on four representative graphs: Yeast (protein interaction), Airfoil (finite-element), Minnesota (road network), and Bunny (3D point cloud).

Key findings include:

  • High Fidelity: Graph size could be reduced by 70% while keeping the approximation error ($\epsilon$) below 1.
  • Superior Accuracy: The proposed "local variation" methods achieved 2.6x to 3.9x smaller error than leading alternatives like Heavy Edge Matching or Kron Reduction.
  • Efficiency: The algorithms scale nearly-linearly with the number of edges, making them competitive with fast heuristics.

Conclusion

This work provides a massive leap forward in the theoretical understanding of graph coarsening. While finding the absolute optimal coarsening is NP-hard, the proposed greedy algorithms provide excellent approximations with provable guarantees. Future work will explore definitive ways to calculate optimal reduction ratios and derive even stronger, explicit cut guarantees.

Summary updated

Abstract

Can one reduce the size of a graph without significantly altering its basic properties? The graph reduction problem is hereby approached from the perspective of restricted spectral approximation, a modification of the spectral similarity measure used for graph sparsification. This choice is motivated by the observation that restricted approximation carries strong spectral and cut guarantees, and that it implies approximation results for unsupervised learning problems relying on spectral embeddings. The paper then focuses on coarsening---the most common type of graph reduction. Sufficient conditions are derived for a small graph to approximate a larger one in the sense of restricted similarity. These findings give rise to nearly-linear algorithms that, compared to both standard and advanced graph reduction methods, find coarse graphs of improved quality, often by a large margin, without sacrificing speed.
BibTeX
@article{loukas2019graph,
  author = {Andreas Loukas},
  title = {{Graph reduction with spectral and cut guarantees}},
  journal = {J. Mach. Learn. Res.},
  year = {2019},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=Ds_UrT0SCZj},
}
Figure