GPRInvNet: Deep Learning-Based Ground-Penetrating Radar Data Inversion for Tunnel Linings

Bin Liu, Yuxiao Ren, Hanchi Liu, Hui Xu, Zhengfang Wang, Anthony G. Cohn, Peng Jiang

TL;DR

This paper introduces GPRInvNet, a novel deep learning architecture designed to accurately invert ground-penetrating radar (GPR) B-scan data into detailed permittivity maps of subsurface structures, specifically for tunnel linings. By uniquely processing GPR data trace-by-trace and leveraging adjacent trace information, GPRInvNet significantly improves the reconstruction of complex tunnel lining defects, outperforming existing methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Inspecting tunnel linings for defects is crucial for safety, but GPR data can be complex and challenging to interpret. Defects in tunnel linings, such as voids, cracks, and delamination, often have irregular shapes and can be obscured by rebars within the lining. Traditional GPR inversion methods struggle with these complexities, leading to inaccurate defect localization and characterization, and are computationally expensive. Existing deep learning approaches, while promising, are often designed for spatially aligned data and don't fully leverage the unique characteristics of GPR signals, particularly the importance of adjacent trace information for subsurface imaging. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a deep learning model specifically tailored for GPR data inversion, capable of handling complex defect geometries and improving spatial accuracy.

Methods

The core contribution is the GPRInvNet, a deep neural network with a novel "trace-to-trace" encoder-decoder architecture.

  • Trace-to-Trace Encoder: This is the key innovation. Instead of processing the entire B-scan as a single image, the encoder processes each GPR trace individually. It uses convolutional layers to extract features from each trace while simultaneously incorporating information from adjacent traces. This is crucial because GPR signals from a subsurface anomaly tend to be spread across several adjacent traces. The encoder then uses fully connected layers to condense these features for each trace, creating "sensitive zones" that spatially correspond to specific regions in the permittivity map. This approach ensures that spatial alignment between the input GPR data and the output permittivity map is maintained.
  • Decoder: A conventional decoder, similar to those used in previous deep learning inversion models, is employed to reconstruct the permittivity map from the encoded features.
  • Loss Function: A combination of L2 norm and multi-scale structural similarity (MSSIM) is used to minimize the difference between the predicted and ground truth permittivity maps, optimizing for both pixel-level accuracy and structural similarity.

Datasets

  • Synthetic Data: A large synthetic dataset of 432,000 data pairs was generated to train and validate the GPRInvNet. This dataset included various tunnel lining defects (voids, cracks, delamination, non-compactness) with different media (air, water), and the presence of rebars.
  • Real Data Augmentation: To generalize the model to real-world GPR data, a method was developed where background noise patches from real GPR scans of a concrete model were added to synthetic B-scan data. This augmented dataset was used to retrain the GPRInvNet.
  • Experimental Model Data: A physical concrete model was constructed with known defects (rebars, cracks, voids) and used to collect real GPR data for testing.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Leveraging Adjacent Traces is Crucial for GPR: The paper strongly emphasizes that GPR signals are spatially distributed, and effectively using information from neighboring traces is key to accurately reconstructing subsurface structures. This is a departure from methods that might treat each trace independently or rely solely on global context.
  • "Trace-to-Trace" Processing Preserves Spatial Alignment: The novel encoder design directly addresses the challenge of spatial misalignment between GPR B-scans and permittivity maps, a common issue in deep learning inversion. By processing and condensing features trace-by-trace, the model maintains this critical spatial correspondence.
  • DNNs Can Outperform Physics-Based Methods for Complex Defects: The results demonstrate that GPRInvNet, a data-driven approach, can achieve superior results compared to traditional physics-based methods like Full-Waveform Inversion (FWI), especially for complex and irregular defects, and even when rebars are present.
  • Data Augmentation with Real Noise Improves Generalization: The strategy of incorporating real background noise into synthetic training data proved effective in making the model more robust and applicable to real-world GPR data, which is inherently noisier and more complex.

Key Results

  • Superior Defect Reconstruction: GPRInvNet consistently outperformed baseline methods (FWI and Enc-Dec) in reconstructing permittivity maps of tunnel linings with complex defects, including those under rebars. The reconstructed defects had clearer boundaries and more accurate shapes.
  • Quantitative Performance: On the test set, GPRInvNet achieved significantly better metrics (MAE, MSE, SSIM, MSSIM) compared to Enc-Dec. For example, MAE was 0.00286 for GPRInvNet versus 0.004895 for Enc-Dec.
  • Accurate Permittivity Values: The inverted permittivity values along cutting lines closely matched the ground truth, with GPRInvNet showing less oscillation and better accuracy, especially for defects under rebars and water-bearing defects.
  • Real-World Applicability: Experiments with real GPR data from a concrete model showed that GPRInvNet, after retraining with augmented data, could effectively reconstruct rebars and defects, demonstrating its practical utility.
  • Computational Efficiency: While training is intensive, the well-trained GPRInvNet can perform inversion at near-real-time speeds (approximately 0.027 seconds per image), a significant advantage over FWI which takes about 60 minutes per scan.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Real-World Complexity: The authors acknowledge that real GPR data is more complex than even the augmented synthetic data, and only rough profiles of defects could be reconstructed in some cases.
  • Field Data Validation: The study did not include validation experiments using actual field data from operational tunnels. This is identified as an area for future research.
  • Resolution Limits: While GPRInvNet shows good resolution, it cannot clearly distinguish targets separated by less than approximately a quarter of the wavelength.
  • Further Research: The authors suggest that future work should focus on addressing these limitations, particularly by incorporating more diverse and complex real-world GPR data for training and validation.

Summary updated

Abstract

A DNN architecture referred to as GPRInvNet was proposed to tackle the challenges of mapping the ground-penetrating radar (GPR) B-Scan data to complex permittivity maps of subsurface structures. The GPRInvNet consisted of a trace-to-trace encoder and a decoder. It was specially designed to take into account the characteristics of GPR inversion when faced with complex GPR B-Scan data, as well as addressing the spatial alignment issues between time-series B-Scan data and spatial permittivity maps. It displayed the ability to fuse features from several adjacent traces on the B-Scan data to enhance each trace, and then further condense the features of each trace separately. As a result, the sensitive zones on the permittivity maps spatially aligned to the enhanced trace could be reconstructed accurately. The GPRInvNet has been utilized to reconstruct the permittivity map of tunnel linings. A diverse range of dielectric models of tunnel linings containing complex defects has been reconstructed using GPRInvNet. The results have demonstrated that the GPRInvNet is capable of effectively reconstructing complex tunnel lining defects with clear boundaries. Comparative results with existing baseline methods also demonstrated the superiority of the GPRInvNet. For the purpose of generalizing the GPRInvNet to real GPR data, some background noise patches recorded from practical model testing were integrated into the synthetic GPR data to retrain the GPRInvNet. The model testing has been conducted for validation, and experimental results revealed that the GPRInvNet had also achieved satisfactory results with regard to the real data.
BibTeX
@article{liu2021gprinvnet,
  author = {Bin Liu and Yuxiao Ren and Hanchi Liu and Hui Xu and Zhengfang Wang and Anthony G. Cohn and Peng Jiang},
  title = {{GPRInvNet: Deep Learning-Based Ground-Penetrating Radar Data Inversion for Tunnel Linings}},
  journal = {IEEE Transactions on Geoscience and Remote Sensing},
  year = {2021},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=VOF2rlrx1T},
}
Figure