Abstract
While Winograd convolutions are known to reduce the computational complexity of convolutional neural networks (CNNs), the more efficient $F_4$ variant (using 4x4 tiles) has historically been avoided due to numerical instability and high hardware overhead. This paper introduces tap-wise quantization, a technique that enables stable 8-bit integer inference for $F_4$ Winograd convolutions. By combining this method with custom, area-efficient hardware transformation engines, the authors demonstrate up to 1.83x end-to-end speedup and 1.85x energy efficiency gains on state-of-the-art computer vision models like UNet and YOLOv3 with negligible accuracy loss.
Introduction
Convolutional neural networks (CNNs) are the foundation of modern computer vision but require immense computational resources. The Winograd algorithm reduces the number of multiplications needed for a convolution. While the widely used $F_2$ version (2x2 tiles) offers a 2.25x reduction in multiplications for 3x3 kernels, the $F_4$ version (4x4 tiles) theoretically offers a much larger 4x reduction.
Despite this potential, $F_4$ has remained impractical for integer hardware due to two primary challenges: numerical instability during 8-bit quantization and the significant hardware area required for data transformations. This work addresses these challenges through a hardware-software co-design approach.
Tap-Wise Quantization
The primary obstacle to using $F_4$ in 8-bit hardware is that the transformation matrices have a wide range of coefficients, leading to wildly different dynamic ranges for different components (or "taps") in the Winograd domain. Standard quantization methods that use a single scaling factor for an entire layer fail to capture this variance, resulting in massive accuracy drops.
To solve this, the authors propose tap-wise quantization. Each tap index in the Winograd domain is quantized independently, allowing the system to adapt to the non-uniform distributions shown in Figure 1.
To maintain hardware simplicity, these scaling factors are restricted to powers-of-two, replacing expensive multiplications with simple bit-shifts. The authors utilize a training flow involving a straight-through estimator and knowledge distillation—using a high-precision FP32 model as a teacher—to recover accuracy lost during the quantization process.
Hardware Architecture and Co-Design
To mitigate the overhead of Winograd transformations, the researchers developed two specialized hardware modules integrated into a programmable domain-specific accelerator (DSA):
- Row-by-row engine: Optimized for high-throughput input and output transformations by processing spatial rows in parallel.
- Tap-by-tap engine: An area-efficient design that unrolls transformation logic over time, specifically suited for weight transformations where data reuse is high.
These engines occupy only 6.1% of the total AI core area, proving that Winograd support can be added to existing designs with minimal silicon overhead. The integration of these components into the broader AI Core architecture is illustrated in Figure 2.
Experimental Results
The approach was evaluated on standard benchmarks including CIFAR-10 and ImageNet, as well as complex end-to-end models like RetinaNet, YOLOv3, and UNet.
- Accuracy: On ImageNet with ResNet-34, the tap-wise quantized $F_4$ model achieved 72.3% Top-1 accuracy, just 0.3% below the FP32 baseline.
- Performance: The system achieved end-to-end speedups of up to 1.83x for segmentation and detection tasks compared to standard convolution methods.
- Efficiency: The Winograd-enhanced DSA demonstrated up to 1.85x better energy efficiency (Inferences per Joule).
- Comparison: When compared to the industry-standard NVDLA architecture, this approach was 1.5x to 3.3x faster at the same peak throughput due to superior bandwidth management and the efficiency of $F_4$ over $F_2$.
Conclusion
By treating the Winograd domain as a collection of independent taps rather than a monolithic entity, tap-wise quantization overcomes the numerical instability of $F_4$ convolutions. When paired with efficient hardware transformation engines, this method makes high-order Winograd algorithms a viable and highly effective solution for accelerating deep learning inference on the edge.
Summary updated