Graph convolutional networks for drug response prediction

Tuan Nguyen, Giang T.t. Nguyen, Thin Nguyen, Duc‐Hau Le

TL;DR

This paper introduces GraphDRP, a novel deep learning model that represents drugs as molecular graphs to predict their response in cell lines. By moving beyond string-based drug representations, GraphDRP achieves superior prediction accuracy and offers interpretable insights into which genomic aberrations in cell lines contribute most to drug response.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Personalized medicine aims to match the right drug to the right patient at the right time. A crucial step in this is predicting how a patient (or in this case, a cell line representing a patient's biological characteristics) will respond to a specific drug. While many machine learning methods, particularly deep learning, have been developed for this, they often represent drugs as simple strings (like SMILES). This approach fails to capture the rich structural information inherent in drug molecules, potentially limiting prediction accuracy. Furthermore, these "black box" models often lack interpretability, making it difficult to understand why a particular prediction was made, which is vital for clinical trust and further research.

Methods

The core innovation of GraphDRP lies in its representation of drugs. Instead of using SMILES strings, drugs are converted into molecular graphs. In these graphs, atoms are nodes and chemical bonds are edges, directly reflecting the drug's structure. Graph Convolutional Networks (GCNs), along with three other variants (GAT, GIN, and a GAT&GCN combination), are employed to learn meaningful features from these drug graphs. For cell lines, the paper uses a binary vector representing genomic aberrations (mutations and copy number alterations). These cell-line features are processed by 1D convolutional layers. The learned drug and cell-line representations are then concatenated and fed into fully-connected layers to predict the drug response (specifically, IC50 values). A key aspect for interpretability is the use of saliency maps, which highlight the contribution of individual genomic aberrations to the predicted drug response.

Datasets

The study primarily utilizes the Genomics of Drug Sensitivity in Cancer (GDSC) dataset, version 6.0. This dataset contains drug sensitivity data (IC50 values) for numerous drugs across thousands of cell lines, along with their genomic aberration information. The Cancer Cell Line Encyclopedia (CCLE) and NCI60 datasets are also mentioned as sources for similar data. The authors preprocessed the GDSC data, resulting in 223 drugs and 948 cell lines, with a total of 172,114 drug-cell line pairs for analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Graphs are better than strings for drugs: Representing drugs as molecular graphs, which inherently capture structural information, significantly improves drug response prediction compared to using string-based representations.
  • Interpretability is achievable: The use of saliency maps allows researchers to identify specific genomic aberrations in cell lines that are most influential in determining a drug's effectiveness, moving beyond the "black box" nature of many deep learning models.
  • GIN shows promise for drug representation: Among the graph neural network variants tested, the Graph Isomorphism Network (GIN) demonstrated strong performance, particularly in predicting responses for unseen cell lines.
  • Unseen drugs are harder to predict: The model's performance drops when predicting responses for drugs not encountered during training, highlighting a significant challenge in drug discovery and personalized medicine.

Key Results

GraphDRP consistently outperformed the baseline method, tCNNS, across all experiments and performance metrics (RMSE and Pearson correlation coefficient).

  • Mixed Test: GraphDRP achieved better RMSE and CCp than tCNNS. The GIN variant achieved the best RMSE (0.0243), and the GCN_GAT variant achieved the best CCp (0.9308).
  • Blind Test (Unseen Drugs): While performance decreased, GraphDRP models still showed better RMSE than tCNNS. The GCN model achieved the best RMSE (0.0542), and the GCN-based model was the best for both CCp and RMSE in this experiment.
  • Blind Test (Unseen Cell Lines): GIN achieved the best CCp (0.8460) and RMSE (0.0358). Interestingly, predicting for unseen cell lines generally yielded better results than for unseen drugs.
  • Interpretability: Saliency maps successfully identified known and plausible genomic aberrations contributing to drug sensitivity for specific drugs (e.g., TP53 mutation for Bortezomib).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that predicting responses for unseen drugs is more challenging than for unseen cell lines. They also note that the GDSC dataset only measures drug toxicity at a single concentration, which might not fully capture a drug's therapeutic potential.

Future work suggested includes:

  • Exploring other omics data: Incorporating additional data types like gene expression could further enhance prediction accuracy.
  • Tissue-specific analysis: Investigating how performance varies when cell lines are grouped by tissue type, considering that cell lines from the same tissue share genetic similarities.
  • Beyond IC50: While this study focused on IC50, future work could explore other response measures and drug properties.
  • Improving unseen drug prediction: Developing strategies to better handle novel drugs not present in the training data.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Background Drug response prediction is an important problem in computational personalized medicine. Many machine-learning-based methods, especially deep learning-based ones, have been proposed for this task. However, these methods often represent the drugs as strings, which are not a natural way to depict molecules. Also, interpretation (e.g., what are the mutation or copy number aberration contributing to the drug response) has not been considered thoroughly. Methods In this study, we propose a novel method, GraphDRP, based on graph convolutional network for the problem. In GraphDRP, drugs were represented in molecular graphs directly capturing the bonds among atoms, meanwhile cell lines were depicted as binary vectors of genomic aberrations. Representative features of drugs and cell lines were learned by convolution layers, then combined to represent for each drug-cell line pair. Finally, the response value of each drug-cell line pair was predicted by a fully-connected neural network. Four variants of graph convolutional networks were used for learning the features of drugs. Results We found that GraphDRP outperforms tCNNS in all performance measures for all experiments. Also, through saliency maps of the resulting GraphDRP models, we discovered the contribution of the genomic aberrations to the responses. Conclusion Representing drugs as graphs can improve the performance of drug response prediction. Availability of data and materials Data and source code can be downloaded at https://github.com/hauldhut/GraphDRP .
BibTeX
@article{nguyen2022graph,
  author = {Tuan Nguyen and Giang T.T. Nguyen and Thin Nguyen and Duc‐Hau Le},
  title = {{Graph convolutional networks for drug response prediction}},
  journal = {IEEE ACM Trans. Comput. Biol. Bioinform.},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1109/tcbb.2021.3060430},
}
Figure